Effects of Pre-Reading Activities on Senior Secondary Students’ Achievement in Reading Comprehension in North-Central, Nigeria

Citation

Musa, D. D., Jangebe, S. M., Muopshin, J., Muopshin, J., & Yabo, N. U. (2026). Effects of Pre-Reading Activities on Senior Secondary Students’ Achievement in Reading Comprehension in North-Central, Nigeria. International Journal of Research, 13(4), 279–292. https://doi.org/10.26643/ijr/edupub/23

Danjuma Dogara Musa*, Salisu Muhammad Jangebe, Jocelyn Muopshin, Nafisat Umar Yabo.

ddmusadagaske@gmail.com

Department of Language Education, Federal College of Education (Technical) Gusau, Zamfara State, Nigeria

Abstract:

The present study examined the effects of pre-reading activities on senior secondary students’ achievement in reading comprehension in North-Central which comprises Plateau, Benue, Niger, Kwara, Kogi and Nasarawa states. The study adopted the quasi-experimental research design. Specifically, the pre-test post-test non-equivalent comparison group design. The sample size of the study consisted of 103 senior secondary students (SS2) The sample was drawn using simple random and purposive sampling techniques. Reading Comprehension Achievement Test (RCAT). was used to gather data. The Reading Comprehension Achievement Test (RCAT) measured the two reading skills namely the literal and inferential comprehension. The data collected for the study were organized and interpreted using descriptive and inferential statistics. The research questions one to two were answered using the mean and standard deviation. Hypotheses one to two were tested using analysis of covariance (ANCOVA). The findings showed that pre-reading activities motivate and sustain students’ interest in the actual reading activity. They also activate the building of related information in such a way that new information is easily assimilated into learners’ existing fields of knowledge. Though pre-reading activities such as brainstorming, use of picture and predicting play a critical role in the reading comprehension classroom, the study revealed that a significant number of teachers do not use them. The few who do, neither use a variety of them nor use them regularly. The study recommends that curriculum developers and implementers should incorporate appropriate and regular pre-reading activities for assigned texts in the reading comprehension classroom.

Keywords: reading, pre-reading activities, reading comprehension, achievements.

Introduction

Reading comprehension refers to the ability to understand information presented in written form. It is a process of making predictions and confirming predictions. The ability to read and understand is, therefore, essential for academic learning because it is the foundation for success in all academic subjects. It is the essence and goal of reading, since the purpose of all reading is to gather meaning from the printed page. The ultimate goal of reading is for extraction of meaning from what the reader is able to read. It is the ability to read text, process it and understand its meaning.

Background and Statement of the Problem

Reading comprehension is the ability to read, internalize, understand, and interact with the text you are reading. It involves critical thinking and deductive reasoning to make meaning of an entire piece of writing. Reading comprehension skills are essential for students, professionals, and anyone who wants to read for pleasure or information. It’s not just about phonological awareness and reading words aloud; it encapsulates language skills such as grammar (syntax), vocabulary, and semantics, to understand the meaning of texts. You make inferences and form an opinion about the read text. Good reading comprehension involves creating images of the words you just read. Readers make connections to previous knowledge as they enjoy the text. They can comfortably answer comprehension questions and summarize parts of the writing or the entire text.

Without reading, ideas and facts stored up in printed materials and electronic sources cannot be tapped. In view of this, reading is regarded indispensable in education as it promotes cognitive growth (Beard, 2021).

Seeing the important role that English language plays as medium of communication in education in Nigeria, the ability to read and understand texts is central. Reading is one of the four basic skills of English language namely listening, speaking, reading and writing. It is the primary means through which students gain information across various subjects and discipline. It makes students understand and interpret text which helps to enhance their critical thinking. Reading exposes one to new ideas, culture, and perspective and increases one’s understanding of the world (Nwodo, 2019).

Researchers have consistently shown that both teachers and students face numerous challenges in teaching and learning reading comprehension. Many English language teachers in secondary schools lack specialized training in teaching reading strategies. According to Ajide (2020), many teachers rely on outdated methods that focus on literal comprehension and vocabulary drills rather than teaching inferential or evaluative reading skills. Teachers often adopt the read and answer method without guiding students through active reading strategies. Lack of familiarity with scaffolding techniques like prediction, vocabulary pre-teaching, pre-questioning, summarizing and previewing has effect on the students’ performance and achievement. The conventional method

employed by the teachers does not allow the students to employ various skills of reading that will aid their comprehension of the literal, inferential and critical among other skills.

In order to address the challenges of students’ achievement in reading comprehension, the following skills need to be taught systematically and intentionally which are literal comprehension and inferential comprehension.

Literal reading comprehension is an understanding of information and facts that are directly stated in the text. This ability is considered the first and most basic level of comprehending a text. The literal level is the most fundamental part of reading. Without understanding of literal meaning, it will be difficult for the students to answer questions on a passage that requires literal understanding. Inferential reading is the ability to realize the hidden concepts and the unstated relationship between the lines in a text. It is concerned with the ability of students to understand meaning that is not explicitly stated or explained in the text. Critical reading is a process of analysing, interpreting and sometimes evaluating. When students read critically, they use critical thinking skills to question the text. Critical reading helps the reader to have a deep understanding of the passage. It helps the reader to seek knowledge, develop ideas and to reflect on the objectives of the passage.

Most of the studies conducted concentrated on EFL classroom environments and at the tertiary, pre-tertiary, and preschool levels. There exists little current literature on the effects of pre-reading activities on senior secondary students’ achievement in reading comprehension. This study, therefore, purposed tofind out the effects of pre-reading activities on senior secondary students’ achievement in reading comprehension in North-Central, Nigeria.

Aim and Objectives

The aim of this study was to ascertain the effects of pre-reading activities on senior secondary students’ achievement in reading comprehension in North-Central, Nigeria.

RQ1: What is the difference in literal comprehension achievement between treatment and control groups of SS2 students in public secondary schools?

RQ2: What is the difference in inferential comprehension achievement between treatment and control groups of SS2 students in public secondary schools?

Scope of the Study

This research work was restricted to the effect of pre-reading activities on senior secondary students’ achievement in reading comprehension in North-central Nigeria. Pre-reading activities such as brainstorming, pre-questioning, predicting were used to teach reading comprehension to senior secondary students. The variables of interest as contained in the research questions were the ability to answer literal comprehension questions, and identify inferential ideas.

Theoretical Framework

Schema theory was used for the study. The theory was first proposed by Immanuel Kant which was later developed by Sir Frederic Bartle who became the propounder of the theory in 1932 who posits that people’s understanding and remembrance of events is shaped by their expectations or prior knowledge, and that the prior knowledge is presented mentally in some sorts of schematic structures. The profounder observes that when people are asked to repeat a story from memory, they often fill in details which are not included in the original but related to what they have already known based on their cultural background. The proponent identifies means on how to guide the reader in the actual reading comprehension as a process.

Literature Review

Reading comprehension is one of the pillars of the act of reading (Lawal, 2019 Adele, 2021 Asemota, 2018) Obika, 2020)). When a person reads a text he engages in a complex array of cognitive processes. The reader is simultaneously using his awareness and understanding of phonemes, phonics and ability to comprehend or construct meaning from the text. This last component of the act of reading is reading comprehension. It is the most difficult and most important of the three. There are elements that make up the process of reading comprehension. In order to understand a text, the reader must be able to comprehend the vocabulary used in the piece of writing. Reading comprehension is one of the necessary subjects in the primary and secondary levels of education. The readers are expected to drive the real information incorporated by the author, accurately. The fluency and accuracy skills motivate

the children and create the tendency to read more. This provides the basis for the use of pre-reading activities as a strategy to teach reading comprehension to senior secondary students.

Reading comprehension is therefore the purpose of reading and remains an essential part of all learning. Comprehension can be conceptualized as the extraction of relevant knowledge from texts and consists of three elements; the reader, the text, and the purpose of reading. It is the interaction between text, readers, and purpose as well as the use of reading comprehension strategies that increase comprehension. Tompkins (2011) consequently defines reading comprehension as the level of understanding of a text/message. Reading comprehension is the interaction between the written words and the knowledge they elicit from sources outside the text or message. Thus, reading comprehension is a cognitive process that is meant for decoding the meaning embedded in a text in order to understand what the author is communicating to their audience through the message. Without comprehension, reading is reduced to symbols that do not provide the reader with any information, and again, without comprehension, reading is nothing more than tracking symbols on a page with the readers’ eyes and sounding them out (Mahmoud, 2015).

Effects of Pre-Reading Activities on Students ’Reading Comprehension

Pre-reading activities are meant to give students the background knowledge they need in order to better understand a text when they interact with it. They are the activities that pupils are taken through to enable them to acquire skills for actual reading. Therefore, they are designed to prepare beginners for formal reading. Johnson (2010) states that pre-reading activities are a series of activities pupils are exposed to, as a way of preparing them for formal reading. For this reason, they can be viewed as essential tasks that should be carried out to activate learners’ schema and avoid any failures in text comprehension. Pupils familiarize themselves with the subject, vocabulary, or challenging structures in the passage through the use of pre-reading activities. Pre-reading exercises are particularly useful in fostering a love for reading and in introducing important cultural ideas. According to Ping (2014), pre-reading activities are essential to pupils’ later applications in school activities. They are exercises that give pupils the chance to decide whether to read more of a text in order to discover more intriguing ideas from it (Mikatama, 2019), bring about success in pupils’ comprehension (Malikhatul, 2019), has key impacts on reading comprehension.

Pre-reading activities are essential for giving students the fundamental knowledge they need about texts, piquing their interest in reading texts, and keeping them in a reading environment throughout their formal learning stage (Osei, 2016). According to Hasan (2011), students’ schemata can be triggered during the pre-reading phase before the real reading stage, and this can improve their comprehension of written material. It is clear that pre-reading activities are very important in the reading class and have a good impact on pupils. Pre-reading activities, according to (Villanueva, 2022), include a variety of games, comparative picture studies, and picture-storytelling exercises that are typically helpful in assisting children in developing the reading abilities necessary for formal reading. These activities are enabling activities which give young readers the thorough grounding they need to plan activities and understand the reading material (Kim & Quinn, 2013). In this view, pre-reading activities uncover and elicit prior knowledge, and the purpose(s) for reading, and develop a knowledge foundation required for dealing with the content and structure of the contents provided (Maingi, 2018).

Pre-reading activities set up and strengthen students’ foundation for reading materials, demonstrating the critical function pre-reading activities have in strengthening students’ focus and attention on the reading materials they will be reading (Franceschini, 2013). Without a doubt, the activities allow the child to gradually test out his emotional self, calm himself through emotional expression in a range of reading situations, and more easily pick up pre-reading skills (Abdulai, 2014). Pre-reading activities have drawn a lot of attention as the cornerstone techniques for introducing children to reading and maintaining their interest in texts (Maingi, 2018) and by employing these activities, readers are better prepared for the reading activities when they are motivated to read the text, which is a result of pre-reading activities. Additionally, because of their increased confidence, children are better able to complete the activity without expending too much effort, and they are more eager to participate in it. Furthermore, pre-reading activities add excitement to the activity, give the students a reason to read, and give the teacher an opportunity to assess how well the text can be understood with the aid of the activities assigned before/after reading (Osei, 2016). Hence, by providing pre-reading activities, teachers can help learners become successful readers (Dickson, 2022). The application of the pre-reading technique is effective in improving reading comprehension of narrative text (Mujahidah & Ramli, 2019) and increases reading performance.

Pre-reading activities have positive effects on students’ performance in reading comprehension (Rondon & Tomitch, 2020; Asgar, 2016) and can have positive effects on all students whether high-level or low-level, and all learners can benefit from the techniques (Hashemi, 2016). They are motivational (Nahid &Asgar, 2016), and improve students’ comprehension of texts because pre-reading strategies activate students’ prior knowledge and facilitate L2 learners’ comprehension ability of the target text (Al Akremi (2016). Therefore, the wise use of pre-reading techniques is one primary step in ensuring efficient comprehension and a more successful reading (Febriantil. 2022). Based on the forgoing arguments and empirical evidence, the following hypotheses are stated:

H₁: There is no significant difference in literal comprehension achievement between treatment and control groups of SS2 students in public secondary schools H₂: There is no significant difference in inferential comprehension achievement between treatment and control groups of SS2 students in public secondary schools

Importance of Pre-Reading Activities to Students’ Achievement

Pre-reading activities are strategies or exercises designed to prepare students for engaging with a text. These activities offer several advantages, both in terms of enhancing comprehension and fostering interest. Here are the key benefits:

It activates prior knowledge by helping the students connect their existing knowledge and experiences to the new text and makes the reading material more palatable and easier to understand. It Builds vocabulary: It introduces key terms and concepts before encountering them in the text and reduces the cognitive load during reading, allowing students to focus on comprehension.

It establishes purpose by encouraging students to understand why they are reading the text and sets goals, such as identifying specific information, themes, or ideas. It Stimulates Interest by engaging students’ curiosity about the topic and makes them more motivated to read and explore the material.

It promotes predictive thinking in encouraging students to predict contents based on titles, headings, and visuals and develops critical thinking skills by making them actively anticipate what they will learn. It facilitates engagement: It activities like group discussions, brainstorming, or visual analysis, foster collaboration and creates a dynamic learning environment before reading.

It reduces anxiety by familiarizing students with the text’s content or challenges this aspect can make it less intimidating and boosts confidence by preparing them for what lies ahead. It enhances comprehension: It prepares student to navigate the structure and ideas in the text and makes it easier to focus on deeper levels of understanding.

Method and Procedure

Design, Population and Sample

The quasi-experimental research design was used in the current study. Specifically, the study adopted the pre-test post-test nonequivalent comparison group design. The population of this study was all SS2 students in public secondary schools in Karu Local Government Area in Nasarawa State. The population of all the secondary schools in Karu Local Government was one thousand nine hundred, ninety (1990) students. The sample schools for the study consisted of 103 students that were in SS2 at the time of the study in the designated schools.

Instrument

The Reading Comprehension Achievement Test (RCAT) was used to gather data for this study. The RCAT measured the two reading skills namely the literal skill, and inferential skill. The RCAT was adopted and adapted from SSCE English language 1 Examination of June 1992.

Procedure

The pretest was administered for two days. Day one was for testing questions on literal comprehension while day two was used for testing questions on inferential comprehension. A comprehension passage was given and students were asked to answer five questions.

Administration of the Treatment

Treatment was administered by the researcher in two experimental schools. Treatment consisted of reading comprehension achievement test. Students in the experimental group were taught using pre-reading activities while students in the control group were taught using normal school English lessons within the periods. Treatment lasted for the periods of 2 weeks which were delivered two times a week for 40 minutes, or a double period of 80 minutes.

Administration of Post-Test

The researcher administered on the participants in both the experimental and control groups after the treatment. It was administered the same duration of time and day as the pre-test. The text items were as same as the pre-test as students were asked to use 30 minutes to answer the comprehension questions on the passage.

Analyses

The research questions raised for this study were answered using the mean and standard deviation. By this, the significant difference between the experimental and control groups in the pre-test and post-test were determined.

Research Question One

What is the difference between the pre-test and post-test literal comprehension achievement mean scores of SSII students in the experimental and control groups?

To determine the pre-test and post-test literal comprehension achievement mean scores of students in the experimental and control groups, mean and standard deviation were employed as presented in Table1.

Table 1: The Pre-test and Post-test Literal Comprehension Achievement Mean scores of SS II students in the Experimental and Control Groups

Group		Pretest		Posttest
	N	Mean	SD	Mean SD	Mean Gain	𝒙̅-Gain difference
Experimental	49	9.76	1.74	15.24 1.88	5.48	4.60
Control	54	9.91	1.48	10.69 1.06	0.88

Table 1 shows the pre-test and post-test literal comprehension achievement mean scores of SSII students in reading comprehension in the experimental and control groups. The experimental group obtained a pre-test mean score of 9.76 with a standard deviation of 1.74 and a post-test mean score of 15.24 with a standard deviation of 1.88, yielding a mean gain of 5.48 after exposure to pre-reading activities. The control group had a pre-test mean score of 9.91 with a standard deviation of 1.48 and post-test mean score of

10.69 with a standard deviation of 1.06, yielding a mean gain of 0.88 The result indicated that students in the experimental group had a higher mean gain score after exposure to pre-reading activities than those in the control group who were not given treatment. The mean gain difference was 4.60 in favour of the experimental group. This means that pre-reading activities did increase the students’ achievement in reading comprehension.

Research Question Two

What is the difference between the pre-test and post-test inferential comprehension achievement mean scores of SSII students in the experimental and control groups?

To determine the pre-test and post-test inferential comprehension achievement mean scores of students in the experimental and control groups, mean and standard deviation were employed as presented in Table 2.

Table 2: The Pre-test and Post-test Inferential Comprehension Achievement Mean Scores of SS II Students in the Experimental and Control Groups

Group		Pretest		Posttest
	N	Mean	SD	Mean SD	Mean Gain	𝒙̅-Gain difference
Experimental	49	9.78	1.48	16.08 2.52	6.30	4.54
Control	54	9.28	1.76	11.04 0.73	1.76

Table 2 shows the pre-test and post-test inferential comprehension achievement mean scores of SSII students in the experimental and control groups. The experimental group obtained a pre-test mean score of with 9.78 standard deviation of 1.48 and a post-test mean score of 16.08 with a standard deviation of 2.52, yielding a mean gain of 6.30 after exposure to pre-reading activities. The control group had a pre-test mean score of 9.28 with a standard deviation of 1.76 and post-test mean score of 11.04 with a standard deviation of 0.73, yielding a mean gain of 1.76 The result indicated that students in the experimental group had a higher mean gain score after exposure to pre-reading activities than those in the control group who were not given treatment. The mean gain difference was 4.54 in favour of the experimental group. This means that pre-reading activities did increase the students’ achievement in reading comprehension.

Hypotheses Hypothesis One

There is no significant difference between the pre-test and post-test literal comprehension achievement mean scores of SSII students in the experimental and control groups.

Analysis of variance (ANCOVA) was employed in testing the null hypothesis on the pre-test and post-test literal achievement mean score of Secondary School Students in the experimental and control groups. This is presented in Table 3.

Table 3: ANCOVA Result on Pretest and Posttest Literal Comprehension Achievement Mean Scores of SSII Students in the Experimental and Control Groups

Source	Type II Sum of Squares	df	Mean Square	F	Sig.	Partial Squared	Eta
Corrected Model	728.256^a	2	364.128	1053.624	.000	.955
Intercept	53.294	1	53.294	154.210	.000	.607
Achievement	194.150	1	194.150	561.783	.000	.849
Group	564.002	1	564.002	1631.971	.000	.942
Error	34.560	100	.346
Total	17782.000	103
Corrected Total	762.816	102

a. R Squared = .955 (Adjusted R Squared = .954)

The data were subjected to analysis of covariance (ANCOVA) having experimental and control groups to determine if a significant difference exists in the pre-test and post-test literal comprehension achievement mean scores of SS II students in reading comprehension in the experimental and control groups. Table 3 shows that F (1, 100) = 1631.971, P < 0.05. Since the p-value of .000 is less than the 0.05 level of significance, the null hypothesis was rejected. This indicates that, there was a significant effect of pre-reading activities on senior secondary students’ achievement in reading comprehension in the experimental group. The result further reveals an adjusted R squared value of .954 which means that 95.4 percent of the variation in the dependent variable which is students’ literal achievement is explained by variation in the treatment of pre-reading activities while the remaining is due to other factors not included in this study. Hence, we can say that pre-reading activities does improve students’ achievement in reading comprehension.

Hypothesis Two

There is no significant difference between the pre-test and post-test inferential comprehension achievement mean scores of SSII students in the experimental and control groups.

Analysis of covariance (ANCOVA) was employed in testing the null hypothesis on the pre-test and post-test mean scores inferential comprehension achievement of Secondary School Students in the experimental and control groups. This is presented in Table 4.

Table 4: ANCOVA Result on Pretest and Posttest Inferential Comprehension Achievement Mean Scores of SSII Students in the Experimental and Control Groups

Source	Type II Sum of Squares	df	Mean Square	F	Sig.	Partial Squared	Eta
Corrected Model	845.617^a	2	422.808	298.334	.000	.856
Intercept	87.861	1	87.861	61.995	.000	.383
Achievement	191.876	1	191.876	135.388	.000	.575
Group	536.714	1	536.714	378.706	.000	.791
Error	141.723	100	1.417
Total	19584.000	103
Corrected Total	987.340	102

a. R Squared = .856 (Adjusted R Squared = .854)

The data were subjected to analysis of covariance (ANCOVA) having experimental and control groups to determine if a significant difference exists in the pre-test and post-test inferential comprehension achievement mean scores of SS II students in reading comprehension in the experimental and control groups. Table 4 shows that F (1, 100) = 378.706, P < 0.05. Since the p-value of .000 is less than the 0.05 level of significance, the null hypothesis was rejected. This indicates that, there was a significant effect of pre-reading activities on senior secondary students’ achievement in reading comprehension in the experimental group. The result further reveals an adjusted R squared value of .854 which means that 85.4 percent of the variation in the dependent variable which is students’ inferential achievement is explained by variation in the treatment of pre-reading activities while the remaining is due to other factors not included in this study. Hence, we can say that pre-reading activities does improve students’ achievement in reading comprehension.

Discussion

The results from research question one revealed that literal comprehension skill of both control and experimental groups were mostly in the poor category at pretest. After treatment, however, the literal comprehension skill of the experimental group showed significant improvement in the literal comprehension skill of students in the control group. This finding is in consonance with Osei (2016), Nurdima (2018)), who found that pre-reading activities are essential for giving students the fundamental knowledge they need about texts, piquing their interest in reading texts, and keeping them in a reading environment throughout their formal learning stage. Results obtained from research question two showed that both control and experimental groups recorded low scores in inferential comprehension achievement test at pretest as both groups had high percentage of students in poor category. At posttest, the experimental group increased in inferential comprehension skills while the control group did not improve significantly. This finding supports the research of Paul and Christopher (2017) who found out that Inferential skill helps the students to realize the hidden concepts and the unstated relationship between the lines in a text and it is concerned with the ability of students to understand meaning that is not explicitly stated or explained in the text. Result from hypothesis one as presented on table 2 revealed that the experimental group improved in their literal comprehension scores after treatment unlike the control group which did not improve as indicated by the posttest. It means that pre-reading activities had effect on senior secondary students’ achievement in reading comprehension in the experimental group than the control group. Finding from hypothesis two showed that the inferential comprehension achievement scores of the experimental group did significantly better than the control group after posttest when reading a text. Inferential comprehension is higher cognitive level of comprehension and it can only be attained when pre-reading activities are employed This view was corroborated by Naranjo (2021) who opined that; since inferential comprehension requires readers to read between the lines’ It is more challenging comprehension task. The results also agree with the views Agbevivi (2022) and Ramli, (2019) who agree that, comprehension strategies like prior knowledge for text content which are fundamental factors in gaining comprehension should be taught intentionally to learners.

Conclusion

Pre-reading activity is the activity used to elicit students’ prior knowledge to the actual reading material. The activity is intended to provide students with required background knowledge that will be needed to have a better comprehension when they interact with a text. Pre-reading has to do with what a learner brings to the reading which can affect how he/she understands what he reads. Pre-reading activities is, therefore, an effective strategy of teaching reading comprehension because of its gains it yielded to students in the experimental group. This study has established the fact that pre-reading activities have significant effects on students’ reading comprehension achievement. When the right strategy and activity are employed to teach reading comprehension among students, the number of failures would be reduced drastically. Based on the significant gains recorded by the experimental group at posttest as compared to the control group whose posttest scores did not significantly improve, it is clear from the findings that pre-reading activities can have impact on the students’ reading comprehension achievement. Findings from the study also established that the gain scores which reflected on the experimental group was a result of the use of pre-reading activities.

References

Akremi, O. (2016). Effective leadership and management in childhood care and education services. In fundamentals of pre – school and primary school teacher preparation in Nigeria. An unpublished material of the University of Ibadan, Nigeria.
Agbevivi, S. L. G. (2022). Aspects of kindergartners’ reading and writing skills assessed by kindergarten teachers in the Atwima Kwanwoma District, Ghana. International Journal of Research and Innovation in Social Science, VI(VIII). 77 – 94.
Ajide, F.O. (2020). Challenges in the teaching of reading comprehension in secondary school. Journal of Language Education, 5(2), 66 – 71.
Asemota, H. (2018). The effect of directed reading thinking activity through cooperation learning on English secondary stage students, reading comprehension in Jordan International Journal of Humanities and Social Science 2 (16):138-143.
Beard, R. (2018). Reading-a personal and professional view. International Journal of Primary, Elementary and Early Years’ Education, 49(1), 13 – 25.
Christopher, G. (2017).Teaching reading skill using heuristic technique through Schema theory. IUP Journal of English Studies, 12(1), 11.
Dickson, A. (2022). Pre-reading activities to boost comprehension. Retrieved on 4th June 2022 from https://ellii.com/blog/prereading-activities-to-boost-comprehension
Gharawi, H. (2014). Understanding the 2013 curriculum of English teaching through the teachers’ and policymakers’ perspectives. International Journal of Enhanced Research in Educational Development (IJERED), 3(1), 6 – 15.
Hasan, S. (2011). Tradition and modernity in Islam: A reading through power, property and philanthropy. Saudi Arabia: Usman Press.
Hashemi, A., G. (2016). The impact of content-based pre-reading activities on Iranian high school EFL learners’ reading comprehension. Journal of Language Teaching and Research, 7(1 ), 137.
Johnson, P. (2010). Re-examining some conventional assumptions in vocabulary teaching: What can we learn from the research? In E. Hinkel (Ed.) Handbook of practical second language teaching and learning (pp. 409-420). New York: Taylor & Francis.
Kim, Y. (2019). A comparison of the impact of extensive and intensive reading approaches on the reading attitudes of secondary EFL learners. Second Language Learning and Teaching, 10(2), 337–358.
Lawal, S. (2019). Pre-reading and during –reading questions as predictors of reading comprehension achievement of Nigerian senior secondary school students. An unpublished doctoral dissertation, University of Ilorin, Ilorin, Nigeria.
Mahmoud, R. (2020). Reading comprehension assessment: The effects of reading the items aloud before or after reading the passage. The Elementary School Journal, 120(2), 300-318.
Mohammad, H. (2015). Research methods and statistics in psychology (2^nd Ed.). London: Hodder & Stoughton.
Nanda, D.W. (2020). Poor reading comprehension issue in EFL classroom among Indonesian secondary school students:

Scrutinizing the causes, impacts and solutions. Journal of English, Education and Humanities, 8(1), 12 – 24.

Naranjo, E., (2021). Reading: definition and reading operations. Journal of Research Innovation and Implications in Education, 3(2), 53-62.
Nurdina U. (2018). The effect of before, during, and after reading (BDA) strategy on students’ reading comprehension achievement in narrative text. Unpublished master’s thesis, University of Muhammadiyah Sumatera Utara.
Nwodo, D. W. (2019). Poor reading comprehension issue in EFL classroom among Indonesian secondary school students:

Scrutinizing the causes, impacts and possible solutions. Englisia Journal of Language, Education, and Humanities, 8(1), 12– 24.

Oakhill, J., Cain, K., & Elbro, C. (2015). Understanding and teaching reading comprehension: A handbook. New York:

Routledge.

Osei, O. R. (2016). The importance of reading in Nigeria schools. Ibadan: Spectrum publishers.
Oyetunde, T. O., & Muoddumogu, C. A. (1999). Reading strategy instruction and comprehension development in Nigerian schools. Nigerian Educational Research Journal, 5(2), 33-41.
Silbert, D. (2016). Improving reading comprehension and social studies knowledge among middle school students with disabilities. Journal of Exceptional Children, 81(4), 426-442.
Yusuf, A. (2016) Instructional materials and students’ performance in comprehension tasks. Ilorin Journal of Education, 2(1), 92 – 100.

Daily writing prompt

How can you build a regular fitness routine?

View all responses

An Autoregressive Moving Average Model for Short-Term Prediction of Non-Insulin Dependent Diabetes Among Farmers in Benue State

Citation

Agada, J., Kuhe, D. A., & Anthony, O. N. (2026). An Autoregressive Moving Average Model for Short-Term Prediction of Non-Insulin Dependent Diabetes Among Farmers in Benue State. International Journal of Research, 13(4), 255–278. https://doi.org/10.26643/ijr/edupub/22Style

APA

John Agada¹, David Adugh Kuhe² and Ojochegbe Noah Anthony^3*

¹Department of Mathematics and Computer Science, Rev, Fr. Moses Orshio Adasu University Makurdi, Benue State, Nigeria

²Department of Statistics, Joseph Sarwuan Tarka University, Makurdi, Benue State, Nigeria

³Department of Mathematics and Computer Science, Rev, Fr. Moses Orshio Adasu University Makurdi, Benue State, Nigeria

Corresponding Author: Email: davidkuhe@gmail.com; Tel: 2348064842229

ABSTRACT

This study employs an Autoregressive Moving Average (ARMA) time series model to forecast the short-term incidence of non-insulin-dependent diabetes mellitus (Type 2 Diabetes) among farmers in Benue State, Nigeria. The data was collected from the Benue State Epidemiological Unit, Makurdi, and covered a 20-year period from January 2005 to June 2025. The study employed descriptive statistics and normality measures, Augmented Dickey-Fuller (ADF) unit root test and ARMA (p,q) model as the principal analytical techniques and procedures used to examine the data. The descriptive statistics indicated moderate variability in diabetes cases over the years, while the Augmented Dickey-Fuller (ADF) test confirmed the stationarity of the series in level. Model choice based on Akaike Information Criterion (AIC), Schwarz Information Criterion (SIC), and Hannan–Quinn Criterion (HQC) identified the ARMA(3,3) model as the best fit for forecasting diabetic cases in the study area. The model’s high coefficient of determination (R² = 0.8905) and statistically significant parameters (p < 0.05) demonstrated its robustness and predictive accuracy. Diagnostic checks using autocorrelation, partial autocorrelation, and the Ljung–Box Q-statistics showed that the residuals behaved like white noise, indicating a well-specified model. Forecast evaluations using Root Mean Square Error (RMSE), Mean Absolute Error (MAE), and Mean Absolute Percentage Error (MAPE) confirmed that the model accurately good for predicting out-of-sample values. The forecast for July 2025 to June 2027 revealed a potential average of approximately 6,420 diabetes cases per month among farmers, with expected fluctuations over time. The study underscored the growing public health concern of diabetes among the farming population in Benue State and its implications for agricultural productivity and postharvest losses. The study concluded that predictive modeling can serve as a vital tool for health planners to design early intervention strategies, integrate health management with agricultural development, and enhance the overall well-being of rural farmers.

Keywords: Diabetes, ARIMA, Time Series Forecasting, Non-Insulin Dependent Diabetes, Farmers, Benue State, Public Health, Postharvest Losses

1.0 INTRODUCTION

Diabetes mellitus, often simply referred to as diabetes, is a group of metabolic disorders characterized by high blood sugar levels over a prolonged period. The two main types of diabetes are type-1 diabetes, which results from the body’s inability to produce insulin, and Type-2 diabetes develops when the body either becomes resistant to insulin or produces insufficient insulin to control blood sugar levels effectively. Diabetes mellitus is a multifaceted metabolic condition marked by high concentrations of glucose (sugar) in the bloodstream Glucose is a crucial source of energy for cells, and insulin, a hormone produced by the pancreas, plays a central role in regulating its uptake into cells. In diabetes mellitus, this regulation is disrupted, leading to persistent hyperglycemia (high blood sugar) (American Diabetes Association, 2022).

Diabetes mellitus is a significant public health concern worldwide, with its prevalence increasing steadily over the past few decades. According to the International Diabetes Federation (IDF, 2019), an estimated 537 million adults aged 20-79 years were living with diabetes globally in 2021 and this number is projected to rise to 783 million by 2045. The prevalence of diabetes varies by region, with higher rates observed in low- and middle-income countries, particularly in urban areas undergoing rapid socioeconomic development and lifestyle changes. (ADA, 2022).

In Nigeria, the prevalence is estimated at 7% and 11.35% in South-south zone. The Diabetes Association of Nigeria (DAN) reviewed that, mortality rate of diabetes from insufficient management far outweighs that of HIV/AIDs, Malaria and Cancer (Olamoyegun et al., 2024)

Diabetes mellitus is significantly Impacting farmers in Benue State with prevalence rate among yam farming population estimated at 24.9% and mortality rate of 8.61% and as led to reduced labor productivity, economic impact and health complications (Teran, A.D.. 2017)

Diabetes is associated with numerous complications that can affect nearly every organ system in the body. These complications includes Microvascular: Retinopathy (vision loss) neuropathy (nerve damage), nephropathy (kidney damage), and Microvascular: cardiovascular disease (such as heart attack and stroke), others are foot ulcers and amputations. The burden of diabetes-related complications is substantial, leading to increased medical costs, reduced quality of life, and higher risk of premature mortality (ADA, 2022).

Type-2 diabetes, also known as non-insulin dependent diabetes, is a long-term condition that affects how the body processes sugar (glucose), which is an important source of energy. In this condition, the body either becomes resistant to insulin, a hormone that helps move sugar into cells, or doesn’t produce enough insulin to keep blood sugar levels normal (Sun et al., 2021). Unlike type-1 diabetes, where the immune system attacks and destroys insulin-producing cells in the pancreas, type-2 diabetes usually develops slowly over time. While it was once mostly seen in adults, more children and teenagers are now being diagnosed, largely due to increasing obesity and less active lifestyles (Sun et al., 2021).

A major characteristic of type-2 diabetes is insulin resistance, which means the body’s cells don’t respond to insulin as they should. When this happens, the pancreas tries to make more insulin to help move sugar into the cells. However, over time, the pancreas may struggle to keep up with this increased demand. As a result, sugar starts to accumulate in the blood, causing high blood sugar levels (Cloete, 2022).

Several determinants contributes to the risk of developing type-2 diabetes, including obesity, particularly excess fat around the abdomen (central obesity), A sedentary lifestyle, unhealthy eating habits—like eating too many sugary and processed foods—having a family history of diabetes, getting older (especially after 45), and belonging to certain ethnic groups are all factors that can increase the risk of developing diabetes (ADA, 2022).

In Addition to insulin resistance, type-2 diabetes can also involve problems with the pancreas, the organ that makes insulin. Sometimes, the pancreas doesn’t produce enough insulin to keep blood sugar levels in check, making high blood sugar worse (Desai & Deshmukh, 2020).

Symptoms of type-2 diabetes often develop slowly and can include increased thirst, frequent urination, fatigue, blurred vision, slow wound healing, and repeated infections. In the early stages, some people may not notice any symptoms at all, which is why regular screenings are essential (IDF, 2019).

Treatment for type-2 diabetes aims to maintain blood sugar levels within a target range to prevent serious health problems and complications. This typically involves lifestyle modifications such as regular exercise, healthy eating habits (including portion control and selecting nutrient-rich foods), weight management, and monitoring blood sugar levels. (Desai & Deshmukh, 2020).

The management and treatment of type-2 diabetes can impose financial burdens on individuals, families, and healthcare systems. In regions where healthcare costs are primarily borne by the individual or are not adequately covered by insurance, the expenses associated with diabetes care can divert resources away from agricultural investments and productivity-enhancing measures. This can directly impact agricultural communities with reduced investment into agricultural produces, reduced income and crop loss thereby affecting their livelihood (Huang et al., 2016).

Diabetes Mellitus is diagnosed when certain blood sugar levels are met or exceeded. Specifically, a person may be diagnosed if their A1C is 6.5% or higher, which reflects average blood glucose over the past few months. Alternatively, if fasting blood sugar is 126 mg/dL or higher, or if a 2-hour blood sugar reading during an oral glucose tolerance test reaches 200 mg/dL or more, a diagnosis may be made. Additionally, if an individual has a random blood sugar of 200 mg/dL or higher along with symptoms like excessive thirst, frequent urination, or unexplained weight loss, they may also be diagnosed with diabetes (Jaeger et al., 2025).

Agricultural activities, like applying chemical fertilizers and pesticides, can have environmental consequences that can indirectly impact diabetes risk factors. For instance, exposure to chemicals such as glyphosate or organophosphates used in farming has been associated with a higher likelihood of developing metabolic disorders. Additionally, environmental factors such as air pollution and climate change may exacerbate diabetes risk factors and health outcomes, potentially affecting agricultural productivity and crop yields (whiting et al., 2011). Overall, while the direct impact of type-2 diabetes on agricultural productivity and postharvest losses may be limited, the interplay between diabetes, dietary patterns, healthcare access, and environmental factors can have broader implications for agricultural communities and food systems. Addressing the complex relationship between health, agriculture, and the environment requires a holistic approach that considers socioeconomic factors, public health interventions, and sustainable agricultural practices (Whiting et al., 2011).

Overall, while the direct impact of type-2 diabetes on agricultural productivity and postharvest losses may be limited, the interplay between diabetes, dietary patterns, healthcare access, and environmental factors can have broader implications for agricultural communities and food systems. Addressing the complex relationship between health, agriculture, and the environment requires a holistic approach that considers socioeconomic factors, public health interventions, and sustainable agricultural practices (Huang et al., 2016).

This study therefore attempts to extend the existing literature and contribute to the existing body of knowledge by modeling and forecasting non insulin dependent diabetes among farmers in Benue State using autoregressive moving average (ARIMA) time series model with more recent data.

2.0 MATERIALS AND METHODS

2.1 Method of Data Collection

The data utilized in this research work are monthly secondary time series data on morbidity incidence of type-2 diabetes in Benue state for the period of January, 2005 June, 2025 making a total of 234 observations. The data was collected from Benue State Epidemiological unit, Makurdi. The data was transformed to natural logarithms using the following formula:

where is the confirmed type-2 diabetes series observation indexed by time , while is the natural logarithm. Hence forth will be regarded as a series.

2.2 Methods of Data Analysis

Find below the statistical tools employed in the analysis of data in this work.

3.2.1 Descriptive statistics and normality measures

The mean of any given set of data can be computed as follows:

The sample standard deviation of any given set of data over a given period of time is computed using the formula:

where is the sample mean, is the sample size.

Jarque-Bera test is a normality test of whether a given sample data have the skewness and kurtosis similar to that of a normal distribution. The test was proposed by Jarque and Bera (1980, 1987) and test the null hypothesis that the series is normally distributed. Given any data set, the test statistic JB is defined as:

where is the sample skewness denoted as:

and is the sample kurtosis given below:

whereT is the total number of observations. The JB normality test checks the following pair of hypothesis:

and (i.e., follows a normal distribution)

and (i.e., does not follows a normal distribution).

The test rejects the null hypothesis if the p-value of the JB test statistic is less than level of significance.

2.2.2 Augmented Dickey-Fuller (ADF) unit root test

The Augmented Dickey-Fuller (ADF) test helps to identify if a time series is stationary or has a unit root, indicating a persistent trend over time (Dickey and Fuller, 1979).

It accounts for higher-order correlations by assuming the series follows an AR(p) process and incorporates lagged differences of the series into the regression to enhance the test’s precision.

where are optional exogenous regressors which may consist of constant, or a constant and trend, and are parameters to be estimated,β values arelagged difference terms and the are assumed to be white noise. The null and alternative hypotheses are written as:

(8)

and evaluated using the conventional ratio for

where is the estimate of and “the coefficient standard error is denoted as “

2.2.3 Portmanteau test

A Portmanteau test also called he Ljung-Box Q-statistic test is used to determine whether there is any remaining serial correlation or autocorrelation in the residuals of a time series. The test checks the following pairs of hypotheses:

(all lags correlations are zero)

(there is at least one lag with non-zero correlation). The test statistic is given by:

where

denotes the autocorrelation estimate of squared standardized residuals at lags. T is the sample size, Q is the sample autocorrelation at lag k. We reject if p-value is less than level of significance (Ljung and Box, 1979).

2.3 Time Series Models Specification

To specify an ARIMA model which is the model framework use in this study, we first specify autoregressive (AR) model, moving average (MA) model, autoregressive moving average (ARMA) model before specifying autoregressive integrated moving average (ARIMA) model. These models are specified as follows.

2.3.1 The autoregressive (AR) model

A stochastic time series process {} is an autoregressive process of order p, denoted AR() if it satisfied the difference equation

where is a white noise and are constants to be determined.

2.3.2 Moving average (MA) model

A time series {} which satisfies the difference equation

where are fixed constants with as white noise is called a moving average process of order q, denoted MA().

2.3.3 Autoregressive moving average (ARMA) model

A stochastic time series process {} which results from a linear combination of autoregressive and moving average processes is called an Autoregressive Moving Average (ARMA) process of order p, q, denoted ARMA () if it satisfies the following difference equation:

where are fixed constants associated with the AR terms and are fixed constants associated with the MA terms with being a white noise. The stationarity of an ARMA () process is guaranteed if the roots of the polynomial

lie outside the unit circle.

An ARMA () model is specified as:

2.3.4 Autoregressive integrated moving average (ARIMA) model

Autoregressive (AR), Moving Average (MA) or Autoregressive Moving Average (ARMA) model in which differences have been taken are collectively called Autoregressive Integrated Moving Average or ARIMA models. A time series {} is said to follow an integrated autoregressive moving average model if the ^th difference is a stationary ARMA process. If follows an ARMA(p, q) model, we say that {} is an ARIMA (p, d, q) process. For practical purposes, we can usually take or at most 2.

Consider then an ARIMA (p, 1, q) process, with , we have

In terms of the observed series,

)

2.4 Model Order Selection

We use the following information criteria for model order selection in conjunction with log likelihood function: Akaike information criterion (AIC) due to Akaike (1978), Schwarz information Criterion (SIC) due to (Schwarz, 1978) and Hannan-Quinn information Criterion (HQC) due to (Hannan, 1980). The formula for the information criteria are:

where is the number of free parameters to be estimated in the model, T is the number of observations and L is the likelihood function defined as:

Thus given a set of estimated ARMA models for a given set of data, the preferred model is the one with the minimum information criteria and maximum log likelihood.

2.5 Model Forecast Evaluation

We employed Root Mean Square Error (RMSE) and Mean Absolute Error (MAE) accuracy measures to select an optimal model mode that is both parsimonious and accurately forecast the data based on minimum values of the accuracy measures.

2.5.1 Root Mean Square Error (RMSE)

The Root Mean Square Error is a statistical tool for measuring the accuracy of a forecast method. It is computed as:

Where is the forecast value of the series and is the actual series and is the number of forecast observations.

2.5.2 Mean Absolute Error (MAE)

The mean absolute error (MAE) is a statistical tool for measuring the average size of the errors in a collection of predictions, without taking their directions into account. It is measured as the average absolute difference between the predicted values and the actual values and is used to assess the effectiveness of a model. It is given as:

where” is the actual value of the series at time is the forecasted value of the series and is the number of observations. The lower the value of RMSE and MAE, the better the model is able to forecast future values.

3.0 RESULTS AND DISC0USSION

3.1 Summary Statistics and Normality Measures

This study seeks to provide a short-term prediction of non-insulin-dependent diabetes (Type-2 diabetes mellitus) among farmers in Benue State using the Autoregressive Moving Average (ARMA) time series model. Before model estimation, a preliminary analysis of the dataset was conducted to summarize its key characteristics and assess the normality of the distribution. Table 1 below presents the descriptive statistics and normality test results for the observed monthly diabetes cases.

Table 1: Summary Statistics and Normality Measures

Variable	Statistic
Mean	5571.321
Maximum	9661.00
Minimum	3624.000
Standard Deviation	1769.088
Skewness	0.010212
Kurtosis	1.767498
Jarque-Bera Statistic	15.57465
p-value	0.000415
Number of Observations	246

From the result of summary statistics and normality measures reported in Table 1 above, the mean value of approximately 5571 infection cases indicates the average number of recorded non-insulin-dependent diabetes cases among farmers during the study period, while the maximum and minimum values (9661 and 3624, respectively) show the range of variation in the data. The standard deviation (1769) suggests a relatively high level of fluctuation around the mean, implying moderate variability in the monthly incidence of diabetes cases.

The skewness value (0.010212), being close to zero, indicates that the distribution of the series is approximately symmetric. However, the kurtosis value (1.767498) is less than 3, signifying a platykurtic distribution, that is, the data are relatively flatter than a normal distribution with lighter tails.

The Jarque–Bera statistic (15.57465) with an associated p-value of 0.000415 is statistically significant at the 1% level, leading to the rejection of the null hypothesis of normality. This implies that the series does not follow a perfectly normal distribution, which is a common characteristic of real-world time series data.

Overall, the results suggest that while the data are fairly symmetric, they deviate slightly from normality, a factor to be considered when fitting and diagnosing the ARMA model for accurate short-term forecasting.

4.2 Graphical Examination of Diabetes Miletus Series

Examining the morbidity cases of diabetes mellitus is essential for identifying trends and patterns over time, which can provide insights into the progression and fluctuations of the disease within a population. By analyzing these visual representations, healthcare providers and policymakers can better understand peak periods, seasonal variations, and the impact of interventions. This information is crucial for planning targeted healthcare responses, optimizing resource allocation, and developing strategies to reduce disease incidence and manage complications, ultimately improving health outcomes for affected populations. The time plots of the level and log transform series of diabetes mellitus are plotted in Figures 1 and 2 respectively as shown below.

The time plots of the level series and log transformed series reported in Figures 1 and 2 below indicate that both series are covariance or weakly stationary which implies the absence of unit root in the series in level. This is indicated by the smooth trend of both series.

Figure 1: Time Series Plot of Diabetes Miletus in Benue State from 2005 to 2025

Figure 2: Time Series Plot of Natural Log of Diabetes Miletus in Benue State from 2005

to 2025

4.3 Augmented Dickey-Fuller (ADF) Unit Root Test Result

To ensure the appropriateness of applying an Autoregressive Moving Average (ARMA) model for short-term prediction of non–insulin-dependent diabetes cases among farmers in Benue State, it is necessary to examine the time series properties of the data. A key requirement for ARMA modeling is that the underlying series must be stationary. Therefore, the Augmented Dickey–Fuller (ADF) unit root test was conducted to determine whether the series is stationary. Table 2 below presents the results of the ADF test under two specifications: with an intercept only, and with both intercept and trend.

The ADF statistics reported in Table 2 below for both model specifications (intercept only and intercept with trend) are -15.3344 and -15.4304, respectively. These values are far more negative than their corresponding 5% critical values (-2.8731 and -3.4283). In addition, the associated p-values are 0.0000, indicating strong statistical significance. Because the ADF test statistics are well below the critical values and the p-values are less than 0.05, the null hypothesis of a unit root is rejected under both model specifications. This confirms that the series stationary in its level form. Stationarity implies that the mean and variance of the diabetes case series remain stable over time, making it suitable for direct ARMA modeling without differencing. The strong evidence of stationarity enhances the reliability of subsequent short-term forecasts produced by the ARMA model.

Table 2: Augmented Dickey-Fuller (ADF) Unit Root Test Result

Variable	Option	ADF Test Statistic	p-value	5% Critical Value
	Intercept only	-15.3344	0.0000	-2.8731
	Intercept & Trend	-15.4304	0.0000	-3.4283

4.4 Autocorrelations and Partial Autocorrelations Functions of the Series

After confirming that the series of non–insulin-dependent diabetes cases among farmers in Benue State is stationary, the next step in the ARMA modeling process involves examining the autocorrelation structure of the series. The Autocorrelation Function (ACF) and Partial Autocorrelation Function (PACF) are used to identify the dependence pattern between current and past observations, which guides the selection of appropriate autoregressive (AR) and moving-average (MA) orders.

Furthermore, the Ljung-Box Q-statistics were computed to test for the joint significance of autocorrelations up to various lags. This test determines whether the residuals are independently distributed — a key requirement for model adequacy. Table 3 below presents the ACF, PACF, and Ljung-Box Q-statistics results for the series while Figure 3 belowpresented the ACF and PACF plots of the series.

The results of ACF and PACF reported in Table 3 below and Figure 3 show that the autocorrelation (ACF) and partial autocorrelation (PACF) coefficients for all lags are small in magnitude, fluctuating around zero. This indicates the absence of significant serial correlation in the data. None of the autocorrelations exceed the approximate 95% confidence bounds (±0.1 for a large sample size of 246), suggesting that the time series behaves like a white-noise process.

The Ljung-Box Q-statistics and their corresponding p-values across all lags (p > 0.05) further confirm that there is no significant autocorrelation remaining in the residuals. This means that the null hypothesis of no autocorrelation cannot be rejected at any lag, implying that the series is adequately described by a stationary stochastic process (Ljung & Box, 1979).

Table 3: Autocorrelations and Ljung-Box Q-Statistics Test Results

Lag	ACF	PACF	Q-Statistics	p-value
1	0.014	0.014	0.0458	0.831
2	-0.019	-0.019	0.1338	0.935
3	0.004	0.005	0.1380	0.987
4	-0.049	-0.050	0.7497	0.945
5	0.022	0.024	0.8747	0.972
6	0.037	0.034	1.2165	0.976
7	0.022	0.023	1.3420	0.987
8	0.017	0.015	1.4126	0.994
9	-0.007	-0.005	1.4260	0.998
10	-0.110	-0.107	4.5659	0.918
11	-0.025	-0.022	4.7227	0.944
12	0.078	0.075	6.2944	0.901
13	-0.008	-0.012	6.3115	0.934
14	-0.017	-0.027	6.3907	0.956
15	0.052	0.055	7.0970	0.955
16	-0.035	-0.022	7.4226	0.964
17	-0.012	-0.008	7.4599	0.977
18	-0.088	-0.093	9.5213	0.946
19	-0.054	-0.050	10.302	0.945
20	-0.092	-0.114	12.567	0.895
21	-0.026	-0.032	12.750	0.917
22	-0.115	-0.115	16.369	0.797
23	0.007	0.008	16.381	0.838
24	-0.053	-0.074	17.165	0.842
25	-0.056	-0.036	18.032	0.841
26	-0.047	-0.056	18.643	0.851
27	0.055	0.057	19.482	0.852
28	-0.011	-0.032	19.514	0.882
29	0.060	0.057	20.511	0.876
30	0.056	0.042	21.381	0.876
31	0.040	0.061	21.828	0.888
32	-0.001	-0.015	21.828	0.912
33	-0.027	-0.007	22.036	0.927
34	-0.109	-0.121	25.432	0.855
35	-0.056	-0.074	26.342	0.854
36	0.066	0.025	27.604	0.841

Figure 3: Plots of ACF and PACF of Log Transformed Series

Collectively, these findings suggest that the series is not driven by persistent temporal dependence, and any ARMA model fitted to the data should yield uncorrelated and well-behaved residuals. Therefore, the dataset is suitable for ARMA model identification and estimation, and the absence of significant autocorrelation validates the appropriateness of proceeding with short-term forecasting using the ARMA framework.

4.5 Model Order Selection

Following the establishment of stationarity and the absence of significant autocorrelation in the diabetes time series, various ARMA model orders were estimated to determine the most parsimonious and best-fitting specification for short-term prediction. Model selection was based on several statistical criteria, including the Log Likelihood (LogL), Akaike Information Criterion (AIC), Schwarz Information Criterion (SIC), and Hannan–Quinn Criterion (HQC). Generally, the preferred model is the one with the highest Log Likelihood and the lowest values of AIC, SIC, and HQC. Table 4 below presents the results of the model order selection process.

Among the twenty-four ARMA model specifications estimated, the ARMA(3,3) model exhibits the highest Log Likelihood value (-24.0103) and the lowest AIC (0.2552), SIC (0.3159), and HQC (0.2958) values. These results indicate that the ARMA(3,3) model provides the best balance between goodness-of-fit and parsimony.

Table 4:Model Order Selection using Log Likelihood and Information Criteria

S/n	Model	LogL	AIC	SIC	HQC
1.	ARMA(0,1)	-34.4597	0.2964	0.3349	0.3079
2.	ARMA(1,0)	-34.8194	0.3006	0.3391	0.3121
3.	ARMA(1,1)	-32.9444	0.2934	0.3363	0.3107
4.	ARMA(0,2)	-34.4107	0.3042	0.3469	0.3214
5.	ARMA(2,0)	-35.1256	0.3125	0.3555	0.3298
6.	ARMA(1,2)	-32.9256	0.3014	0.3586	0.3245
7.	ARMA(2,1)	-33.2988	0.3057	0.3631	0.3288
8.	ARMA(2,2)	-30.3771	0.2899	0.3616	0.3188
9.	ARMA(0,3)	-34.4060	0.3122	0.3692	0.3352
10.	ARMA(3,0)	-35.4688	0.3248	0.3823	0.3480
11.	ARMA(1,3)	-28.0912	0.2701	0.3616	0.3089
12.	ARMA(3,1)	-32.9028	0.3119	0.3838	0.3409
13.	ARMA(2,3)	-30.3708	0.2981	0.3841	0.3328
14.	ARMA(3,2)	-30.5304	0.3007	0.3859	0.3354
15.	ARMA(3,3)**	-24.0103	0.2552	0.3159	0.2958
16.	ARMA(0,4)	-34.1157	0.3180	0.3893	0.3467
17.	ARMA(4,0)	-35.3492	0.3335	0.4056	0.3625
18.	ARMA(1,4)	-34.4466	0.3302	0.4159	0.3647
19.	ARMA(4,1)	-35.3432	0.3417	0.4282	0.3765
20.	ARMA(2,4)	-32.0099	0.3198	0.4201	0.3602
21.	ARMA(4,2)	-26.7027	0.2785	0.3795	0.3192
22.	ARMA(3,4)	-25.4065	0.2799	0.3899	0.3213
23.	ARMA(4,3)	-33.4797	0.3428	0.4581	0.3893
24.	ARMA(4,4)	-31.4253	0.2962	0.4060	0.3285

Therefore, based on the information criteria, the ARMA(3,3) model is selected as the optimal model for forecasting short-term variations in non–insulin-dependent diabetes cases among farmers in Benue State. This suggests that both autoregressive and moving average components up to the third order significantly contribute to capturing the dynamic structure of the series.

4.6 Parameter Estimates of ARMA(3,3) Model

After selecting the ARMA(3,3) model as the optimal specification based on the information criteria, the model parameters were estimated to evaluate the dynamic relationship between past observations and random disturbances in the series of non–insulin-dependent diabetes cases among farmers in Benue State. Table 5 below presents the estimated coefficients of the ARMA(3,3) model, along with their corresponding standard errors, t-statistics, and p-values. Goodness-of-fit measures such as the R-squared, Adjusted R-squared, F-statistic, and Durbin–Watson statistic are also reported to assess the adequacy of the fitted model.

Table 5: Parameter Estimates of ARMA(3,3) Model

Variable	Coefficient	Std. Error	t-Statistic	p-value
C	8.768664	0.017218	509.2761	0.0000
AR(1)	0.366096	0.024641	14.85713	0.0000
AR(2)	0.311203	0.029382	10.59171	0.0000
AR(3)	-0.912359	0.024212	-37.68166	0.0000
MA(1)	-0.372828	0.009593	-38.86277	0.0000
MA(2)	-0.386923	0.009312	-41.55086	0.0000
MA(3)	0.982389	0.007644	128.5160	0.0000
R-squared	0.890511		AIC	0.255229
Adjusted R²	0.867389		SIC	0.315852
F-statistic	6.914400		HQC	0.295759
Prob(F-stat.)	0.000951		Durbin-Watson stat.	2.011502

The model estimation results reported in Table 5 show that all autoregressive (AR) and moving average (MA) coefficients are statistically significant at the 1% level, as indicated by their very low p-values (p < 0.01). This implies that past values and past error terms up to the third lag significantly influence the current level of non–insulin-dependent diabetes cases among farmers.

Specifically, the positive coefficients of AR(1) and AR(2) suggest a direct persistence effect, meaning that increases in diabetes cases in the immediate past periods tend to raise current cases. Conversely, the negative AR(3) coefficient indicates a corrective mechanism, implying that after about three periods, the series tends to revert toward its mean. The MA terms also show alternating positive and negative signs, suggesting that short-term shocks have both dampening and amplifying effects over time before dissipating.

The high R-squared (0.8905) and adjusted R-squared (0.8674) values indicate that approximately 89% of the variation in diabetes cases is explained by the model, signifying a very good fit. The F-statistic (6.9144) with a significant probability value (0.000951) confirms the overall significance of the model.The Durbin–Watson statistic (2.0115) is close to 2, suggesting the absence of serial correlation in the residuals, while the information criteria (AIC = 0.2552, SIC = 0.3159, HQC = 0.2958) reaffirm that the ARMA(3,3) model remains the most parsimonious and efficient choice.

Overall, the ARMA(3,3) model adequately captures the temporal dynamics and short-term fluctuations in non–insulin-dependent diabetes cases among farmers in Benue State, making it suitable for reliable short-term forecasting.

4.7 Model Diagnostic Checks

Following the estimation of the ARMA(3,3) model for predicting non–insulin-dependent diabetes cases among farmers in Benue State, diagnostic checks such as multicolinearity test and Ljung-Box Q-statistic tests were conducted to verify the adequacy of the fitted model. This assessment ensures that the residuals behave like white noise, uncorrelated, homoscedastic, and pattern-free over time. The test are presented in the following subsections.

4.7.1 Multicolinearity test result

Multicollinearity diagnostics were performed to make sure the variables in ARMA(3,3) model weren’t overlapping too much. Using the Variance Inflation Factor (VIF) for each autoregressive (AR) and moving average (MA) term, the test assessed how multicollinearity might affect the stability and reliability of parameter estimates. Generally, VIF values above 10 indicate severe multicollinearity, values between 5 and 10 suggest moderate correlation, and values below 5 imply no serious concern. The results presented in Table 6 show both uncentered and centered VIF statistics for the ARMA(3,3) model parameters.

The results of multicolinearity test reported in Table 6 below reveal that all centered VIF values are considerably low, ranging between 1.11 and 2.55, which are far below the critical threshold of 10. This indicates that there is no serious multicollinearity among the explanatory variables (AR and MA terms) in the estimated ARMA(3,3) model.

Therefore, the estimated parameters are statistically reliable, and the standard errors are not inflated by multicollinearity. This implies that the ARMA (3,3) model is well-conditioned, and the coefficients can be interpreted with confidence.

Table 6: Test for Multicolinearity (Variance Inflation Factors)

	Coefficient	Uncentered	Centered
Variable	Variance	VIF	VIF
C	0.000296	1.018813	Na
AR(1)	0.000607	1.779456	1.779044
AR(2)	0.000863	2.552345	2.552344
AR(3)	0.000586	1.768375	1.768101
MA(1)	9.20E-05	1.257613	1.255458
MA(2)	8.67E-05	1.213557	1.203709
MA(3)	5.84E-05	1.121942	1.111356

4.7.2 Ljung-Box Q-statistic test result for serial correlation

The Autocorrelation Function (ACF), Partial Autocorrelation Function (PACF), and Ljung–Box Q-statistics were used to test for serial correlation. High p-values (greater than 0.05) for the Q-statistics indicate no significant autocorrelation, suggesting that the residuals are random and the model is well specified. Table 5 presents these diagnostic test results for the ARMA(3,3) model residuals.

The results of Q-statistic reported in Table 5 and the ACF as well as PACF plots reported in Figure 4 show that all residual autocorrelations (ACF and PACF) are very small and fluctuate closely around zero across all 36 lags. None of the autocorrelation coefficients appear significant, suggesting that the residuals from the ARMA(3,3) model are approximately white noise.

Furthermore, the Ljung–Box Q-statistics have p-values consistently greater than 0.05, indicating that the null hypothesis of no autocorrelation cannot be rejected at any lag. This confirms that there is no statistically significant serial correlation remaining in the residuals. In addition, the Durbin–Watson statistic from the model estimation (2.0115) supports this conclusion by indicating near-zero autocorrelation in the residuals.

Overall, these diagnostic results confirm that the ARMA(3,3) model is well specified, the residuals are independently and randomly distributed, and the model provides a statistically adequate fit to the data. Therefore, the model is suitable for reliable short-term forecasting of non–insulin-dependent diabetes cases among farmers in Benue State

Table 7: Autocorrelations and Ljung-Box Q-Statistic Test Results of Residuals

Lag	ACF	PACF	Q-Statistics	p-value
1	-0.024	-0.024	0.1415	0.707
2	-0.012	-0.012	0.1760	0.916
3	-0.069	-0.070	1.3558	0.716
4	0.007	0.003	1.3669	0.850
5	-0.126	-0.128	5.3247	0.378
6	-0.036	-0.048	5.6541	0.463
7	-0.017	-0.024	5.7294	0.572
8	0.142	0.124	10.812	0.213
9	-0.042	-0.042	11.254	0.259
10	0.046	0.032	11.802	0.299
11	-0.021	-0.015	11.918	0.370
12	0.052	0.044	12.628	0.397
13	-0.025	0.012	12.794	0.464
14	-0.009	-0.008	12.815	0.541
15	0.062	0.080	13.804	0.540
16	0.068	0.053	15.019	0.523
17	0.112	0.147	18.316	0.369
18	0.109	0.127	21.475	0.256
19	-0.008	0.027	21.493	0.310
20	-0.087	-0.066	23.529	0.264
21	-0.066	-0.032	24.707	0.260
22	-0.020	0.010	24.810	0.306
23	-0.062	-0.057	25.855	0.308
24	-0.048	-0.064	26.480	0.329
25	0.021	-0.044	26.599	0.376
26	0.020	-0.037	26.704	0.425
27	-0.033	-0.069	27.003	0.464
28	0.065	0.050	28.156	0.456
29	0.052	0.030	28.898	0.470
30	0.062	0.046	29.969	0.467
31	0.014	0.040	30.023	0.516
32	0.010	0.016	30.053	0.565
33	0.042	0.050	30.555	0.589
34	0.003	0.004	30.558	0.637
35	-0.039	-0.013	30.994	0.662
36	-0.008	-0.001	31.014	0.705

Figure 4:Plot of Correlogram of Residuals of Estimated ARMA(3,3) Model

4.8 Forecast and Forecast Evaluation

To evaluate the predictive performance of the ARMA(3,3) model in forecasting non–insulin-dependent diabetes cases among farmers in Benue State, forecast accuracy measures were computed. The Root Mean Squared Error (RMSE), Mean Absolute Error (MAE), and Mean Absolute Percentage Error (MAPE) were used to assess both in-sample and out-of-sample forecast accuracy. Lower values of these statistics indicate better model performance and predictive reliability. The result is presented in Table 8.

The results of forecast comparison reported in Table 8below show that the out-of-sample forecast achieved slightly lower RMSE (0.2671), MAE (0.2310), and MAPE (2.6490) values compared to the in-sample forecast (RMSE = 0.2715, MAE = 0.2446, MAPE = 2.6781). This suggests that the ARMA(3,3) model demonstrates strong predictive capability, with minimal forecast error and good generalization performance. The model selected in forecast mode, as denoted by the accuracy measures, provides reliable short-term out-of-sample predictions of non–insulin-dependent diabetes cases.

Table 8: Forecast Comparison using Accuracy Measures

	RMSE	MAE	MAPE
In-Sample	0.271510	0.244615	2.678116
Out-of-Sample**	0.267100	0.231048	2.649005

Note: ** denotes forecast mode selected by accuracy measures.

4.8.1 Forecast of Diabetes Miletus in Benue State from July, 2025 to June, 2027

To evaluate the short-term predictive performance of the ARMA(3,3) model, forecasts of non–insulin-dependent diabetes (Type-2 Diabetes Mellitus) cases among farmers in Benue State were generated for the period July 2025 to June 2027. The forecasts were computed in natural logarithmic form and then converted to actual population estimates. For each forecast, the standard error, lower confidence limit (LCL), and upper confidence limit (UCL) were calculated at a 95% confidence level, using . These values provide a range within which the true number of diabetes cases is expected to fall with high probability, thereby indicating the reliability and uncertainty of the forecasts. The forecast result is reported in Table 9 below while the forecast graph is presented as Figure 5 below too.

Table 9: “Forecast of Diabetes Miletus Infection Cases in Benue State from July 2025-

June, 2027″

Year: Month	Forecast (natural log form)		Actual Forecast (No. of Persons)
Year: Month	Forecast	Std. error	LCL	Forecast	UCL
2025:06	6.9967	—	—	8896	—
2025:07	8.77405	0.271243	3799	6464	11000
2025:08	8.72655	0.271669	3619	6165	10499
2025:09	8.78204	0.271670	3826	6516	11098
2025:10	8.77132	0.272065	3782	6447	10988
2025:11	8.80141	0.272672	3893	6644	11337
2025:12	8.74519	0.272672	3680	6281	10717
2026:01	8.76088	0.272790	3738	6380	10889
2026:02	8.74585	0.273455	3677	6285	10741
2026:03	8.79725	0.273466	3871	6616	11308
2026:04	8.77366	0.273476	3781	6462	11044
2026:05	8.77825	0.274040	3794	6492	11107
2026:06	8.73648	0.274110	3638	6226	10654
2026:07	8.76803	0.274114	3755	6426	10996
2026:08	8.76810	0.274473	3752	6426	11005
2026:09	8.79729	0.274652	3862	6616	11335
2026:10	8.76026	0.274669	3722	6376	10923
2026:11	8.76113	0.274824	3724	6381	10936
2026:12	8.74504	0.275111	3662	6279	10767
2027:01	8.78341	0.275121	3805	6525	11188
2027:02	8.77734	0.275152	3782	6486	11121
2027:03	8.78223	0.275481	3798	6517	11183
2027:04	8.74716	0.275481	3667	6293	10798
2027:05	8.76058	0.275481	3717	6378	10944
2027:06	8.76313	0.275759	3724	6394	10978
Total	210.40663			154075
Average	8.766942917			6419.7917

Note: For 95% confidence intervals, . LCL and UCL denote lower and upper confidence limits respectively.

Figure 5: Forecast Graph of Diabetes Miletus in Benue State from July, 2025-June, 2027

The forecast results reported in Table 9 and Figure 5 above reveals that the predicted number of non–insulin-dependent diabetes cases among farmers in Benue State is expected to fluctuate moderately over the two-year forecast horizon (July 2025–June 2027). The monthly forecasts range between approximately 3,600 and 11,300 cases, with an overall average of about 6,420 cases per month and a total forecast of 154,075 cases during the study period. The relatively narrow confidence intervals across months suggest a high level of precision in the model’s predictions.

Overall, the ARMA(3,3) model demonstrates strong forecasting capability, indicating that diabetes prevalence among farmers in Benue State is likely to remain fairly stable with mild month-to-month variations over the forecast period.

4.9 Implications of the Study to Farmers and Postharvest Losses in Benue State

The implications of this study for farmers and postharvest losses in Benue State are significant from both public health and socio-economic perspectives. The findings, which forecast the prevalence of non–insulin-dependent diabetes (Type-2 Diabetes Mellitus) among farmers, suggest that a substantial portion of the agricultural workforce may experience declining health and productivity over time. Poor health conditions such as diabetes can reduce farmers’ physical capacity to engage in strenuous agricultural activities, particularly during critical periods like harvesting and processing. “This in turn increases the likelihood of postharvest losses, as crops may remain un-harvested or inadequately stored due to reduced labour efficiency and absenteeism resulting from illness”.

Moreover, “higher diabetes prevalence among farmers implies increased medical expenditures and a diversion of household income away from agricultural investment”, further compounding the problem of low productivity and waste. The study underscores the urgent need for integrated health and agricultural policies—including improved rural healthcare services, regular medical screening, health education on diet and lifestyle, and the promotion of labour-saving technologies—to mitigate the dual burden of disease and postharvest losses. Ultimately, addressing the health challenges of farmers is crucial for achieving food security, sustaining agricultural livelihoods, and enhancing overall economic resilience in Benue State.

4.0 Conclusion

The study demonstrates that the ARMA(3,3) model effectively forecasts the incidence of non-insulin-dependent diabetes among farmers in Benue State, Nigeria, The analysis revealed that the ARMA(3,3) model provided the best fit based on information criteria and diagnostic tests, with residuals behaving like white noise, indicating a well-specified and reliable model. The forecasts from July 2025 to June 2027 suggest a steady and relatively high incidence of diabetes cases among farmers, implying that the disease poses an ongoing public health concern within the agricultural population. This condition could adversely affect farmers’ productivity, increase medical costs, and indirectly contribute to higher postharvest losses due to reduced labour availability and inefficiencies in farm management. These findings highlight the interconnectedness between health and agricultural output, emphasizing that the burden of chronic diseases like diabetes extends beyond healthcare into the realm of food security and economic stability. Therefore, proactive health interventions and policy integration between the health and agricultural sectors are vital. Ensuring farmers’ wellness through preventive care, early detection, and education can significantly reduce the impact of diabetes and its broader economic consequences. The study provides empirical evidence to guide policymakers, healthcare providers, and agricultural development agencies in formulating context-specific strategies to improve both health outcomes and agricultural sustainability in Benue State.

REFERENCES

Al Zahrani, S., Al Rahman Al Sameeh, F., Musa, A. C. M., &Shokeralla, A. A. A. (2020). Forecasting diabetes patients attendance at Al-Baha hospitals using autoregressive fractional integrated moving average (ARFIMA) models. Journal of Data Analysis and Information Processing, 8, 183-194.

American College of Obstetricians and Gynecologists. (2018). ACOG Practice Bulletin No. 190: Gestational Diabetes Mellitus. Obstetrics & Gynecology, 131(2), e49–e64.

American Diabetes Association. (ADA 2022). Diagnosis and Classification of Diabetes Mellitus. Diabetes Care, 45(1), S17-S38.

Atkinson, M. A., Eisenbarth, G. S., & Michels, A. W. (2014). Type 1 diabetes. The Lancet, 383(9911), 69–82.

Benue State Epidemiological Unit, Makurdi, Nigeria.
(Unpublished secondary data on type-2 diabetes incidence, 2005–2025).

Box, G. E. P., Jenkins, G. M., & Reinsel, G. C. (2015). Time series analysis: forecasting and control. John Wiley & Sons.

Carlos M. Jarque, C. M., &Anil K. Bera, A. K. (1980).Efficient tests for normality,homoscedasticity and serial independence of regression residuals. Economics Letters, 6(3), 255–259.

Carlos M. Jarque, C. M., & Anil K. Bera, A. K. (1987).A test for normality of observations and regression residuals. International Statistical Review, 55(2), 163–172

Cloete, L. (2022). Diabetes mellitus: an overview of the types, symptoms, complications and management. Nursing Standard, 37(1), 61-66.

David A.Dickey, D. A., &Wayne A. Fuller, W. A. (1979).Distribution of the estimators for autoregressive time series with a unit root.Journal of the American StatisticalAssociation, 74(366), 427–431.

Deberneh, H. M. & Kim, I. (2021). Prediction of type 2 diabetes based on machine learning algorithm. International Journal of Environmental Research and Public Health, 18, 3317-3329.

Desai, S. & Deshmukh, A. (2020). Mapping of type-1 diabetes mellitus. Current Diabetes Reviews, 16(5), 438-441.

Dickey, D. A., & Fuller, W. A. (1979). Distribution of the Estimators for Autoregressive Time Series with a Unit Root. Journal of the American Statistical Association, 74(366), 427–431. https://doi.org/10.2307/2286348

Diogo, M. V., Nunopombo, F., & Brandão, P. (2022).Hypoglycemia prediction models with auto explanation. IEEE Access, 10, 57930-57941.

Donath, M. Y., & Shoelson, S. E. (2011). Type-2 diabetes as an inflammatory disease. Nature Reviews Immunology, 11(2), 98–107.

Edward J. Hannan, E. J., &Barry G. Quinn, B. G. (1979).The determination of the order of an autoregression.Journal of the Royal Statistical Society: Series B, 41(2), 190–195

George Casella, G., &Roger L. Berger, R. L. (2002).Statistical Inference (2nd ed.). Duxbury.

George E. P. Box, G. E. P., Gwilym M. Jenkins, G. M., &Gregory C. Reinsel, G. C. (2015).
Time Series Analysis: Forecasting and Control (5th ed.). Wiley

Greta M. Ljung, G. M., &George E. P. Box, G. E. P. (1978).On a measure of lack of fit in time series models.Biometrika, 65(2), 297–303

Hirotugu Akaike, H. (1974).A new look at the statistical model identification.IEEE Transactions on Automatic Control, 19(6), 716–723.

Huang, Y., Vemer, P., Zhu, J., & Postma, M. J. (2016). The economic burden of diabetes mellitus in rural southwest China. International Journal of Environmental Research and Public Health, 13(9), 875-889.

International Diabetes Federation. (IDF, 2019). IDF Diabetes Atlas, 9th Edition. Brussels, Belgium: International Diabetes Federation.https://www.diabetesatlas.org/en/

Jaeger, B., Casanova, R., Demesie, Y., Stafford, J., Wells, B., & Bancks, M. P. (2025). Development and Validation of a Diabetes Risk Prediction Model With Individualized Preventive Intervention Effects. The Journal of Clinical Endocrinology and Metabolism, 110(12), e4023–e4029. https://doi.org/10.1210/clinem/dgaf250

Kahn, S. E., Cooper, M. E., & Del Prato, S. (2014). Pathophysiology and treatment of type-2 diabetes: perspectives on the past, present, and future. The Lancet, 383(9922), 1068–1083.

Katsarou, D. N., Georga, E. I., Christou, M., Tigas, S., Papaloukas, C., & Fotiadis, D. I. (2022). Short term glucose prediction in patients with type-1 diabetes mellitus. Annual International Conference of IEEE Engineering, Medical & Biological Society, 2022, 329-332.

Ljung, G. M., & Box, G. E. P. (1979). The Likelihood Function of Stationary Autoregressive-Moving Average Models. Biometrika, 66(2), 265. https://doi.org/10.2307/2335657

Ma, N., Zhao, Y., Wen, S., Yang, T., Wu, R., Tao, R., Yu, X., & Li, H. (2020). Online blood glucose prediction using autoregressive moving average model with residual compensation network. Journal of science, 12(2), 115-128.

Matthew, P. K., Timothy, K. N., Ajia, R., & Antyev, S. (2022).Time series modelling of diabetes disease in Taraba state, Nigeria. Science World Journal, 17(3), 406-412.

Olamoyegun, M. A., Alare, K., Afolabi, S. A., Aderinto, N., & Adeyemi, T. (2024). A systematic review and meta-analysis of the prevalence and risk factors of type 2 diabetes mellitus in Nigeria. Clinical Diabetes and Endocrinology, 10(1). https://doi.org/10.1186/s40842-024-00209- 1

Olivares-Vera, D. A., Gutiérrez-Hernández, D. A., Escobar-Acevedo, M. A., Lara-Rendón, C., & Velázquez-Vázquez, D. A. (2021). Comparison of algorithms for the prediction of glucose levels in patients with diabetes. Nova Scientia, 13(2), 1-19.

Powers, A. C., D’Alessio, D., & Endocrine Society. (2016). Diabetes Mellitus: Diagnosis, Classification, and Pathophysiology. In Endotext. MDText.com, Inc.

Rob J. Hyndman, R. J., & George Athanasopoulos, G. (2021).Forecasting: Principles and Practice (3rd ed.). OTexts.Available online: https://otexts.com/fpp3/

Robertson, R. P. (2004). Chronic oxidative stress as a central mechanism for glucose toxicity in pancreatic islet beta cells in diabetes. Journal of Biological Chemistry, 279(41), 42351-42354.

Rodríguez-Rodríguez, I., Chatzigiannakis, L., Rodríguez, J., Maranghi, M., Gentili, M., & Zamora-Izquierdo, M. (2019). Utility of big data in predicting short-term blood glucose levels in type 1 diabetes mellitus through machine learning techniques. Sensors, 19, 4482-4498.

Schwarz, G. (1978c). Estimating the Dimension of a Model. The Annals of Statistics, 6(2), 461–464. https://doi.org/10.1214/aos/1176344136

Sheldon M. Ross, S. M. (2014).Introduction to Probability and Statistics for Engineers and Scientists (5th ed.). Academic Press.

Singye, T. &Unhapipat, S. (2018). Time series analysis of diabetes patients: A case study of Jigme Dorji Wangchuk National Referral Hospital in Bhutan. Journal of physics: conference series, 1039, 1-11.

Smith, S. M., Boppana, A., Traupman, J. A., Unson, E., Maddock, D. A., Chao, K., Dobesh, D. P., Brufsky, A., & Connor, R. I. (2021). Impaired glucose metabolism in patients with diabetes, prediabetes, and obesity is associated with severe COVID-19. Journal of Medical Virology, 93(1), 409-415.

Spyros Makridakis, S., Steven C. Wheelwright, S. C., & Rob J. Hyndman, R. J. (1998).Forecasting: Methods and Applications (3rd ed.). Wiley

Sun, Y., Tao, Q., Wu, X., Zhang, L., Liu, Q., & Wang, L. (2021). The utility of exosomes in diagnosis and therapy of diabetes mellitus and associated complications. Frontiers in Endocrinology (Lausanne), 12, 75-88.

Teran, A. D. (2017). Effects of diabetic prevalence and mortality on households farm labour productivity in Benue State. IOSR Journal of Agriculture and Veterinary Science, 10(7), 63-72.

Villani, M., Nanayakkara, N., Ranasinha, S., Earnest, A., Smith, K., Soldatos, G., Teede, H. &Zoungas, S. (2017). Utilisation of prehospital emergency medical services for hyperglycemia: a community-based observational study. PLoS ONE, 12, e0182413.

Wang, J., Zhang, T., Lu, X., Zhang, H., Dong, Y., & Chen, X. (2019). Application of ARIMA model in forecasting diabetes mellitus mortality in China from 2019 to 2023. Chinese Journal of Preventive Medicine, 53(11), 1121–1125.

Whiting, D. R., Guariguata, L., Weil, C., & Shaw, J. (2011). IDF diabetes atlas: global estimates of the prevalence of diabetes for 2011 and 2030. Diabetes Research and Clinical Practice, 94(3), 311–321.

Zhu, D., Zhou, D., Li, N., & Han, B. (2022). Predicting Diabetes and Estimating Its Economic Burden in China Using Autoregressive Integrated Moving Average Model. International Journal of Public Health, 66, 1604449.

Zhu, H., Capistrant, B. D., & Peng, Y. (2017). Investigating the impact of socioeconomic factors, air quality, and built environment on diabetes mellitus in China. Journal of Environmental and Public Health, 2017, 1–12.

Daily writing prompt

What’s a classic book that you think is overrated?

View all responses

There are Cities and there are Cities: Marking the Sociological Distinction and Considerations

Citation

Ogbonnia, E. F., Chigoziri, N. E., C, I. K., U, A. K., Augustine, I., Esq, O. C., Onwe, D. C., & Chinelo, N. G. (2026). There are Cities and there are Cities: Marking the Sociological Distinction and Considerations. Journal for Studies in Management and Planning, 12(2), 66–73. https://doi.org/10.26643/jsmap/11

Egwu Francis Ogbonnia

Department Of Criminology And Security Studies, Ae-Funai

Orcid: Https://Orcid.Org/0009-0009-8519-8303

Nlemchukwu Emmanuel Chigoziri, Ph.D

Department Of Criminology And Security Studies, Ae-Funai

Nlemchukwuemmanuel@Yahoo.Com 08030819692

Orcid: Https://Orcid.Org/0009-0002-6403-6507

Igwe Kenneth C

Department Of Political Science, Ae-Funai

Adinde Kenneth U., Ph.D

Department Of Criminology And Security Studies, Ae-Funai

Orcid: Https://Orcid.Org/0009-0002-7458-7847

Izuogu Augustine

Department Of Criminology And Security Studies

University Of Agriculture And Environmental Sciences, Umuagwo, Imo State

Onyeacho Chike, Esq

Department Of Criminology And Security Studies

University Of Agriculture And Environmental Sciences, Umuagwo, Imo State

Daniel Chidiebere Onwe Alex Ekwueme Federal University Ndufu-Alike, Ebonyi State, Nigeria.

Nwadiani Grace Chinelo

Department Of Criminology And Security Studies, Alex Ekwueme Federal

University Ndufu-Alike, Ebonyi State, Nigeria.

ABSTRACT

This work centres on the various forms of cities and features that distant a city from the other. It is instructive to note that all known human society has various characteristics that tries to make it peculiar from other cities or communities. Thus, this study identified various cities and attempted to Sociologically demonstrate why some are seen as developed while others are still undergoing economic, political and social transition. The indicators that are primarily considered here are the level of human development, gross domestic product (GDP), direct foreign investment (DFI), Level of educational system/innovation amongst other factors.

Keywords: Cities, development, education, government, suburban, urban centres

INTRODUCTION

A city is a large and permanent human settlement. Cities generally have complex systems for sanitation utilities, Land usage, housing and transportation. The concentration of development greatly facilitates interaction between people and business, sometimes benefiting both parties in the process, but it also presents challenges to managing urban growth. Ekpenyong (2013) Opined that since 1870, the world has witnessed more far-reaching transformations in social life than occurred in the vast span of human history prior to that date. Urban centers have become the milieu in which almost everyone in the advanced world (capitalist society) live.

The development of cities is the result of a combination of circumstances. In western civilization (Europe, USA, Canada etc), the revolution in technology brought about a mechanization of agriculture that greatly improved per capital output, producing the food surpluses needed to sustain the cities.

At the same time human energy on the farm was increasingly replaced by mechanical energy, creating pressure on the rural population to leave the land.

Improved transportation system, road and railways, better housing systems and nutrition, health centers as well as communication technology all characterized city life, (Ekepenyong, 2011). Historically, there is not enough evidence to assert what conditions gave rise to the first cities. Some, theorists have speculated on what they consider suitable pre-conditions and basic mechanism that might have been important driving force. Conventional views thought that cities were first formed after the Neolithic revolution. This revolution gave impetus to agriculture, encouraged Hunter-gatherers to abandon nomadic lifestyles and to settle near others who lived by agricultural production.

Paul Bairoch (NY, cited in Ekpenyong 2013) believes that agricultural activities appearnecessary before true cities can form.

Various indices have been scholarly advanced regarding the conditions necessary for an area to be given the status of a city. According to Verve Gordon Childe, for a settlement to qualify as a city, it must have enough surplus of raw materials to support trade and relatively large population. For example, Shanghai China was seen as the biggest city while Durbai is presently the fastest growing city.

The first true towns are sometimes considered as large settlements where the inhabitants were no longer simply farmers but began to take on specialized occupations and where trade, food storage and power were centralized. Gordon Childe (1950 cited in Ekpenyong 2013) defined a city with 10 general indices. These are:-

Size and density of the population should be above normal.
Differentiation of the population; not all residents grow their own
food leading to specialists.
Payment of taxes to a deity or king.
Monumental public building.
Those not producing their own food are supported by the King
or ruler.
System of recording and practical science.
A system of writing
Development of symbolic art,
Trade and import of raw materials.
Specialist craftsman from outside the Kin-group

These characteristics are best used to describe ancient cities. One major characteristics that can be used to distinguish a small city from a large town is organized government. A city has professional administrators, regulations, and some form of taxation.

THE AFRICAN CITY

It is arguable to state that tropical Africa is one of the least urbanized

regions of the world. This is because in most countries, less than a quarter of the total population lives in urban centers, (Ekpenyong, 2013).

In 1950 for example, only two cities in the African continent had more than one million residents. Rapid population increase is an important factor in measuring urban development.

Cities in Africa are characterized by rapid population growth though other indices that are used as measuring yardsticks for urban settlement such as improved technology, stable government, quality social amenities and other essential needs of man are lacking. They are poverty-stricken, socially divided and present problems such as those insufficient and inadequate housing and unemployment on a large scale which are not encountered by the developed countries. Failure in Africa has always been attributed to cultural differences.

However, what is often forgotten is that such measures do not totally translate into development obstacles nor do they touch the underlying factors responsible for generating conditions favorable for unhindered development.

Though generalizations are difficult because of the scarcity of data, but Ekpenyong (2013) believed that there is abundant evidence that African societies are heterogeneous in their socio-political organization, but the context shared by all of them is the location of their economics at the periphery of international capitalism. This was made possible by the uneven trade relations that were not negotiated rather, a violent imposition of business relations with African Nations were made to become the producers of raw materials for the colonial masters and consumers of manufactured products of industries in the West.

Industrialization, improved housing, availability of seasoned health care, social amenities, refined schools and quality referrals amongst others are some of the indications of urban settlement and their peculiar pattern. Unfortunately, most of these amenities are lacking in African countries especially in their so-called cities. Another important factor as admitted by Ekpenyong (2013) is the concept of political stability. Since the exodus of Colonialism from African soil, Africa as a continent has been beset with variegated political instability especially in pre-election and election times.

Nevertheless, despite these bedeviling challenges, Africa Still possess several cities that have been running abreast with western cities and their development strides. These cities in Africa include Lagos, Kano, Port Harcourt, Accra, Egyptian cities which is the center of civilization and other growing cities in Africa.

In summary, cities in Africa are shaped by the nature of the incorporation of the entire social formation, The African economy which has been tied to uneven western capitalism of exploitation has been a huge obstacle to the full development of African cities just like the western counterparts. This explains the preponderance of prirnate cities in Africa, the seeds were sown during period of colonialism. City life today though is part of a world economic system such that changes in one part of the world have a direct impact elsewhere. The presence of multinationals has improved the plight of cities through their direct injection of fluid into business, improved communication, administration and investment strategies. These welcome developments have their attendant consequences, which include a high rate of criminality and corruption. Several crime issues now dominate the city life ranging from burglary, kidnapping, armed robbery to rape, political assassination and other related criminalities (Aneke, 2019).

EGYPT CIVILIZATION AND CITIES,

The more complex human societies called the first civilizations emerged around 3000 BC in the river Valleys of Mesopotamia, India, China and Egypt. An increase in food production led to the significant growth in human population and the rise of cities, The -people of

Egypt and southwest Asia laid the monumental foundation of western civilization, developed cities and struggled with the problems of organized state as they moved from individual communities to large territorial units and eventually to empire. Among the early old-world cities, Mohenjo-Daro of Indus Valley Civilization in present day Pakistan, existing from about-2600 BC, was one of the Largest with a population of 50,000 or more. These points to the fact that population is an important factor to be considered in defining and delineating what constitutes a city centre.

These Greek city-states reached great levels of prosperity that resulted in an unprecedented cultural boom, expressed in architecture, drama, Science, mathematics and philosophy and nurtured in Athens under a democratic government. In the 4^thCentury, Alexander the Great Commissioned Dinocrate of Rhodes to lay out his new city of Alexandra, the grandest example of idealized urban planning of the ancient Mediterranean world where the city’s regularity was facilitated by its level site near mouth of the Nile.

Urban planning is one distinguishing factor between cities of Africa and the rest of the world, African cities though with profound developmental strides lack seasoned planning and architecture that makes it looks attractive.

Some cities are sparsely populated political capitals; others were trade centers and still other cities had a primarily religions focus. A good example is Saudi Arabia where Muslim go far pilgrimages and Jerusalem where privileged Christians go for pilgrimage. The growth of the population. of ancient civilizations, the formation of ancient empire concentrating political power, and the growth in commerce and manufacturing led to ever greater capital cities and centers of commerce, tourism and industry. In ancient America, early urban traditions developed in the Andes and Mesoamerica. In the Andes, the first urban centers developed in

the Norte Chico civilization. It is the oldest known civilization in the Americas, flourishing between the 30^th century BC and the 18^thcentury BC. Meso-America saw the rise of early Urbanism in several cultural regions. Later cultures such as the Aztec drew on these earlier urban traditions.

The growth of modern industry from late 18^th century onward led to massive Urbanization and the rise of great new cities, first in Europe and then in other regions, as new opportunities brought huge numbers of migrants from rural communities into urban areas. In the United States, from 1860 to 1910, the introduction of railroads reduced transportation costs and large manufacturing centers began to emerge, thus allowing migration from rural to city areas. Cities during this period were deadly places to live in due to health problems resulting from contaminated water, air and communicable diseases. In the great depression of the 1930s, cities were hard hit by unemployment, especially those with a base in heavy industry. In the USA, Urbanization rate increased from 40 to 80 percent during 1900-1990. Today, the world’s population is slightly over half urban and continues to urbanize with roughly a million people moving into cities every 24 hours worldwide.

Generally, Richard Sennett (1977) gives a rather sociologically inclined definition of a city. To him, a city is a human settlement where strangers are likely to meet.

Even amongst the western world, there is no single definitional construct on the concept of what constitutes a city. This is because the factors, or better still, peculiarities that distinguish a city vary from place to place and time to time. What constitutes a city in medieval civilization for instance may not be apt enough to determine the features of a city in modern times. Even in the next century, what we see now as cities may net be seen as full-blown cities.

Modern cities are known for creating their own microclimates. This is due to the large clustering of heat absorbent surface that heat up in sunlight and that channel rainwater into underground ducts, Waste and sewage are two major problems for cities such as air

pollution from various forms of combustion, including fire burning, stoves, other heating systems, engine emission and internal combustion engines. Crime is another consequence of city life. Studies have shown that crime rate in cities is higher and the chance of punishment after getting caught is lower. In extreme cases such as burglary, the higher concentration of people in cities creates more items of higher value worth the risk of crime. Cities also generate positive external effects. The close physical proximity facilitates knowledge spillovers, helping people and firms exchange information and generate new ideas. Population density enables also sharing of common infrastructure and production facilities, however in very dense cities, increased crowding; thickening labor market due to uncontrolled migration may lead to some negative effects. These have been the challenges confronting cities in Africa and beyond even in the western civilized parts of the world.

GLOBAL CITIES

A global city, also known as a world city, is a prominent Centre of trade, banking, finance, innovation and markets. As it was coined by Sakia Sassen (1991). Global Cities have more in common with each other than with other cities.

Global cities are opposed to mega-city which refers to any city of economic power or influence. This includes London, Paris, Mew Yo^rk, Tokyo and the modern Dubai. Los Angeles, the home of Hollywood is a globalizing city though more significant in Cultural than economic terms unlike the enumerated cities. From the foregoing, global cities are characterized by intense economic activities, business growth and investment opportunities and not along cultural lines. A good example is Eggaton Street in London where some of the cheapest buildings cost about three million pounds.

There is a growing movement in North America called “New Urbanism” that calls for a return to traditional city planning methods where mixed-use zoning allows people to walk from ‘one type of land use to another. The idea is that housing, shopping, office space and Leisure facilities are all provided within walking distances of each

other, thus reducing the demand for road space and also improving the efficiency and effectiveness of mass transit, (Jeribe 2023)

SUB-URBAN/ SUBURBANITES

This is another dimension in the analysis of cities and urban development. By suburban, it means that it is not urban, rather below urban requirement or away from urban life. On the one hand, suburban sirnply means a smaller community adjacent to or within commuting distance of big city, an outlying part of a city or town, (Jeribe 2023). It could also mean a town or other areas where people live in houses near a larger city. On the other hand, suburbanites are the people who dwell in such areas as described above. Most developed cities or” the world due to over-population, busy traffic, high tenancy, crime rate and other vices have paved way ‘for the emergence and development of suburban cities. It is a drift away from city life. Most inhabitants of inner city have moved away to settle in suburban centers.

Even the rural dwellers whose economic situation has taken an upward turn have also found abode/reasons to migrate to suburban centers. Suburbanites could be government functionaries, business and oil magnets, executives in corporations and successful business tycoons. In Rivers State for instance, resident of government reserved area (GRA), Trans Amadi residents etc can decide to relocate to Aluu, Choba or Igwuruta towns. Gradually, development will move into such areas. This will also gradually give rise to another
suburban city with the passage of time and by social interaction and processes. Soaring housing and electricity bills, environmental challenges and the upsurge of massive retrenchment, unemployment and a lot more social problems could be reasons for the increase in the number of suburbanites.

Town planners and urban sociologists are presently concerned with the development of suburban and suburbanites. Land acquisition and tenancy rates are cheaper in suburban centers, giving room for higher influx of people into the area.

Suburbanites are likely to travel to the city for work. Suburbs have more single-family homes than apartment buildings and suburbanites are more likely to have a yard with trees and grasses. They may enjoy a little of the advantage of rural settings as well as some facilities common with the cities. The disadvantage is that if they work in the main city, they might have a Long Commute that adds to the time they are away from their family.

Suburbs are usually middle-class residences: rents are usually cheaper in the suburbs. We have suburbs of New York and Manchester etc. (Jeribe, 2023),

The typical life, attitude and way of life of people who live in the suburbs may be peculiar. Some people consider suburban life to be rather boring and conservative compared to the hustle and ‘bustle’ of city life, while others commend the serenity and peace of some Suburbs that have not yet been eroded by the encroachment of a developing city, (Jeribe, 2023).

CONCLUSION

In conclusion, what can be seen as cities exist in all parts of the world though with varying features. This is a reality because what constitutes a favored city in London or Tokyo rnay not be found in growing nations such as Nigeria and other African countries. Generally, cities are up of densely populated conglomeration of peon e from diverse ethnic origin, improved housing system with urban planning standard, quality health care facilities and referrals, technology and communication as well as the presence of multinationals, good road network, stable electricity / alternatives (Gas turbines etc) as well as free competitive market, financial institutions and unparallel investment. In other to bring African nations to this standard, the following recommendations are made:

Urban planners should be allowed to strategize on the best way to manage housing and housing related issues. The government has always hijacked this- role which has made urban settlement patterns a big failure.
Creation of employment by the government is germane to minimize the crime rate in our cities,
Direct investment both small and medium enterprises should be encouraged. Government should aid them by boosting their financial potential,

4.The creation of a stable, sane and crime-free society through

Improved security monitoring is essential. No city or nation progresses when it is beset with security challenges.

5. Finally, the creation of enabling physical environment such as controlled pollution of the environment with toxic waste and other harmful substances will necessitate/improve our match to a healthy living standard.

REFERENCES

Anele K. A (2019), Social Change and Social Problems in Nigeria. Department of Sociology, University of Port-Harcourt.

Ekpenyong S. (2011), Elements of Sociology 2^no edition, Heritage Research and Publication.

Ekpenyong S, (2013), The City in Africa, Davidstones Publishers Ltd,

Jeribe C. (2023), The Concepts of Suburbanite, A Seminal Presentation, University of Port-Harcourt.

Richard S. (1977), The Fall of Public Man, P, 39, ISBN 0-14-100757-5.

Siskia Sassen (1991), The Gioba! city, Mew York, London/ Tokyo, (Princeton): Princeton University Press, 1991), 1^st edition, ISBN

0-691-07063-6

Daily writing prompt

How can you build a regular fitness routine?

View all responses

Evaluating Occupational Health and Safety Compliance and Enforcement Mechanisms in Nigeria’s Manufacturing Sector

Citation

EGBEGI, F. R. (2026). Evaluating Occupational Health and Safety Compliance and Enforcement Mechanisms in Nigeria’s Manufacturing Sector. International Journal for Social Studies, 12(2), 60–67. https://doi.org/10.26643/ijss/10

EGBEGI, Friday Raphael

Department of Sociology and Anthropology,

Enugu State University of Science and Technology,

Enugu, Nigeria

Abstract

Nigeria has a rather robust regulatory framework for occupational health and safety in the manufacturing sector that includes national laws, international agreements, and policy guidelines. However, the main causes of the continued low level of compliance include the large informal sectors, ignorance, budgetary constraints, and inadequate enforcement measures. The study comes to the conclusion that while key regulatory bodies like the Federal Ministry of Labour and Employment, the National Industrial Safety Council of Nigeria (NISCN), and the Occupational Safety and Health Department (OSHD) play crucial roles in enforcing OHS regulations, they face systemic problems like corruption, inadequate inspection capacity, and outdated legal frameworks. The findings highlight the vital need for strengthening regulatory agencies, increasing public awareness, providing incentives for compliance, and enacting more severe legal penalties in order to bridge the gap between OHS legislation and actual implementation.

Keywords: Compliance, Enforcement mechanisms, Labour regulation, Legal framework, Workplace hazards

Introduction

Particularly in high-risk sectors like manufacturing, occupational health and safety (OHS) is a crucial part of labour laws. According to Saka and Olanipekun (2021), Nigeria’s manufacturing sector is essential to the country’s economic development because it significantly boosts employment, industrialisation, and GDP growth. However, due to the extensive use of heavy machinery, exposure to toxic materials, repetitive physical tasks, and hazardous working circumstances, this industry is beset by a number of occupational hazards (Almaskati et al., 2024). Mechanical injuries, respiratory issues from chemical exposure, loud noises, poor ventilation, and ergonomic difficulties are among the risks that factory workers frequently encounter. These risks may lead to fatalities, long-term health issues, and occupational accidents. Given these concerns, establishing a safe and healthy workplace must be a top priority. This is both morally and legally necessary for long-term economic development and worker safety.Nigeria has passed a number of laws and regulations to shield employees from workplace hazards because it recognises the significance of OHS. Standards for workplace safety, employer obligations, and employee rights are provided by significant laws such as the Factories Act (2004), Labour Act (2004), Employee Compensation Act (2010), and National Policy on Occupational Safety and Health (2020) (Ememobong & Akpan, 2020). Nigeria has also accepted international agreements, such as Convention No. 155 on Occupational Safety and Health of the International Labour Organization (ILO), which emphasises the significance of strict regulations (ILO, 2022). Despite these legal frameworks, securing workplace safety in Nigeria’s manufacturing sector is still very difficult due to lax enforcement, little government oversight, low employer compliance, and low worker awareness. Preventable deaths, ongoing workplace injuries, and monetary losses from lower output and compensation claims have all resulted from the ongoing discrepancy between legal standards and real enforcement.The capacity of regulatory organisations like the Occupational Safety and Health Department (OSHD), the National Industrial Safety Council of Nigeria (NISCN), and the Federal Ministry of Labour and Employment to uphold and implement OHS laws in Nigeria is a significant obstacle. These organisations find it challenging to conduct regular inspections and implement safety laws due to issues such insufficient budget, a small workforce, corruption, and inefficient bureaucracy (Umeokafor, 2014). Additionally, many employers—especially those in the unorganised sector—disregard safety rules in order to increase profits, and employees may be unwilling to report hazardous workplaces due to job instability (Onwo & Ohazulike, 2021). This condition increases occupational risks and reduces the efficacy of current rules.A strong and well-enforced legislative framework for OHS is essential, especially as Nigeria seeks to expand its industrial sector and attract foreign investment. A variety of tactics are needed to overcome these challenges, such as strengthening regulatory agencies, enforcing harsher penalties for infractions, increasing public awareness campaigns, and promoting collaboration between the government, labour unions, and business sector organisations (Muhammed, 2021). The existing legal framework governing OHS in Nigeria’s manufacturing sector is examined in this article. A deeper comprehension of the intricacies of occupational health and safety regulations in the manufacturing sector will help policymakers, industry participants, and enforcement agencies better protect sustainable industrial development, boost productivity, and protect worker welfare.

Nigeria’s manufacturing sector faces difficulties adhering to occupational health and safety (OHS) regulations

Although Nigeria has a legal framework for occupational health and safety (OHS), the manufacturing sector’s reality is somewhat different. Ngwama (2016) claims that a large number of factories do not comply with fundamental safety regulations, demonstrating that compliance is still inadequate. Low awareness, lax enforcement, financial restrictions, and the informal nature of a significant component of the industry are the main causes of this predicament. Each of these elements is necessary to maintain hazardous working conditions in the industry, as can be shown below.

The unorganised sector: secret security

Because a significant portion of Nigeria’s manufacturing sector operates outside of the official regulatory framework, OHS regulation is particularly challenging (Olujobi, 2021). Small-scale workshops, roadside factories, and home-based production units continue to flout safety and employment requirements despite making up a significant section of the industry. Mujtaba & Kaifi (2023) state that most of these businesses are not officially registered with government agencies. It is implied that they do not undergo workplace safety inspections or receive instruction on compliance. Many of them operate in makeshift buildings without proper ventilation, fire exits, or emergency response plans. Workers in these settings are regularly exposed to hazardous chemicals, high temperatures, and hazardous machines without any protective clothing. Additionally, worker rights are rarely respected because the majority of workplaces are informal. Workers have little negotiating power and job stability, according to Xhafa and Serrano (2024).

Lack of knowledge: a society that is careless and uninformed

According to Kamoli et al. (2021), one of the biggest barriers to OHS compliance in Nigeria’s manufacturing sector is the pervasive ignorance among employers and workers. Many plant owners and managers do not fully understand the legal standards for workplace safety, and workers themselves often do not know their rights surrounding occupational health. Because of this, many employers see safety compliance as a bureaucratic burden rather than a need, especially those in charge of small and medium-sized firms (SMEs) (Nieuwenhuizen, 2019). Without sufficient sensitisation, some persons are really ignorant of the extent of their legal obligations. Others may think that official, legally recognised standards are unnecessary and that workplace safety is only a matter of individual responsibility and common sense.

Financial constraints: the cost of compliance

Financial limitations are a major factor in Nigeria’s manufacturing sector’s low OHS regulatory compliance rates. Many business owners, especially those in small and medium-sized enterprises, see safety regulations as an expensive requirement that affects their final product (Kitching et al., 2015). Spending money on machine guards, ventilation systems, fire safety installations, personal protective equipment (PPE), and frequent safety training is necessary to implement proper workplace safety measures, according to Patel et al. (2022). For instance, in companies already struggling with high production costs because of unpredictable power supplies, high taxes, and fluctuating raw material prices, spending on safety is sometimes seen as an unnecessary expense rather than a long-term investment (Patel et al., 2022). Some plant owners may deliberately take short cuts in order to reduce operational costs. Instead of making the necessary investments in safety equipment, they may repurpose old or damaged PPE or require employees to buy their own protective gear, which many cannot afford.

Ineffective laws and weak enforcement methods

Even if employers are aware of OHS requirements, Segbenya and Yeboah (2022) argue that there is little likelihood that they will face serious consequences for non-compliance. Nigeria’s largely ineffective enforcement mechanisms are to blame for this. Meanwhile, Umeokafor (2014) contends that the Federal Ministry of Labour and Employment and other regulatory bodies lack the institutional capacity, staff, and resources required to carry out routine factory inspections and enforce compliance. One major issue in Nigeria is the lack of labour inspectors relative to the number of businesses. Maintaining regular inspections is difficult with thousands of industrial businesses spread across the country. Since some factories are not inspected for years, unsafe practices may go unnoticed. Umeokafor (2014) claims that rather than keeping an eye on compliance with safety regulations, labour inspectors regularly ask businesses for bribes.

Africa’s Occupational Safety and Health

Even though OHS has advanced significantly in wealthier countries, Africa still faces substantial challenges in implementing comprehensive workplace safety legislation. Due to inadequate enforcement, poor legal frameworks, and a high percentage of informal employment, where safety laws are largely disregarded, OHS regularly encounters difficulties in Africa (Onyenechere et al., 2022).Occupational health and safety (OHS) frameworks have been attempted throughout Africa, but their successful implementation has been hampered by a number of persistent issues. According to Wilcox (2021), insufficient institutional capacity is a significant barrier to OHS adoption in Africa. Many governments are said to lack the infrastructure, resources, and expertise needed to carry out workplace safety regulations. Kohn et al. (2023) noted that despite the existence of OHS law, regulatory agencies often encounter difficulties because of a lack of personnel, antiquated enforcement techniques, and inadequate coordination among relevant institutions. Inadequate compliance results from businesses continuing to operate without adhering to safety standards, especially in high-risk industries like mining, construction, and agriculture.The frequency of informal work is one major barrier. Christiaensen and Maertens (2022) claim that a sizable portion of Africa’s working population operates outside of established legal and regulatory frameworks. Upholding OHS standards is difficult since jobs in the informal sector, such as street vending, domestic work, artisanal mining, and small-scale agriculture, may not have legal safeguards. According to research, workers in these sectors frequently come into contact with hazardous products, malfunctioning equipment, and extreme weather, and they are not provided with any legal protections or compensation in the event that they become ill or are injured (Abdalla et al., 2017). It is more difficult for authorities to monitor working conditions or ensure that safety procedures are followed because many jobs are informal.Many African countries still struggle to effectively incorporate occupational health and safety into their national labour policies, despite the fact that some, like South Africa, have made significant strides in enacting stringent OHS regulations and enforcement procedures. OHS has advanced significantly in South Africa as a result of extensive

An multinational perspective on workplace health and safety frameworks

Numerous worldwide bodies have created policies, guidelines, and legislative frameworks to raise Occupational Health and Safety (OHS) standards across a range of industries and nations in recognition of the significance of workplace safety on a global scale. By reducing workplace accidents, health risks, and fatalities, these frameworks seek to provide polite, safe, and productive work environments (Schulte et al., 2022). According to Alli (2008), the International Labour Organization (ILO) has been a prominent supporter of occupational health and safety (OHS). To assist national governments in creating their OHS regulations, it creates technical standards, legally enforceable agreements, and non-binding recommendations. The ILO’s programs are based on the fundamental principle that every worker has a right to a safe and healthy workplace. To do this, the organization works with governments, companies, and employees to develop OHS rules suitable for different national situations.

Conclusion

Nigeria has a fairly strong framework of national laws, international agreements, and policy guidelines governing occupational health and safety in the manufacturing industry. However, the extensive informal sectors, illiteracy, financial limitations, and insufficient enforcement methods are the primary causes of the ongoing low level of compliance. The study concludes that although important regulatory organisations such as the Occupational Safety and Health Department (OSHD), the National Industrial Safety Council of Nigeria (NISCN), and the Federal Ministry of Labour and Employment play vital roles in enforcing OHS regulations, they confront systemic issues such as corruption, insufficient inspection capacity, and antiquated legal frameworks.

References

Ajah, B. O. (2026). Cultural Syncretism and Crime: Exploring the Blending of Indigenous Practices and Modern Criminality in Uganda. Journal of Somali Studies (JOSS), 13(1), 1- 25.

Ajah, B. O., & Magadze, T. O. (2026). State Failure and the Rise of Organised Crime: A Case Study of Governance Gaps in Nigeria. African Renaissance, 23(1), 123-144.

Ajah, B. O., & Magadze, T. O. (2026). Combating Transnational Crime: Evaluating the Role of ECOWAS in West African Security Architecture. An-Najah University Journal for Research – B Humanities, 40(2), 1-15.

Ajah, B. O., Onyejegbu, C. O., Isife, C. T., Enweonwu, O. A., Chinweze, C. C., Anyadike, N. K., Ilo, K. O., Omaliko, J. C., Asadu, N., Ugwu, C. C. O., Okemini, O. O., Leweanya, K. C., Ohabuenyi, J., Uzoigwe, O. U., Iloma, O., Madubuko, J. C., & Ngwu, G. E. (2026). Narrative accounts, feelings, and perceptions of yahoo-plus offenders in Enugu and Abakaliki correctional centers, Nigeria. International Journal of Law, Crime and Justice, 84, 1-12. DOI: https://doi.org/10.1016/j.ijlcj.2025.100823

Asogwa, U., Ajah, B. O., Okpa, J. T., Ugwu, I. P., Nnamani, R. G., & Okorie, A. (2023). Examining the views and opinions of itinerary-traders on adherence to covid-19 lockdown in Enugu State, Nigeria. Fudan Journal of the Humanities and Social Sciences, 16, 1-24. doi: 10.1007/s40647-023-00376-y

Ezeanya, O.C.P., Ajah, B. O., Okpa, J.T., Chinweze, U. C., Onyejegbu, D.C., Enweonwu, O. A., & Obiwulu, A. C. (2023). Elite complicity in the non-egalitarian structures, occasioning violence and anarchy in the Nigerian State. African Renaissance, 20(1), 77- 92.

Okpa, J.T., Ugwuoke, C.U., Ajah, O. B*., Eshioste, E., Igbe, J. E., Ajor, O.J., Ofem, N.O., Eteng, M.J., & Nnamani, R.G. (2022). Cyberspace, black-hat hacking and economic sustainability of corporate organizations in Cross-River State, Nigeria. SAGE OPEN. 10.1177/21582440221122739.

Okpa, J. T., Ajah, B. O., Nzeakor, O.F., Eshioste, E., & Abang, T.A. (2022). Business E-mail compromise scam, cyber victimisation and economic sustainability of corporate organisations in Nigeria. Security Journal, 1-22. https://doi.org/10.1057/s41284-022- 00342-5

Iloma, D.O., Nnam, M. U., Effiong, J. E., Eteng, M. J., Okechukwu, G. P., & Ajah, B. O. (2022). Exploring socio-demographic factors, avoiding being a victim and fear of crime in a Nigerian university. Security Journal, 1-20. https://doi.org/10.1057/s41284-022- 00336-3

Ajah, B. O., Chinweze, U.C., Ajah, A.I., Onyejegbu, D.C., Obiwulu, A., Onwuama, E.M., & Okpa, J. T. (2022). Behind bars but not sentenced: the role of computerized central repository in addressing awaiting-trial problems in Ebonyi state, Nigeria. SAGE Open, 12(1). https://doi.org/10.1177/21582440221079822

Ajah, L.O., Ajah, M. I., Ajah, B. O., Onwe, E. O., Ozumba, B.C., Iyoke, C.A., & Nwankwo, T.C. (2022). A 20 Year retrospective review of rape pattern in Ebonyi State, South-East Nigeria. Heliyon, 8, e08894. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.heliyon.2022.e08894

Ezeanya, O.C.P., Ajah, B. O., Ibenwa, C.N., Onuorah, C. & Eze, U. (2022). A critical analysis of the impact of religion on the Nigerian struggle for nationhood. HTS Teologiese Studies/Theological Studies, 78(4), a7225. https://doi.org/10.4102/hts. v78i4.7225.

Ajah, B. O., Nnam, M. U., Ajah, I. A., Idemili-Aronu, N., Chukwuemeka, O. D., & Agboti, C. I. (2021). Investigating the awareness of virtual and augmented realities as a criminal justice response to the plight of awaiting-trial inmates in Ebonyi State, Nigeria. Crime, Law and Social Change, DOI:10.1007/s10611-021-09988-5.

Eze, O.J., Ajah, B. O., Nwonovo, O. S., & Atama, C.S. (2021). Health sector corruption and COVID-19 outbreak: evidence from Anambra and Enugu States, Nigeria. Journal of Contemporary African Studies, 40(1), 34-46. DOI:10.1080/02589001.2021.1921129

Nnam, M.U., Effiong, J.E., Iloma, D.O., Terfa, I.M., & Ajah, B. O. (2021). Hazardous drinking and the dark triad: an antidote for manipulative behaviour among students. Current Psychology, 40(4), 1-7.

Anthony, E.O., Obasi, C.O., Obi, D.O., Ajah, B. O., Okpan, O.S., Onyejegbu, C.D. et al., (2021). Exploring the reasons for perennial attacks on churches in Nigeria through the victims’ perspective. HTS Teologiese Studies/Theological Studies, 77(1), a6207.

Ezeanya, O. C. P. & Ajah, B. O. (2021). Addressing the biblical and ecclesial obligation of Nigerian Roman-Catholic priests in promotion of peace and social justice. HTS Teologiese Studies/ Theological Studies, 77(4), a7138. https://doi.org/10.4102/hts.v77i4.7138

Nnamani, G. R., Ilo, K. O., Onyejegbu, D. C., Ajah, B. O., Onwuama, M. E., Obiwulu, A. C., & Nzeakor, O. F. (2021). Use of noncustodial measure and independent monitoring body as panacea to awaiting-trial problems in Ebonyi State, Nigeria. International Journal of Criminal Justice Sciences, 16(1), 51-63.

Ugwuoke, C. O., Ajah, B. O., & Onyejegbu, C. D. (2020). Developing patterns of violent crimes in Nigerian democratic transitions. Aggression and Violent Behavior, 53, 1-8.

Ajah, B. O., Ajah, A.I., & Obasi, C. O. (2020). Application of virtual reality (VR) and augmented reality (AR) in the investigation and trial of herdsmen terrorism in Nigeria. International Journal of Criminal Justice Sciences, 15(1), 1-20.

Okpa, J.T., Ajah, B. O., & Igbe, J. E. (2020). Rising trend of phishing attacks on corporate organisations in Cross River State, Nigeria. International Journal of Cyber Criminology, 14(2), 460–478.

Ajah, B. O., Dinne, C.E., & Salami, K. K. (2020). Terrorism in contemporary Nigerian society: conquest of Boko-Haram, myth or reality. International Journal of Criminal Justice Sciences, 15(1), 312-324.

Eze, O. J., Obi, D. O., & Ajah, B. O. (2020). Nigerian criminal justice system and victims of crime neglect in Enugu Urban. FWU Journal of Social Sciences 14(3), 41-53.

Ajah, B. O*, Uwakwe, E. E., Nwokeoma, B. N., Ugwuoke C. O., & Nnnamani, R. G. (2020). Ameliorating the plight of awaiting-trial inmates in ebonyi state, nigeria through reasonable bail condition. Pertanika Jounal of Social Sciences & Humanities, 28(4), 2897 – 2911.

Areh, C. E., Onwuama, E. M., & Ajah, B. O. (2020). Social consequences of wife-battering in Ogbaru and Onitsha North Local Government Areas of Anambra State, Nigeria. FWU Journal of Social Sciences, 14(4), 80-92.

Ajah, B. O., & Okpa, J. T. (2019). Digitization as a solution to the problem of awaiting-trial inmates in Ebonyi State, Nigeria. International Journal of Criminal Justice Sciences, 14(2), 199–207.

Ajah, B. O., & Onyejegbu, D. C. (2019). Neo-economy and militating effects of Africa’s profile on cybercrime. International Journal of Cyber Criminology, 13(2), 326–342.

Nnam, M. U., Ajah, B. O., Arua, C. C., Okechukwu, G., & Okorie, C. O. (2019). The war must be sustained: an integrated theoretical perspective of the cyberspace-Boko Haram terrorism nexus in Nigeria. International Journal of Cyber Criminology, 13(2), 379–395.

Ajah, B. O. (2018). Educational training of inmates in Awka and Abakaliki prisons, Nigeria. International Journal of Criminal Justice Sciences, 13(2), 299–305.

Ajah, B. O., & Ugwuoke, C. O. (2018). Juvenile justice administration and child prisoners in Nigeria. International Journal of Criminal Justice Sciences, 13(2), 438–446.

Enweonwu, O. A., Ugwu, I. P., Onyejegbu, D. C., Areh, C. E., & Ajah, B. O. (2021). Religious fanaticism and changing patterns of violent Crime in Nigeria. International Journal of Criminology and Sociology, 10, 1378–1389. https://doi.org/10.6000/1929- 4409.2021.10.158

Onyejegbu, D. C., Onwuama, E. M., Onah, C. I., Okpa, J. T., & Ajah, B. O. (2021). Special courts as Nigerian criminal justice response to the plight of awaiting trial inmates in Ebonyi State, Nigeria. International Journal of Criminology and Sociology, 10, 1172- 1177. https://doi.org/10.6000/1929-4409.2021.10.136

Nwadike, N. C., Okpa, J. T., Ofem, N. O., Ajah, B. O., Chinweze, U. C., & Isife, C. T. (2023). Socio-cultural practices and stress among working mothers of underage children in Nigeria Public Universities. Rupkatha Journal on Interdisciplinary Studies in Humanities, 15(3), 1-23.

Areh, C. E., Ajah, B. O., Ezeanya, O. C. P., Eze, A. U., Onwuchekwa, S. I., & Onyejegbu, C. D. (2021). The Troubling Epidemic of Wife-Battering in Ogbaru and Onitsha North Local Government Areas of Anambra State, Nigeria. International Journal of Criminology and Sociology, 10, 1349-1361.

Nzeakor, O. F., Nwokeoma, B. N., Hassan, I. M., Ajah, B. O., & Okpa, J. T. (2022). Emerging Trends in Cyber ends in Cybercrime A crime Awareness in Nigeria. International Journal of Cybersecurity Intelligence & Cybercrime, 5(3), 41-67.

Onwuama, O. P., Ajah, O. B., Asadu, N., Ebimgbo, S. O., Odii, A., & Okpara, K. C (2019). Public perception of police performance in crimes control in Anambra state of Nigeria. African Journal of Law and Criminology, 9(1) 17-26.

Ajah, B. O., Eze, O. J., & Okpa, J. T. (2024). Reforming the Nigeria Criminal Justice System. Rowman & Littlefield.

Okpa, J. T., *Ajah, B. O*., Eze, O. J., & Enweonwu, O. A. (2022). Communal conflict and violence: Causes and impact. In C. Martin, V. R. Preedy and V. B. Patel (eds) Handbook of Anger, Aggression, and Violence. Springer, Cham. https://doi.org/10.1007/978-3-030- 98711-4_184-1

Eze, O.J., *Ajah, B.O.*, Okpa, J.T., Ngwu, G. E. (2023). Ethnic-based violence: Nigeria perspectives. In: Martin, C., V. R. Preedy and V. B. Patel (Eds), Handbook of anger, aggression, and violence. Springer, Cham. https://doi.org/10.1007/978-3-030-98711- 4_182-2

Eze, J.O., Okpa, J.T., Onyejegbu, C.D., & *Ajah, B. O*. (2022). Cybercrime: victims’ shock absorption mechanisms. UK: IntechOpen. doi: 10.5772/intechopen.106818.

Alawari, B. M., & Ajah, O. B. (2017). Understanding the gender dimensions of cyberbullying among undergraduates in Nigeria. (A Book Chapter). Ahmadu Bello University Press Limited, Zaria.

Daily writing prompt

If you could erase one movie from your memory and watch it again for the first time, which one would it be?

View all responses

The Role of Motivation in Learning: A study of its impact on students of secondary schools in Aba State.

The Role of Motivation in Learning: A study of its impact on students of secondary schools in Aba State.

Betty Nansikombi

Department of Education

National Institute for Nigerian Languages, Aba.

mailbetty@gmail.com

Abstract

This research investigates the multifaceted role of motivation in the secondary educational landscape of Aba State, Nigeria, employing a qualitative research methodology to elucidate the nuanced interplay between psychosocial drivers and academic achievement. By utilizing semi-structured interviews and thematic analysis, the study explores how motivational constructs are uniquely mediated by local socio-cultural imperatives. The findings confirm that motivation within this region is fundamentally rooted in a collectivist framework, standing in stark contrast to the individualistic paradigms prevalent in Western educational theory. The analysis demonstrates that academic performance is optimized when a symbiotic alignment exists between a students internal aspirations and the external support structures provided by familial, peer, and communal networks. This suggests that academic success is not merely an autonomous endeavor but a communal achievement. However, the study identifies significant pedagogical risks, specifically regarding the potential for an over-reliance on extrinsic rewards. Such mechanisms may inadvertently cultivate a performance-oriented mindset, prioritizing superficial grade attainment over the cognitive depth inherent in intrinsic engagement. Furthermore, the data reveals that the interaction between academic ability and motivational orientation necessitates a highly nuanced instructional approach; students lacking intrinsic drive are notably vulnerable to psychological disengagement if their dependence on external validation remains unmanaged. Consequently, this research advocates for an educational framework that honors the cultural richness of Aba State while simultaneously fostering the self-efficacy and internal intellectual curiosity required for long-term professional success. By bridging the gap between communal expectations and individual cognitive development, educators can facilitate a more resilient learning environment, ultimately enhancing the efficacy of secondary education within the region.

Keywords: Motivation, Secondary School’s, Aba State, Students, Learning

Introduction

Motivation is a fundamental element in the learning process, significantly influencing students’ engagement, persistence, and overall academic success. It serves as the driving force behind students’ willingness to learn, participate in class, and strive to achieve their educational goals. In the context of secondary schools, where students experience significant academic and social pressures, understanding motivation becomes crucial for educators and policymakers. This study aims to explore the role of motivation in learning and its impact on secondary school students in Aba State, Nigeria.

The dichotomy between intrinsic and extrinsic motivation provides a useful framework for examining student engagement. Intrinsic motivation refers to the way in which individuals engage in activities for the inherent satisfaction and enjoyment they derive from them, while extrinsic motivation involves performing activities to achieve external rewards or avoid negative consequences (Ryan & Deci, 2020). Research indicates that intrinsic motivation is generally linked to deeper learning, greater creativity, and sustained engagement in educational settings (Deci et al., 2019). Given the unique socio-cultural and economic landscape in Aba State, understanding the factors that influence both types of motivation could lead to enhanced educational practices and outcomes.

While intrinsic motivation has been shown to correlate with heightened academic success, recent studies highlight how extrinsic factors also play an important role in shaping students’ experiences. For instance, Akinola and Ndubuisi (2021) describe how parental expectations, teacher support, and peer interactions can either stoke or diminish student motivation. In Aba State, where many families face economic constraints, external motivators such as peer pressure and societal norms may heavily influence students’ academic motivation. This influence can lead to students prioritizing grades and external accolades over genuine interest in learning, which may, in turn, compromise the quality of their educational experiences (Nwankwo & Kalu, 2022).

Furthermore, the role of teachers in fostering motivation cannot be overstated. Research indicates that teachers who employ motivational strategiessuch as setting achievable goals, providing positive feedback, and creating an inclusive classroom environmentcan significantly enhance students’ intrinsic motivation (Lpez & Crespo, 2021). This is particularly salient in secondary schools where teaching approaches can either foster a love of learning or lead to disillusionment. Teachers in Aba State schools face unique challenges, including limited resources and varying levels of training, which may affect their ability to motivate students effectively.

Cultural factors also come into play when considering the motivation of secondary school students in Aba State. Okechukwu (2021) emphasizes that the values, beliefs, and aspirations prevalent in the community can foster or hinder student motivation. In many Nigerian communities, there may be a strong emphasis on academic achievement as a pathway to social mobility. However, the correlation between high expectations and student stress levels cannot be overlooked. High-stakes testing and societal pressure for academic excellence can inadvertently diminish intrinsic motivation, causing students to engage in rote learning rather than fostering a genuine interest in their studies (Chiemeke, 2023).

In exploring the dimensions of motivation within the context of secondary education in Aba State, this study will also consider the psychological aspects of motivation. Factors such as self-efficacythe belief in ones capabilities to execute behaviors required to produce specific achievementsplay a significant role in academic motivation (Bandura, 2018). Students who perceive themselves as capable are more likely to engage in challenging tasks and persist in the face of difficulties. Conversely, low self-efficacy can lead to a lack of motivation and engagement, resulting in suboptimal academic performance (Nwankwo & Kalu, 2022).

Moreover, the consequences of motivation extend beyond academic performance; they also include social and emotional well-being. Research has shown that motivated students tend to exhibit higher levels of self-esteem and emotional regulation, which can positively influence their interpersonal relationships (Akinola & Ndubuisi, 2021). Given the importance of social interactions during adolescent years, understanding how motivation impacts not only academic performance but also students’ emotional and social development is crucial for a holistic view of education in Aba State.

Additionally, the increasing integration of technology in education presents a new landscape for motivation. The pandemic has accelerated this trend, leading to a greater reliance on online learning platforms. While technology can serve as a tool for enhancing engagement, it also raises questions about students’ intrinsic versus extrinsic motivation. Research suggests that technology-driven learning can either foster independence and self-directed learning or lead to disengagement and distraction, depending on how it is incorporated into the educational framework (Lpez & Crespo, 2021).

In summary, motivation emerges as a multifaceted construct that significantly influences secondary school students’ learning experiences in Aba State. By examining both intrinsic and extrinsic motivational factors, this study aims to provide insights into how motivation affects not only academic achievement but also the overall well-being of students. Recognizing the role of cultural, social, and technological influences will be essential in understanding the complex dynamics of student motivation in this specific context. Ultimately, the findings could offer valuable recommendations for educators and policymakers to foster a more engaging and supportive learning environment for secondary school students in Aba State.

Statement of the problem

The role of motivation in learning is a pivotal area of study, particularly in the context of secondary education, where students undergo significant cognitive and emotional developments. This research focuses on understanding the impact of motivation on students in secondary schools in Aba State. Despite existing literature addressing the general influence of motivation on learning outcomes, two critical gaps warrant further investigation.

Gap 1: Cultural Context of Motivation Factors

Current research often emphasizes motivational theories that may not fully consider the unique socio-cultural and economic context of students in Aba State. Many studies have been conducted in Western educational settings, where motivational drivers differ significantly from those in a Nigerian context. Specifically, the role of community, family expectations, and socio-economic factors in shaping motivation remains underexplored. This research aims to identify culturally relevant motivational drivers that specifically affect students in this region.

Gap 2: Differentiated Impact on Diverse Student Demographics

While motivation is widely recognized as a key influence on academic success, the differentiated impact of motivational types (intrinsic vs. extrinsic) on various student demographics such as gender, socio-economic status, and academic ability has received limited attention in the literature. In secondary schools in Aba State, it is crucial to understand how these factors interact to influence individual student learning experiences and outcomes. This study aims to fill this gap by investigating how different motivational factors affect diverse groups of students within the secondary education system.

Objective of the Study

1. To identify and examine the culturally relevant motivational factors that affect the learning outcomes of secondary school students in Aba State and to compare these factors with those documented in Western educational contexts.

2. To explore the influence of community and family expectations on the academic motivation of secondary school students in Aba State, identifying specific socio-cultural elements that enhance or hinder this motivation.

3. To examine the differential impacts of intrinsic and extrinsic motivation on academic performance among secondary school students in Aba State, with a focus on variations across demographic factors such as gender and socio-economic status.

4. To investigate how different motivational types interact with students’ academic abilities and to evaluate their collective influence on learning experiences and outcomes in secondary schools within Aba State.

Significance of the study

1. Culturally Tailored Educational Strategies

This research will contribute valuable insights into the unique motivational drivers of students in Aba State. By understanding how socio-cultural and economic contexts influence motivation, educators and policymakers can develop culturally tailored strategies that enhance student engagement and learning outcomes. Such strategies can be rooted in local values and community expectations, thereby fostering a more supportive educational environment that resonates with students.

2. Enhanced Educational Equity

By examining the differentiated impact of motivational types across diverse student demographics, the study will inform educators about the varying needs of students based on gender, socio-economic status, and academic ability. This understanding can lead to the design of more equitable educational interventions that address specific motivational barriers faced by different groups. Ultimately, this can enhance academic success and reduce disparities in educational achievement, fostering a more inclusive learning atmosphere.

3. Foundation for Future Research

The identification of gaps in the existing literature not only highlights the necessity for this study but also lays the groundwork for future research in the field of motivation and learning. By addressing these areas, this research will encourage further exploration of motivation in diverse educational contexts, particularly in underrepresented regions like Aba State. This can lead to an expanded body of literature that benefits educational psychology and policy-making, offering deeper insights into effective motivational strategies in various cultural settings.

Research Questions

1. What are the culturally relevant motivational factors that influence learning outcomes for secondary school students in Aba State, and how do these factors differ from those identified in Western educational contexts?

2. How do community and family expectations shape the academic motivation of secondary school students in Aba State, and what specific socio-cultural elements enhance or undermine this motivation?

3. What are the differential impacts of intrinsic and extrinsic motivation on academic performance among secondary school students in Aba State, particularly across different demographic factors such as gender and socio-economic status?

4. How do various motivational types interact with students’ academic abilities to influence learning experiences and outcomes in secondary schools within Aba State?

Literature Review

Motivation and Academic Performance

Motivation plays a crucial role in shaping students’ academic outcomes. According to Okwor and Agbo (2018), intrinsic motivation significantly correlates with higher academic performance among secondary school students in Nigeria. This study emphasizes the impact of self-determination and personal interest in the learning process. Furthermore, Eze and Amah (2020) highlight that extrinsic motivators such as rewards and recognition can also stimulate students’ engagement, though their effect tends to diminish over time.

Theoretical Framework of Motivation

Theories of motivation, such as Self-Determination Theory (SDT), provide foundational insights into how motivation influences learning. Ryan and Deci (2020) argue that students who perceive their education as autonomous and self-directed are more likely to adopt engaging learning strategies, resulting in improved academic performance. Additionally, Akpan and Eyo (2021) apply SDT to examine how relevant curriculum content affects motivation among secondary school students in Aba State, suggesting that aligning curriculum with students interests enhances intrinsic motivation.

Classroom Environment and Motivation

The classroom environment significantly influences student motivation, with factors like teacher support and peer relationships playing crucial roles. Ogbondah (2019) found that a supportive classroom atmosphere fosters engagement and promotes intrinsic motivation among students. Moreover, Chukwu and Nwafor (2022) emphasize the importance of collaborative learning environments in secondary schools in enhancing motivation levels, asserting that interactions with peers can act as strong motivators for students.

Technology and Motivation

The integration of technology in education has been shown to enhance student motivation. Nwankwo et al. (2023) discussed how digital platforms increase engagement and foster a sense of autonomy among students in their learning processes. Similarly, Ifeanyi and Okoro (2025) highlighted the trend of gamified learning experiences that encourage motivation and participation in secondary schools.

Socio-Cultural Factors

Socio-cultural factors significantly influence motivation among secondary school students. According to Uche and Ndubuisi (2021), cultural values, family expectations, and societal influences play a critical role in shaping students’ motivation toward learning. These factors differ across regions, impacting students in Aba State distinctively. Furthermore, Afolabi & Chinenye (2024) emphasize the importance of community support in enhancing students’ motivation, noting that external encouragement can significantly uplift student morale and commitment to academic pursuits.

Interventions to Enhance Motivation

Intervention programs targeting motivation are essential for improving student outcomes. Johnson and Okafor (2026) present evidence from a study on motivational enhancement programs in secondary schools, illustrating significant improvements in student engagement and academic performance. They emphasize that such programs should be tailored to the specific needs of students in different demographic contexts, especially in regions like Aba State. Additionally, Nkemjika (2025) identifies the role of mentoring and counseling services in bolstering student motivation, advocating for more structured support systems in schools.

Empirical Review

The Influence of Intrinsic Motivation on Academic Achievement

A study conducted by Okeke and Aniemeka (2019) explored the relationship between intrinsic motivation and academic performance among secondary school students in Aba State. Using a sample of 300 students, the researchers applied a questionnaire measuring intrinsic motivation levels and correlated these with students’ academic achievements across various subjects. Findings indicated a strong positive correlation (r = 0.75, p < 0.01) between intrinsic motivation and academic success, suggesting that students who are internally motivated tend to achieve higher grades. The authors concluded that educators should focus on fostering intrinsic motivation to improve student outcomes.

External Motivators and Student Engagement

Nwoko and Adigwe (2020) investigated how external motivators, such as rewards and recognition, affect student engagement in secondary schools in Aba State. The researchers surveyed 250 students and analyzed the data using regression analysis. Results showed that external motivators significantly boost student engagement ( = 0.62, p < 0.01), especially in competitive environments. The study suggested that while intrinsic motivation is essential, external rewards can also play a crucial role in enhancing student participation and interest in learning.

Technology-Enhanced Learning and Student Motivation

A study by Ifeanyi et al. (2023) examined the impact of technology-enhanced learning on student motivation and academic performance in secondary schools in Aba State. Using a quasi-experimental design, the researchers implemented a technology-integrated curriculum in one school and compared student outcomes with a control group. The findings revealed that students in the experimental group demonstrated significantly higher motivation levels and academic performance (d = 1.1) compared to the control group. The authors concluded that incorporating technology into the curriculum can enhance motivation and learning outcomes.

Socio-Cultural Factors Affecting Motivation

Ugochukwu and Eke (2025) explored the socio-cultural factors affecting student motivation in secondary schools in Aba State through a mixed-methods approach. They conducted surveys with 500 students and followed up with focus group discussions. The findings indicated that family expectations, peer influence, and cultural values significantly impact students’ motivation levels. Quantitative data showed a correlation coefficient of 0.68 (p < 0.01) between perceived family support and intrinsic motivation. The research emphasized the need for broader educational interventions that consider socio-cultural contexts to enhance student motivation.

Theoretical Framework

Self-Determination Theory (SDT)

Self-Determination Theory (SDT), proposed by Ryan and Deci (2020), posits that human motivation is influenced by three intrinsic psychological needs: autonomy, competence, and relatedness. The framework suggests that when these needs are fulfilled, students are more likely to be intrinsically motivated and engage deeply in the learning process. In the context of secondary schools in Aba State, understanding how these factors contribute to student motivation can explain variations in academic performance.

Recent studies highlight the relevance of SDT in educational settings. For instance, Uche and Ndubuisi (2021) found that students who experience autonomy in their learning environment exhibit higher levels of intrinsic motivation, leading to improved academic outcomes. By applying SDT, this research will explore how fulfilling students psychological needs can enhance their motivation and academic performance in secondary schools.

Expectancy-Value Theory

Expectancy-Value Theory posits that students motivation is influenced by their expectations of success and the value they place on the tasks at hand (Eccles et al., 2019). According to this framework, students are more likely to engage in learning activities when they believe they can succeed and perceive the learning outcomes as valuable. This theory is particularly applicable in the context of secondary schools in Aba State, where academic performance is often influenced by students’ beliefs in their capabilities and the perceived relevance of their education.

Recent empirical studies have shown that students motivation is significantly affected by their expectations concerning success and the perceived importance of learning (Chukwu & Nwafor, 2022). By examining how these factors influence motivation and academic achievement, this research aims to provide insights into how educators can better support students in achieving their educational goals.

Research Methodology

This qualitative research aimed to explore specific socio-educational issues within Abia State, with a focus on the perceptions and experiences of secondary school students regarding their academic environment. Abia State, with a population of approximately 5,400,000, provided a diverse backdrop for this study. A purposive sampling technique was employed to select a sample size of 200 respondents from four secondary schools in the region. The selected schools were Government Technical College Aba, Ovom Girls High School Aba, Ngwa High School Aba, and National High School Aba.

Data Collection Methods

Data were collected through two primary qualitative methods: in-depth interviews and focus group discussions.

1. In-depth Interviews:

Individual interviews were conducted with a variety of stakeholders, including:

20 students from each of the four selected schools, totaling 80 students.

10 teachers from the four schools, who provided insights into the educational environment.

10 parents of the interviewed students, to understand familial influences on education.

10 education administrators from Abia State to give broader context regarding educational policies and challenges.

2. Focus Group Discussions:

Focus group discussions comprised smaller groups to facilitate dynamic interaction and deeper insights. The groups included:

4 separate groups of students, with each group consisting of 8 students (totaling 32 students) from different schools to ensure varied perspectives.

2 groups of teachers, with 6 teachers per group to discuss pedagogical approaches and school policies.

2 groups of parents, with 6 parents in each group to gain insights into their expectations and perceptions of the education system.

Ethical Considerations

Prior to conducting the research, ethical considerations were meticulously addressed. Informed consent was obtained from all participants, ensuring that they understood the purpose of the study and their rights, including the right to withdraw at any time. The anonymity and confidentiality of all respondents were strictly maintained throughout the research process. Participants were assured that their information would be used solely for the purposes of this study and would be reported in aggregate form. Additionally, the research received approval from relevant educational authorities and ethical review boards to ensure compliance with ethical standards in research involving human subjects.

This methodology provided a robust framework for understanding the educational dynamics within Abia State, facilitating a comprehensive analysis of the issues at hand.

Discussion and Finding:

Question 1: What are the culturally relevant motivational factors that influence learning outcomes for secondary school students in Aba State, and how do these factors differ from those identified in Western educational contexts?

Finding:

Culturally Relevant Motivational Factors Influencing Learning Outcomes for Secondary School Students in Aba State

In analyzing the culturally relevant motivational factors that influence learning outcomes for secondary school students in Aba State, it is essential to recognize the unique socio-cultural landscape of the region. The findings from our survey indicate that an overwhelming majority of respondents 75% strongly agreed and 20% agreed on the significance of specific motivational factors. Only 5% expressed uncertainty about the influences on student learning outcomes.

Key Motivational Factors Identified:

1. Community and Family Support:

In Aba State, the role of family and community support is paramount. Students often draw motivation from their families’ aspirations for them. This close-knit community environment fosters a sense of responsibility and determination to succeed, which contrasts with some Western contexts where individualism may overshadow communal values.

Cultural Identity and Heritage:

The emphasis on cultural identity and heritage significantly motivates students. Students in Aba often find strength in their cultural traditions and values, which serve to enhance their self-esteem and drive academic performance. In contrast, Western educational contexts may emphasize multiculturalism more broadly, where students are encouraged to draw from a wider range of cultural experiences.

Socio-Economic Factors:

Economic challenges can also serve as a double-edged sword in Aba State. While limited resources may create barriers, they can also motivate students to excel academically to improve their circumstances, a phenomenon that may differ from Western settings where educational resources are generally more accessible.

Extrinsic Rewards:

Opportunities for scholarships and other incentives motivate many students in Aba State. The prospect of financial assistance or job opportunities can be a powerful driver for academic achievement. In Western contexts, the focus may be more on intrinsic motivation and personal growth rather than immediate economic rewards.

Peer Influence and Competition:

Similar to many educational settings worldwide, peer influence plays a critical role in motivating students in Aba State. However, the nature of this influence often leans towards collective achievement rather than individual competition, contrasting with Western contexts where competition among peers may be more pronounced.

Comparison with Western Educational Contexts:

While both Aba State and Western educational settings recognize the importance of motivation in the learning process, the key differences lie in the underpinning cultural values. Western contexts may prioritize personal efficacy, autonomy, and a more pronounced individualistic approach to education. In contrast, secondary school students in Aba State often derive their motivation from communal ties, cultural identity, and a shared sense of purpose within their community.

Question 2: How do community and family expectations shape the academic motivation of secondary school students in Aba State, and what specific socio-cultural elements enhance or undermine this motivation?

Finding:

Community and family expectations play a significant role in shaping the academic motivation of secondary school students in Aba State. According to the findings, a substantial majority of respondents, 65%, strongly agreed that these expectations positively influence their motivation to perform well academically. Additionally, 30% also agreed, indicating a strong belief in the supportive role of these expectations.

Several socio-cultural elements contribute to enhancing or undermining this motivation:

Parental Involvement:

Active participation and support from parents significantly boost students’ motivation. When parents set high academic standards and are involved in their childrens education, it fosters a positive environment for learning.

Cultural Values:

The emphasis on education as a pathway to success in many Nigerian communities, including Aba State, can enhance motivation. Families often instill values that prioritize academic achievement, which encourages students to strive for excellence.

Peer Influence:

The opinions and attitudes of peers can also impact motivation. Positive peer reinforcement for academic success can enhance students drive to perform well, while negative behaviors may undermine motivation.

Socioeconomic Status:

Some families might have limited resources, which can create barriers to academic success and diminish motivation. Conversely, families with better socioeconomic conditions can provide support that fosters motivation.

Community Expectations:

In communities where educational attainment is highly valued, students may feel an intrinsic motivation to meet these expectations. However, unrealistic community pressures can lead to stress and anxiety, potentially undermining motivation.

The remaining 5% of respondents were unsure about the influence of these expectations, suggesting there may be individual variations in experiences or the complexity of relationships among these socio-cultural factors.

Question 3: What are the differential impacts of intrinsic and extrinsic motivation on academic performance among secondary school students in Aba State, particularly across different demographic factors such as gender and socio-economic status?

Finding:

The differential impacts of intrinsic and extrinsic motivation on academic performance among secondary school students in Aba State reveal significant insights, particularly when analyzed across various demographic factors such as gender and socio-economic status. According to the collected data, 63% of respondents strongly agreed that these motivational types greatly influence academic performance, with an additional 34% also agreeing, while only 3% remained uncertain.

Intrinsic Motivation:

This refers to the drive to succeed based on internal desires such as personal satisfaction, curiosity, and the joy of learning. Students who are intrinsically motivated generally exhibit higher academic performance, as their commitment to academic activities is based on personal interest and engagement rather than external rewards.

Gender Differences:

Studies indicate that females may often show higher levels of intrinsic motivation compared to males, leading to enhanced academic performance among girls in Aba State. This could be attributed to educational practices and cultural norms that foster a love for learning in female students.

Socio-Economic Status:

Students from higher socio-economic backgrounds may have more opportunities to engage in enriching educational experiences, thereby enhancing their intrinsic motivation. In contrast, economically disadvantaged students might face obstacles that limit their engagement in learning, potentially reducing their intrinsic motivation.

Extrinsic Motivation:

This involves external factors such as grades, rewards, and parental expectations. While extrinsic motivation can spur students to perform well, its long-term effectiveness may be less sustainable than intrinsic motivation.

Gender Differences:

Males may respond more favorably to extrinsic motivators like competition and recognition, which can lead to varying academic outcomes compared to females who might prioritize intrinsic aspects of learning.

Socio-Economic Status:

For students from lower socio-economic backgrounds, extrinsic motivators such as scholarships or parental approval might drive them toward academic success. However, this reliance on external rewards can sometimes overshadow intrinsic interests, potentially leading to burnout or disengagement.

Question 4: How do various motivational types interact with students’ academic abilities to influence learning experiences and outcomes in secondary schools within Aba State?

Finding:

The interaction between various motivational types and students’ academic abilities plays a crucial role in shaping learning experiences and outcomes in secondary schools within Aba State. Findings from the research indicate that 65% of respondents strongly agreed on this interaction’s significance, with 33% also agreeing, while only 2% were uncertain.

Types of Motivation:

Intrinsic Motivation:

This type stems from personal interest and enjoyment in the learning process. Students who are intrinsically motivated tend to engage more deeply with the material, often leading to improved understanding and retention of information. This commitment enhances their academic abilities, allowing them to perform better in assessments and overall learning experiences.

Extrinsic Motivation:

Extrinsic motivation involves external rewards or pressures, such as grades, praise, or parental expectations. While extrinsic motivators can encourage students to complete tasks or strive for high achievements, they may not always lead to meaningful learning. Students primarily driven by extrinsic factors might focus on the results rather than the learning process, which can limit deeper engagement.

Interaction with Academic Abilities:

The interplay between motivation types and academic abilities can significantly influence how students learn. For instance, a student with strong academic abilities who is intrinsically motivated may approach challenges with curiosity and a desire to master the subject. This can create a positive feedback loop where motivation enhances performance and vice versa.

Conversely, a student with lower academic abilities reliant on extrinsic motivation may struggle with self-efficacy, leading to disengagement if the rewards are not forthcoming or achievable. This scenario can result in poor learning outcomes and an overall negative learning experience.

Learning Experiences:

Motivational types can shape classroom dynamics, affecting both peer interactions and teacher-student relationships. Students who are motivated to learn typically create a more vibrant learning environment, contributing positively to group activities and discussions, which further benefits their academic abilities.

Overall Outcomes:

The interaction between motivation and academic abilities significantly affects academic outcomes, including grades, retention rates, and overall student satisfaction. Intrinsic motivation tends to yield more sustained academic success, while students who rely heavily on extrinsic motivation may experience fluctuations in performance based on external rewards.

Summary

This investigation into the role of motivation among secondary school students in Aba State, Nigeria, delineates a complex interplay between socio-cultural imperatives and psychological drivers of academic achievement. The empirical data, characterized by high levels of consensus among respondents (with agreement rates consistently exceeding 90% across various metrics), underscores that motivation in this region is not merely an individual cognitive state but a deeply communal phenomenon. The study identifies that familial expectations, cultural identity, and the socio-economic exigencies of the Aba environment serve as primary scaffolding for student engagement.

While intrinsic motivation defined by intellectual curiosity and personal satisfaction remains a potent predictor of sustained academic excellence, the research highlights a unique reliance on extrinsic motivators, such as communal recognition and the pursuit of scholarships as a vehicle for socio-economic mobility. Furthermore, the findings reveal significant demographic nuances, particularly regarding gender and socio-economic status, suggesting that the efficacy of these motivational levers is contingent upon the students baseline academic ability and access to resources. The synthesis of this data suggests that the educational landscape in Aba State is a hybrid model where collective cultural values and individual achievement aspirations are inextricably linked.

Conclusion

The research confirms that motivation in Aba State secondary schools is fundamentally grounded in a collectivist framework that contrasts sharply with the individualistic paradigms often observed in Western educational theory. The overarching conclusion is that academic performance is optimized when there is alignment between a students internal academic aspirations and the external support structures provided by family, peers, and the broader community.

However, the study also reveals potential pedagogical risks: an over-reliance on extrinsic rewards may inadvertently facilitate a performance-oriented mindset that prioritizes grades over the cognitive depth associated with intrinsic engagement. The interaction between academic ability and motivational type necessitates a nuanced approach to instruction; students who lack intrinsic drive are particularly vulnerable to disengagement if their reliance on external validation is not carefully managed. Ultimately, the study advocates for an educational framework that honors the cultural richness of Aba State while simultaneously fostering the self-efficacy and internal intellectual curiosity required for long-term academic and professional success.

Recommendations

1. Culturally Integrated Pedagogical Strategies:

Educators should design curricula that explicitly incorporate local cultural heritage and community values into lesson plans. By framing academic concepts within the context of regional identity, schools can stimulate intrinsic interest and enhance the perceived relevance of the curriculum.

2. Holistic Support Systems for Socio-Economic Disparity:

Given the finding that socio-economic status significantly impacts motivation, it is recommended that institutions establish robust scholarship programs and mentorship networks. These interventions should aim to decouple academic progress from financial instability, thereby reducing the “burnout” associated with purely extrinsic, survival-based motivation.

3. Promoting Intrinsic Engagement through Inquiry-Based Learning:

To mitigate the risks of a purely results-oriented academic culture, schools should transition toward inquiry-based learning models. This pedagogical shift encourages students to value the process of discovery, thereby fostering intrinsic motivation that is more resilient to the fluctuations of external rewards.

4. Parental and Community Engagement Workshops:

Schools should facilitate structured dialogues between educators, parents, and community leaders. The objective is to align community expectations with realistic academic goals, ensuring that the pressure to succeed is supportive rather than anxiety-inducing, thereby cultivating a healthier psychological environment for students.

5. Gender-Responsive Motivational Programming:

Recognizing the observed differences in motivational responses between genders, administrators should implement tailored extracurricular activities. Such programs should leverage the strengths of female students in intrinsic engagement while providing male students with structured, competitive, yet collaborative environments that channel their response to extrinsic recognition toward productive learning outcomes.

6. Longitudinal Assessment of Motivational Interventions:

It is recommended that educational stakeholders in Aba State implement longitudinal tracking of student motivation types in relation to academic outcomes. By utilizing the framework of $M_{total} = f(I, E, C)$, where $M$ represents total motivation as a function of intrinsic $(I)$, extrinsic $(E)$, and cultural $(C)$ variables, policymakers can refine interventions based on empirical performance data rather than anecdotal evidence.

References

Afolabi, F. O., & Chinenye, J. I. (2024). The influence of socio-cultural factors on students’ academic motivation in secondary schools in Aba State, Nigeria. Journal of Cultural Psychology, 8(1), 200-215. https://doi.org/10.1234/jcp.2024.81

Akinola, A. O., & Ndubuisi, G. (2021). Exploring the dynamics of intrinsic and extrinsic motivation among secondary school students. Journal of Educational Psychology, 113(2), 155-167. https://doi.org/10.1037/edu000045

Akpan, U. P., & Eyo, A. E. (2021). Relevance of curriculum content and its impact on students’ motivation in secondary schools: A study in Aba State, Nigeria. International Journal of Education and Research, 9(6), 200-214. https://doi.org/10.14426/ijers.2021.906

Bandura, A. (2018). Self-efficacy: The exercise of control. W.H. Freeman.

Chiemeke, S. T. (2023). The correlation between student motivation and academic performance: A study in secondary education. African Journal of Educational Studies, 11(1), 45-59. https://doi.org/10.11648/j.ajes.2023.11.01.15

Chukwu, E. I., & Nwafor, V. E. (2022). The impact of collaborative learning on student motivation in secondary schools in Aba State. Journal of Educational Studies, 15(4), 330-342. https://doi.org/10.1234/jes.2022.154

Deci, E. L., Olafsen, A. H., & Ryan, R. M. (2019). Self-determination theory in work organizations: The state of a science. Annual Review of Organizational Psychology and Organizational Behavior, 6, 19-43. https://doi.org/10.1146/annurev-orgpsych-012218-015059

Eccles, J. S., Wigfield, A., & Schiefele, U. (2019). Motivation and achievement. In Handbook of child psychology (7th ed., Vol. 4, pp. 109-150). Wiley. https://doi.org/10.1002/9781119133709.chmot01

Eze, N. A., & Amah, I. (2020). The effects of extrinsic and intrinsic motivation on student academic performance in secondary schools. Journal of Nigerian Educational Research, 18(2), 45-59. https://doi.org/10.1234/jner.2020.18245

Ifeanyi, I. E., & Okoro, C. M. (2025). The role of gamification in enhancing student motivation in secondary education: A case study. African Journal of Educational Technology, 14(1), 50-65. https://doi.org/10.1234/ajet.2025.141

Ifeanyi, U. F., Nwafor, C. J., & Ogbaji, E. I. (2023). Technology-enhanced learning and its impact on student motivation in secondary education. Journal of Educational Technology, 15(1), 89-105. https://doi.org/10.1234/jet.2023.151

Johnson, T. E., & Okafor, J. (2026). The effectiveness of motivational enhancement programs in Nigerian secondary schools: An empirical study. Journal of Educational Psychology, 118(1), 1-15. https://doi.org/10.12345/jep.2026.1181

López, A. R., & Crespo, M. C. (2021). Teacher’s motivational strategies and their outcomes on students’ engagement. International Journal of Educational Research, 12(3), 112-122. https://doi.org/10.1186/s40571-021-00128-z

Nkemjika, N. I. (2025). Mentoring and counseling as tools for enhancing motivation in secondary education: Perspectives from educators in Aba State. Nigerian Journal of Guidance and Counselling, 14(1), 45-60. https://doi.org/10.1234/njgc.2025.141

Nwankwo, G. A., Okeowo, I. A., & Ameh, I. (2023). Technology as a motivator in secondary school education: A review of trends and practices. International Journal of Technology in Education, 11(2), 212-225. https://doi.org/10.1234/ijte.2023.112

Nwankwo, P. A., & Kalu, I. N. (2022). Motivation and learning strategies among secondary school students in Nigeria. International Journal of Educational Research, 12(3), 112-122. https://doi.org/10.1186/s40571-022-00128-z

Nwoko, J. O., & Adigwe, A. E. (2020). The effect of external motivation on student engagement in secondary schools in Aba State. International Journal of Educational Studies, 18(2), 45-58. https://doi.org/10.1234/ijes.2020.182

Ogbondah, L. D. (2019). The role of classroom environment in motivating secondary school students: Evidence from Aba State. Nigerian Journal of Educational Issues, 10(3), 76-90. https://doi.org/10.1234/njei.2019.103

Okechukwu, I. O. (2021). Socio-economic factors influencing students’ motivation in secondary schools in Nigeria. Journal of Education and Learning, 10(3), 225-237. https://doi.org/10.5539/jel.v10n3p225

Okeke, C. A., & Aniemeka, O. (2019). The influence of intrinsic motivation on students’ academic performance in secondary schools. Journal of Education and Practice, 10(3), 12-20. https://doi.org/10.1234/jep.2019.103

Okwor, I. E., & Agbo, S. O. (2018). Intrinsic motivation and academic achievement among secondary school students in Nigeria. Nigerian Journal of Educational Psychology, 12(1), 1-15. https://doi.org/10.1234/njep.2018.121

References:

Ryan, R. M., & Deci, E. L. (2020). Intrinsic and extrinsic motivations: Classic definitions and new directions. Contemporary Educational Psychology, 25(1), 54-67. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.cedpsych.2020.101232

Uche, S. I., & Ndubuisi, C. A. (2021). Socio-cultural determinants of motivation in learning among secondary school students in South-East Nigeria. African Education Review, 18(2), 133-146. https://doi.org/10.1234/aer.2021.182

Ugochukwu, N. O., & Eke, C. S. (2025). Socio-cultural influences on student motivation in secondary schools in Aba State: A mixed-methods study. Nigerian Journal of Educational Research, 19(2), 145-158. https://doi.org/10.1234/njer.2025.192

Daily writing prompt

How can you build a regular fitness routine?

View all responses

The Impacts of Tribalism and Political Intelligence Towards Ghana and World Development; 21st Century National Assessment of Political and Tribalism Creation effect since Independence on Ghana.

The Impacts of Tribalism and Political Intelligence Towards Ghana and World Development; 21st Century National Assessment of Political and Tribalism Creation effect since Independence on Ghana.

Isaac Odoi Danquah

diok1982@yahoo.coom

Water Resources Engineer, Goldrain Mountain Company Limited, Koforidua, Eastern Region – Ghana.

ABSTRACT

Attainment of tribal and political objectives has been the main motive and intention of most people in Ghana but is usually done on underground motive basis since independence. Dr Kwame Nkrumah has been tagged as one of the greatest leaders and presidents of Ghana who led Ghana towards independence and freedom. History and all written facts proves this declaration but is now a questionable act and attitude before all as his forward ever, backwards never is not in the right direction and is justified with 21st century downgrade and no proper developments in Ghana. This research and investigation is to establish some real facts in this 21st century on impacts of tribalism and political intelligence towards the development of Ghana since independence. Research findings established that tribal governance and group governance is playing major role in the development and downgrade of projects and activities in Ghana. A good example is the 2012 court ruling and swift four years NDC entry into governance and exit for NPP 8 year’s governance which ended in 2024. A strategic move by leaders and knowledgeable men of history and in government when talking about mineral gold production and human gold production in Ghana and worldwide towards world development and governance. Dr Kwame Nkrumah’s forward ever backwards never hasn’t yielded any positive results for Ghana and Africa implying that the black man is not capable of managing his own affairs. And hence the need to look at the outside world and learn from them when it comes to country development and world development. But if the black man is capable of managing his own affairs, then the human gold products and mineral gold products business should build or generate a beautiful country and world comparable to the Dubai, USA, Britain, Canada etc for the next generations.

Keywords: Tribalism, politics, politicians, impacts, independence, New Democratic Party, New Patriotic Party, governance, gold

INTRODUCTION

The governance and leadership of the Ghanaian economy is full of deceit and lies solely from the world of the sociologist and political scientist. Ghana’s attainment of independence in 1957 is a well-established fact based on history but has not yielded any positive results. Graduates in the 21st century are complaining bitterly as the economy is very harsh on them; no jobs, no money, no proper development, acquired loan for projects are left uncompleted or not paid, uncaring attitudes for the common citizen etc. But during political campaigns in election years, are all kinds of promises of job creation, financial breakthroughs, liberation unto freedom for all and so forth. But only a few percentage of the national population get the benefit and rewards after election has been done. Based on all happenings in the country and world – wide, it is justified of a world created for the benefit and reward of the sociologist and the political scientist. Not in favor of the scientist, security forces and engineer and if possible the business man. Talk of the presidents, the actors, music industry, the church ministerial level, the minister and all those in governance. All from the political science and sociologist background. For instance, the actor’s world is full of fun and enjoyment, all the fame, driving the big cars, the beautiful hotels, living in beautiful buildings, making all the travels (both locally and internationally). Meanwhile, the actor does not write script, just learn the script, act, plays the roles and gets all the fame and enjoyment. Talk of the work of the engineer and scientist involved. How much is his salary or remenurations for creating the beautiful car, nice building, all equipments and gadgets for the movie, radio and TV industry? The sociologist or political scientist is never involved with serious hard work when it comes to creation but the most fortunate in the country or economy when it comes to enjoying the goodies of the land. Talk of the president, minister, the pastor, actor, musician etc, this entire category from the background of the sociologist and political scientist. The Dr Kwame Nkrumah creation and political liberation from political slavery and oppression has never resulted the needed results. If the needed results was ever achieved and attained, then it is on tribal bases as not all have benefited in the Nkrumah generation governance. All happenings, characteristics, features and attributes of most governing bodies since independence is protection of the Nkrumah’s tribal freedom liberation. Dr Kwame Nkrumah has been tagged as Fante from Nkroful but that is a true lie and deceit. It is just politically initiated and the only way to siphon and enjoy the goodies and gold resource of Ghana. Have you observed the language tongue of a true Fante? What of the northerner tongue and language? History has it all western migration into the Gold coast was basically around the coast – Fante lands. It could possibly be Akwapim lands as history might tell as Kyerepong and other Akwapim Twi speaking people still exist there comparable to what is found in the Eastern Region of Ghana but in this 21st century as Fante lands. All whites’ settlement and governance was around and within the coast. So by generation and creation, Fante’s are justified as being British, white tongue users and is justified by the way Fante’s speak and the tongues English language speaking smoothness.

What of the tongue of the northerner and people from the northern region, Upper East region and Upper West region. Is there any resemblance of Kwame Nkrumah’s tongue with the people from the northern region? Or the same speaking language tongue compared to the tongue of the Fante’s. But history has it recorded of Dr Kwame Nkrumah born on 21st September 1909 in Nkroful, Gold Coast. There are written documents to confirm what happened 115 years (1909 -2024) ago. If nothing at all, year of independence 1957 did not have anything like World wide web, internet and digital information sharing system in Ghana for this history to be justified before all. The Ghanaian gold has been locked into an account and I believe it’s an account led by the Dr Kwame Nkrumah total liberation and fight for freedom. If Dr Kwame Nkrumah fought for freedom and liberation and won, did he win all the gold inclusive? In which account did he leave the gold production business in Ghana. Does Kwame Nkrumah marriage with the Fathia Ritzk, an Egyptian Coptic bank worker and former teacher ring a bell? Lived in exile in Conakry, Guinea as the guest of President Ahmed Sekou Toure, who made him honary co – president of the country? These are all penned down raw facts but what is happening in the 21st century Ghana. Talk of all the 16 regions in Ghana. In terms of regions to tribe’s ratio, northerners ration to other regions is 3:13. Look at current migration issues in Ghana and the rate of country deterioting attitude. Does the 2024 political election year ring any bell? What of the chosen presidential candidate for the NPP and NDC?

Why this take off after a total world shutdown (during the Akuffo Addo Dankwa led government) and a new take off of the world in 2019/2020 Covid. Never expect a pilot/driver to pilot/drive through storms and take over the piloting/driver wheels in safe mode or periods. This is comparably like a new creation for the next generation and a complete automatic and force take off by the northerner creation. Can’t this be comparable to Nkrumah take off in 1957 after obtaining freedom from the British? How many northerners tongue speakers and users compared to southern tongue/British tongue users and speakers among the BIG SIX who fought for independence? You and I were not there but possibly the 60 years old political scientist or sociologist was at the polling station and therefore can attest or justify that fact. These are questions worth investigating and analyzing for the good will of Ghanaians, the British and the world at large. This is simply because of the downward direction of the country full of lies, corruption, fifth and supposed governance and development of country through loans/grants from donor partners and so forth.

Who can depend solely on loan from a bank, financial institution or friend without a repayment plan when talking about greatness in life or development of a country? Can one get continues loan from a bank without repayment plan before another loan? Assuming Mr A going for a loan for about 10 times from Ghana Commercial Bank (GCB) worth GHC20,000 amounting to Ghc200,000 without repayment plan. Is it not for the GCB to go bankrupt? There will be a total crush of GCB if this is extended to 1000 population who needs loans with this same motive. Then what of receiving loans from China continuously for instance for all projects in Ghana without a repayment plan. Won’t China go bankrupt or run the country’s money down. Is the white man ever in a position to do this, give money continuously to a country for development without a repayment plan? Is China willing to do this for all other countries? Why won’t the country Ghana be full of uncompleted projects? Most of these uncompleted projects have being in that manner for a purpose. All these because of the issue of money. What the Ghanaian will say ‘sika asem’. Who doesn’t need money? Developed countries are developing at a faster rate because of money. Who doesn’t want to be rich, who doesn’t love better things. We all love goodies and need development as a country Ghana and people. What a Nigerian will call a money ritual, a Ghanaian will call money medicine – sika aduro, to heal poverty or money sickness. Hence it is justifiable for Ghanaian to sort or look for a new way of solving Ghanaian problems rather than building a country solely dependent on loans or grants from foreign partners. The issue of building Ghanaian economy based on loans and grants is another questionable act with several big international mineral gold mining companies dotted around the country. Ghana as a country is full of gold mines generating billions of pounds sterling’s and cedis and various real mineral and human gold bars on monthly basis. There exist a missing link or question mark somewhere pointing in the direction of tribalism and political lies in Ghana political setup worth researching and justifying.

Can you think of the rate at which people from other African countries are entering Ghana through Burkina Faso, Togo, Nigeria and making Ghana ugly and filthy all in the names of collection of scrapes? They just pick some wrist watches, nail cutters, dresses, mats, bags etc walks all the way from other African countries and Burkina Faso and into Ghana. This are all northerner tribal related. Looks like other African countries do not want the peace and greatness of Ghana and the Ghanaian economy. This has made the Ghanaian environment and economy too ugly. It has even increased the rate of illegal gold mining business in Ghana destroying forest reserves, lands and water bodies. At Nsutam in the Eastern Region of Ghana for instance is the total destruction of river Birim and Supong. These are things worth investigating and analyzing by security professionals for the good will and wellbeing of mother Ghana.

These are various questions worth justifying through this research to see the main motive of the tribal and political intelligence in Ghana towards development since independence to the 21st century. Then what possible deductions can be made for readjustment and refinement towards the development of Ghana for the next generation.

2 JUSTIFICATION OF RAW FACTS ON POLITICAL LIES

2.1 Wearing of Fugu (Northerner Cloth) during independence Speech before Ghanaians and the World.

Justification for actions and inactions are evidenced based and a good example is the celebration of Independence Day after a great battle by the Nkrumah led government against our colonial masters which is the British. Based on raw facts, documentaries and other printable documents, the day of independence against the British by the government led movement towards independence was celebrated with a speech but one symbolic item is the ‘dress code’ of the big six. They were all in Fugu attire of which a speech was shared. All Ghanaian tribes in Ghana celebrates symbols of unity, citizenship, tribal traits, a sense of belonging through language and mother tongue, food, clothing, facial appearances etc. One can easily identify the tribe of a fellow Ghanaian through the cloth he/she wears or way of dressing. And Fugu in Ghana is always associated with people of the three northern regions especially in the case of Ghana. And if possible in other African countries. So wearing Fugu on the day of independence to celebrate the victory after a hard battle is something related to the northerner. Or in simple terms, it justifies a victory for Ghana or Gold Coast against the British led by the Northerner. This declarations can be analyzed in various ways through logical reasoning and its implications;

It’s a complete northerners registration in battle for victory and independence
A battle for Ghana or Gold Coast led by Dr Kwame Nkrumah who is a northerner
A political party and winning government belonging to the northerner
Takeover government from the British led by the northern
A moslem movement to rule and govern the Gold Coast or Ghana led by the northerner (about 80% Moslems in Ghana) and the world
A change in government and religion from Christian religion to Islamic religion
A well created world and government in the direction of greatness and development changed and reversed in the direction of retraction (Negative way of the statement Forward ever Backward never); this is a fact based on 21st century development in Ghana.
Motive of taking over Gold Coast or Ghana from a well created and intelligent man from an African country based on gold in Ghana. When one looks at movement and shipment of Gold and money from Ghana towards other African countries and final verdict of ending in some African countries and exit from the earth. This is detailed below.

Again, Nkrumah is tagged as someone from the Western Region of Ghana. This can be true and a complete lie to the common Ghana. This is because no one can confidently tell or give correct facts concerning the administrative regions in Ghana during the Gold Coast day’s era. A good example is 10 regions in Ghana comparable to the current 16 regions which is a complete change in terms of new names, geographical position system (GPS) and position of town, community, city or future city. But based on language tongue and dress code, it’s a complete lie to tell or explain to someone that president Dr Kwame Nkrumah is a Fante or from the Western Region of Ghana. It is a complete lie which is worth further analyzing based on Fante’s ways of life, Nkrumah’s declaration and support for Forward Ever Backwards Never couple with current state and affairs of development in Ghana.

Look at it this way again. No human life or being can tell where he/she comes from except by a mother, father, elderly family members or someone. And this citizenship is from the town or community or city where your head with eyes entered into the world. Citizenship coming from where one’s eyes opened to see the new world or creation. That is citizenship being established from the basis of where one is born into the world. This is the reason for citizenship by birth but even that is a question mark? Where final justification is also associated with motive, attitude, actions and contribution towards national and world development. If a real citizen of a town or community is terrorizing and fighting against the system or community, he/she can be thrown off board or into prisons. So if Dr Kwame Nkrumah’s forward ever backwards never is justified with this 21st century Ghana downgrade when dealing and talking about country development and greatness, then there is a missing link worth looking for and fixing. Or there is complete political lies to the advantage of someone somewhere.

2.2 Shipment of Gold and Money to Guinea and landing in Guinea

Dr Kwame Nkrumah is tagged the best ever president Ghana had ever registered in the world whiles others thinks if he hadn’t embarked on his change in rulership and governance from the British , Ghana would have been a better country. Ghana’s way of life, greatness and development would have been comparably the same like other western world countries. Because I believe the whole wide world was set on one platform and asked to move in the direction of greatness and development after the Second World War. This is simple because, one can easily see the creation of a beautiful world of development and greatness in terms of science and engineering in most African Countries. This well created and generated world is the same in the western World. Such beautiful engineered world is seen in most cities of African countries and same in the western world. A good example is Ghana, Senegal, Gambia, Burkina Faso, Nigeria etc. Travel to Accra, Dakar, Banjul and carefully look at the city settings, drainage works, the tall and massive state institutions buildings and they are comparably same as in the western world. This creation should have been taking on a modelling approach, education and training through university intelligence and simulated throughout the country for a western land and city world generation. So it means a world was created out of technology and intelligence for the world to revolve around education, training, planting and generating of such world continuously. A reason for most western countries having the same life in terms of intelligence and development.

But looks like a cycle was broken in terms of a world towards greatness and beauty on the African continent by the Nkrumah led movement. By all assessment and investigations, it looks like that creation was a Christian religion related creation and hence towards salvation, beauty, the goodwill of mankind and great height attainment for the common citizen. But the Nkrumah led movement which I think is Islamic religion focused broke that creation and development cycle. But lied to the common citizen with the phrase ‘Forward ever Backwards Never’. The true reflection and work done by his statement is the current state of Ghana. This is an investigation from one school of thought where one school of thought may prove or want to prove otherwise.

What of the possibility of the Nkrumah led government and world leaders creating and generating a world of greatness and beauty for the world but from the African continent or soil? Where a gold production business and intelligence is generated from Africa to create all kinds of beautiful places and world and hence the need to send the common African into slavery to serve in different fields or capacity through good leadership of a white man and hence a resultant impact or effect on the African Continent. Where at any point in time, a beautiful country or world is created and set as center stage focal point for greatness in all dimensions. A good example is China, other Asian countries and Dubai for instance. Have you ever thought about the world of Football competition between African countries in the 1990’s and in 2025 today? Can Ghana or Nigeria Football team face Chinese team, Korean team and possibly Saudi Arabia national team in this 21^st Century? These are all thoughts worth analyzing and further probing. It’s possibly it was human gold and mineral gold production intelligent creation to help the world as a world where you and I may be part of a world and not part of the world when it comes to enjoying or assessing the goodies of the land or soil. But from the objective and perspective of United Nations Sustainable Development Goals (UN – SDG’s), resources are supposed to be shared equitably in life to the advantage of all.

2.3 Bombing at Burkina Faso during Nkrumah Visit

From the world of investigation and research, can it be a possibility that Ghana is being ruled by Burkina Faso, Ivory Coast and Togolese. That is being governed by three French speaking countries? Where there is intelligent creation motive but the ability to unravel the secrets and mysteries in there is very difficult? Is it also possible that Ghana is being used by this same Burkina Faso, Ivory Coast, Togolese and other African countries to propagate an agenda of mineral and human gold production to the detriment of the common Ghanaian or one who have lived in Ghana for several years? These are well researched investigations with some raw facts but worth further probing and investigating. Think of the northerner, Ivory Coast and Togolese populations and numbers in Ghana in this 21st Century. And comparably think and investigate the rate of migration from Burkina Faso, Ivory Coast and Togo which are all Francophone countries. Is there any correlation between Gold Coast and Ivory Coast? An Anglophone country and Francophone country? A British colony country and French colony country? Is there a relationship between the one who owns and mines the gold called gold trade because the country is involved in gold mining production? And the one involved in ivory trade which is basically buying and selling of ivory (tusks of elephants). Is there any explanation between a French speaking personality comparable to the attributes and features of an English speaking personality? Think of the number of Ghanaian communities and towns in the three countries named or registered above. So assuming a gold production business is set up; both human gold and mineral gold with the current rate of migration from Burkina Faso, Ivory Coast and Togo, who benefits? Who benefits from a well-crafted gold mining business establishment and takeover by these three neighbouring countries in Ghana with their huge numbers and representation in terms of population and manipulation? Assuming Dr Kwame Nkrumah is from Burkina and decides with Ivory Coast, Togo and other Francophone African countries leaders to set up such a business through Ghana, who benefits? Can you imagine how some graduates in Ghana do not get jobs or gets employed in gold mines and state institutions after tertiary educations? These are all questionable acts and behaviours of some secrets, actions and inactions in Ghana when talking about 21st century development in Ghana, mineral gold and human gold production worldwide. Assuming this was a creation from Burkina Faso or corperation and collaboration between the two or more countries and bombing at Burkina Faso for execution of the next intelligence creation direction as discussed by some schools of thoughts or at Kulungugu by another school of thought.

2.4 Forward Ever, Backwards Never

The main objective statement which is the center stage of Dr Kwame Nkrumah’s led leadership and government is ‘Forward Ever Backwards Never’. But a big question we all Ghanaians and a world ought to ask is the meaning, the intelligence and motive in this statement and hence the struggle and battle for freedom and liberation from the governance and rulership of the British. Some are of the assertions that if the British had ruled Ghana and no need for change or the Nkrumah’s fight, Ghana would have been better off. It would have been competition in the direction of greatness in terms of beauty and development among other countries. Can you look at the current state of development in Ghana in terms of everything? And the current destruction if possible all resources coupled with corruption among leaders and the youth. Then again, the generation of a country who thinks and believes complete allegiance to God in terms of song and prayer builds a beautiful country. Everybody in Ghana wants to travel not thinking and knowing that Ghana is someone’s or another countries abroad. Therefore the need to think and create an abroad or country of international status comparable to other countries to attract tourist and develop. Then build a country that will train good scientist and engineers to grow and propagate the country to the next level. Just like we have Ghanaians and other countries nationals in USA working and paying allegiance towards the goodwill and welfare of the USA, other people are in Ghana doing same for their own welfare and countries or nations of origin greatness. And hence Ghanaians needs to think alike or in the same direction. It is possible the Dr Nkrumah’s leadership and government generated a world in the direction of current Dubai to revolve round the world towards greatness and development and hence Forward Ever, backwards Never. Therefore, it’s the time of Ghanaians to learn, think, create and generate a world in that direction. This is after serious work for Ghanaians and the world. OR it could mean Dr Nkrumah embarked on a selfish and greedy ambition for the welfare of other countries or a world to the detriment of the common Ghanaian. Simply because he wasn’t from Ghana and do not wants the welfare and greatness of Ghana but need the gold for his people. Therefore the intelligent creation of a gold mining business for his welfare and good people. A justification for telling Ghanaians I, Dr Kwame Nkrumah will go forward it terms of countries greatness and development. Whiles backwards in terms of countries enrichment is for Ghanaian’s Presidents and his people. Therefore a justification for Forward Ever, Backwards Never. Can you think of the current management of all state resources and items coupled with unwillingness to serve one another? The level of corruption and non-allegiance of security forces to government and non-adherence to rules and laws governing a community or country by citizens? All these negative impacts or effects have proven the negative way of forward ever, backwards never! When this is compared to the governance, operation and management of state resources by the white man and in the western world even though to a certain level (not at level of a probability of 1). So we Ghanaians ought to think and probe further into Dr. Kwame’s Nkrumah’s creation and ask serious questions worth researching for answers, the meaning and motive of ‘Forward Ever Backwards Never’. Based on the current state and affairs in Ghana where a degree holder graduates from school, completes mandatory work to country and state then sits home for years looking for job.

2.5 Free Senior High School Government Policy and Political Intelligence

From the first point above, logical reasoning and its implications, this is rightly applicable to FREE SHS education in Ghana led by the Nana Addo Dankwa Akuffo Addo government. Was FREE SHS Akuffo Addo’s main objective or objective by the former Vice President, Alhaji Mahamudu Bawumai as the second in command but a captain and president for another world or tribe propagating political agenda in an intelligent manner? Who enjoys free education in Ghana most? And in which regions are all the Aids and free money given and generating geared towards in Ghana. I for instance have never enjoyed free education in Ghana and most people in the southern sector are in the same position. Can you imagine the number of scholarships that was given to tertiary students during the 2016 – 2024 Akuffo Dankwa led government gave to Ghanaians tertiary students in Ghana? The total sum of money used to spearhead this scholarships can even build three or four international gold mines in Ghana to help build the Ghanaian economy. I am not against given scholarships but ask of the quality human gold products that are being produced towards national and world development. Then all these actions against stealing and syphoning of government money by Headmasters, Administrators, directors, ministers where raw facts proves of a headmaster buying two cars to the detriment of teachers and staff. Avoiding the opportunity of using this money to complete an administration block for a school. And right after the exit of the Akuffo Addo’s led government out of office and into election is the Nkrumah’s wining and victory attitude; Mr Mahama on the right for election and Dr Bawumai on the left for election towards a total or complete northerner led government registration and take off as pilot after a new world creation – COVID 19 period. Is there a possibility for another project or simulation for another Mr Mahama on the right for election and Dr Bawumai on the left for election towards a total or complete northerner led government registration and take off as pilot in the future with current rambling and tangling in NPP presidential elections? These are questionable acts and raw facts before all Ghanaians and world worth looking into with a deeper and microscopic piecing microscope.

Based on research, investigations from studies areas and Nsutam with illegal gold mining intelligence and motive, I think there is a tribe called Asanteman. Which in terms of phonetics basically looks or literally means; ‘yƐ san ate oman’ – Asanteman. This in English means ‘Establishing another nation or kingdom’ again. This is where one sits down lazily, folds the arms, thinks he/she is smart and intelligent and ask one or the worker to do all the donkey or difficult works with a final take over with guns and intelligence as a thief. Which is one school of thought based on divine creation and Bible and young guys of today’s intelligence and nonsensical insults to business owners and job creators. Think of the current Asanteman explanation and registration at Nsutam in the Eastern Region of Ghana. Where people living in some philosophical world, school of thoughts or regions just gets small scale gold mining certificates from other regions and ends up in Eastern Region for contracts. The contracts are awarded by Newmont Akyem at Abirim with final output for work done to be the destruction of land, water resources, forest reserves, farmlands etc all in the name and philosophy of illegal gold mining. Newmont is where all the nice creation and creative works dealing with gold mining and production are done and completed. Such small scale miners are involved or works in another destruction creators hands justified by the destruction of natural resources and properties worth Billions of Pounds Sterling’s, dollars and cedis with even loss of human lives. This is the case of the COVID – 19 worldwide which is possibly a problem or solution from one philosophical world or school of thought.

3 21ST CENTURY ASSESSMENT OF GHANA

3.1 21st Century Development in Ghana

The 21st century generation, citizens and population in Ghana are bitter and angry at the current state of affairs when talking about job creation, greatness and development of a country. It is on most or all mindset of citizens of Ghana that to make it in life or reach the self-actualization level on the Maslow’s hierarchy of needs, one ought to travel. Citizens do not have faith in the economy, one does not see opportunity when it comes to job creation and accessibility. Even though opportunity comes in different forms, everyone and his knowledge level and hence resultant perception in life. As to whether the opportunity is small or big. I think leaders in Ghana wants graduates and the unemployed to make use of their intelligence and mental capacity towards helping themselves, building the economy and meeting their needs as represented in the Sustainable Development Goals (SDG’s). But I think everyone and his mental development process and hence the attainment of a great intelligence and its application at a stage or point in life. It therefore deems fit for leaders to help the vulnerable in the society or country, educate, train and give jobs as a government. This will help them meet the basic physiological needs in life, help themselves and families. Then think through how to better their lives while working assiduously to climb the Maslow’s’ hierarchy of needs ladder in life and help develop the country.

The rate of development in Ghana isn’t in the right direction as stated by Dr Kwame Nkrumah in his statement of forward ever, backwards never. All developments in Ghana are highly political and party initiated and implemented. An uncompleted project by party A has a lower probability that it will be completed by party B. Fanteakwa South district and Eastern Region of Ghana for instance has a lot of uncompleted projects undergoing deterioting process and extinction from the earth. This motive by government in power leads to wastage in terms of resources, unemployment and financial burden on all at the end of every government tenure. A justification for wastage of graduate’s intelligence and ability, four years wastage in the university in Ghana and other African countries. This is a problem worth investigating and analyzing when it comes to development on participatory approach and not on the basis of party tickets or party lines. Ghana needs development on all fronts; roads constructions, buildings or housing facilities, drainage networks, sewage networks, bioengineering works, hospitals construction, in the education sectors, water resources management, treatments and distribution, afforestation, job creation etc. It’s a basic principle to learn from others and that ought to be the motive of the young generation when it comes to the development and management of the economy. Everyone is a government as anyone can be a president today from the concept of school off thought. The very way one wants to be an assembly man, another member of parliament (MP) and another a Minister towards the presidency as president. The next 50 years president is being admitted at Kindergarten or Primary one (1) today which is a scenario but a reality too. Everyone knows something to the extent of even a mad man knowing something for going through madness school of thought which you, a so called healthy individual has never attended or graduated from before. Therefore, if your mental capacity has developed to the extent of being a leader, never use it to intimidate or bully others. In a nutshell, act responsibly when the duty of responsibility lies on your shoulders. Everyone and his mental capacity development stage in life. Ghana needs to look at the development and country building intelligence by other countries and work on going in that same direction.

3.2 21st Century Management and State institutions Collaboration and partnership in state affairs.

Management of state institution by current generation is very bad with high degree of quest for money first and not offering services for giveaways by clients or customers. Most state institution are in a very bad state and people or managers are not willing to share views, accepts corrections or implement recommendations. Most private and some institutions are not managed in that manner. Money oriented managers and directors operating as group have made the state institutions their own property and not willing to allow the system flow for good controlling and operation by able hands. The state of collaboration that is supposed to exist between state institutions and generate money into government accounts or coffers for projects and initiatives is very poor. This is draining government pocket and accounts on monthly basis as payments for government workers is on monthly basis. Most countries progress and development is basically based on generating of income and money by all state institutions in a collaborative manner. But this is not same in Ghana as most institutions are operated loosely and generating money into individual’s hands and pockets. For instance;

Payment for tariffs (water, electricity) to Ghana Water Company, Water Resources Commission and Electricity Company of Ghana for water and power (electricity) usage. Effective management of accrued money for services offered for all water projects, usage in the water industry and in the power industry.
Payment of road user fee at Tollbooth to Ghana Highway Authority for roads constructions and management of roads.
Generation of revenue through police reports, arrests, illegalities by Ghana Police Services and Security Forces
Fees paying and profits generations from the Ghana Education Service instead of free education (FREE SHS).
Treatment of all illness and disease at a cost by Ghana Health Service professionals to generate funds into government accounts etc.
Revenue generations from the Registrar’s Generals Department through business registrations, certifications, monitoring and quarterly or yearly returns analysis.
Revenues (tax) generation from all state and public bodies and individuals by Ghana Revenue Authority and its Collectors for government projects planting and establishments etc.
Researches and investigations by security forces like immigration services, Ghana Navy, Ghana Military and gives results like from Natural Resources Conservation Services in hydrology and hydraulics. Results and outputs generated from such institutions becomes data that can be sold and money generated into government coffers or is used by the state institutions. For instance, climate data and rainfall data from Meteorological services Department etc.

From the above assertions, it’s well justified that state institutions are supposed to work by coordinating and collaborating with each other. Then generate money through partnership and collaboratively for the running of the institution and into government accounts for picking and planting jobs for the unemployed graduates in Ghana and worldwide.

3.3 The 21st Century Forward Ever, Backwards Never Ghana

If another Ghana is to be built to justify the positive side and direction of forward ever backwards never comparable to Ghana in 2025 as said by Dr Kwame Nkrumah! Then the leaders and siting government need to work collaboratively and not on tribal basis or on tribal grounds. It looks like Ghana is deterioting simply because of the concept of ownership and leadership in Ghana. Every tribe wants to prove to be the owners of the land and hence comparably the same motive in the minds of leaders of the country in every regard. But Ghana needs to develop and generate a beautiful wealthy country through participatory approach and collaboration. In this way the following recommendations and points can be analyzed or probed, reviewed further and applied if applicable;

Build a beautiful modern city like a university, estate or institution with all facilities with modern intelligence and engineering eg is University of Environment and Sustainable Development under construction at Bunso in the Eastern Region of Ghana. A possible change in university name but with same building concept and intelligence as a model for the new Ghana.
The modern intelligence and engineering will includes, good tall buildings, good housing buildings and facilities, good roads, good electrification system, beautiful drainage networks, proper sewage systems, beautiful bioengineering works, well-constructed and coordinated state institutions, good management and collaborative way of making money into government accounts by all state institutions, creating a system where the education system purposely trains children and the young to take over and operate such a project or country development.
The above deliberation will constitute the accoutrements or components of a whole one catchment area even though there might be small catchments within this catchment.
This catchment will be comparable to one complete zone within a town or city with meeting roads around it.
Then building a complete town or city made up of several catchments will be by picking the architectural design and mounting it catchment by catchment with little or some modifications. This is simply because engineering deals with real time simulation based on feasibility studies of geographical location, associated characteristics of project area, seasons of siting of project and other factors.
Then simulation of the project over the whole town, city, region and country.
There will be the building of big malls, entertainment places with some monuments and edifices of beauty for entertainments and happy moods generations during holidays and weekends.
The whole water resources sector will be worked on regionally by engineers towards generating a pure quality clean water to meet the SDG’s. Then obtain water flowing under high pressures for hydropower projects and those with large surface areas that can allow boats and ships to move one as learning and entertainment sources.
There will be waste management sector to manage all wastages and generated wastes in the country towards obtaining a clean towns, cities and country comparable to some western countries like UK, USA, and Dubai, Germany etc. Since waste management and usage is problem, one can employ lecturers in the waste management sector to hold the process together. This intelligence will be applied to cover various sectors of the economy as a clean and beautiful city and country is generated for the now and future generations.
Generation of such a project will be through collaborative approach and engineered. A whole catchment project will constitute a team led by an experienced engineer supervisor. And working under the engineer supervisor will be all kinds of workers or experts that can handle a whole estate building project. A good example is the modelled University of Environment and Sustainable Development project at Bunso in the Eastern Region of Ghana. Such a project is a big employment industry for the unemployed graduate and all. And with this, migrating to abroad will be on lesser note or with a different motive.
Such a project will generate a beautiful country for Ghana and with a possibility of simulating for the whole world. Simulating for the whole wide world is regardless. It simply means taking it to the ends of the world where it doesn’t exist.

3.4 World Development and impacts from Real time Political Intelligence

3.4.1 Establishment of Ministry of Goldway Worldwide

Money is the first and foremost important parameter and symbol which quantifies anything on planet earth whenever one is talking about buying and selling worldwide. Money is a gold which means a real precious mineral (or figure) when dealing with buying and selling in terms of exchange of goods and services. Everyone on planet earth talks and deals with money basically meaning we are all involved with money issues or problems one way or the other. The government talks about money, the government worker talks and deals with money, the estate developer deals with money, the scientist, the engineer, the pilot, the mechanic, the trader or seller at the market, the banker and the common citizen in the society. So in summary, everyone deals and talks about money with the only difference being the particular currency at any point in time. That is either the pounds sterling’s, the dollar, Euro, the cedis, CFA, yen, Naira. These are all money with different symbols of authority based on country, history, allegiance, geographical locations, features, determining factors and finally a weighting factor highly dependent on countries development and impact on the world and its development. And this currency or money is what is moving and developing a country based on inflows and outflows into individual hands, business, home, job or business. But in all these assertions, there is one important group or categories who are dealing with money at any time ‘t’ when talking about buying and selling in real life. And that is the trader or the market man/woman. The beans seller, the meat seller, that rice and flour supplier and any other person at the market. The cashier at the bank or banker deals with money but not in terms of direct selling and buying of goods. Why am I interested in the trader or seller at the market when it comes to money, national development and world development in Ghana? Most countries have all kinds of institutions playing different roles and these institutions have been classified as one body contributing to the welfare and development of oneself, country and world. For instance is the Ministry of Education, Ministry of Défense, Ministry of Finance, Ministry of Water Resources, Ministry of Health, Ministry of Gender, Ministry of Roads and Highways, Ministry of Agriculture, Ministry of Communication, Ministry of Foreign Affairs, Ministry of Sports, Ministry of Energy etc. Most of these ministries are common among countries worldwide with some being different from the other. But possibly with the same roles and responsibilities in a country’s management or world development. This is a clear indication of landing spot that is either as a world controller or country control room operator. So basically this is a reason for some ministries having the same name, the same representation and responsibility in all countries worldwide. The same with different names and less representation worldwide. In totality, it means it’s possible some don’t know how a ministry in government is formed or established while others may have been on that difficult road which leads to a beautiful destination in real life before.

In Ghana for instance which is the research area and main country of focus for data, analysis and scenario generations, there are all kinds of classifications forming a ministry in Government. Examples includes the above listed ministries worldwide which gives thousands of jobs and wages and salaries to employees on monthly basis with associated taxes . These taxes ends up in government account or coffers for various activities towards job creation and world development. But ask yourself if the market woman selling eggs, beans, distributing rice and flour, the factory worker, the graphic designer, the wakye seller in that corner of the street is effectively taxed on monthly basis and contributing to country and world development? The Ghana Revenue Authority (GRA) and revenue collectors have been given this responsibility, but how effective is the collection and taxing system? Compare this to a medical Doctor Husband and accountant wife forming a family who are taxed before payment at the end of the month or salary or wages hitting the personal bank account. Think of this scenario for instance, taxing two families where family A is working for the government and family B are traders not paying taxes or being taxed effectively at the end of the month. All the analyzed figures are applicable in all currencies worldwide.

Table 1: Two family taxing system analysis (Gh₵ or ₵)

	Family A		Family B
	Husband (Doctor)	Wife (Accountant)	Husband (Mechanic)	Wife (Rice Distributor)
Monthly Salary	Gh₵10,000	Gh₵8,000	Gh₵7,500	Gh₵6,000
Monthly Tax (10%)	Gh₵1000	Gh₵800	Gh₵750	Gh₵600
Yearly Tax	Gh₵12,000	Gh₵9,600	Gh₵9,000	Gh₵7,200
Total Contribution by Family per Year	Gh₵108,000		Gh₵16,200
Ten Years Contribution Effect	Gh₵1,080,000		Gh₵162,000

Research findings establishes the salary or wages for husband Doctor and wife accountant payable by the government on monthly basis. But then, there is a procedure which justifies the ₵10,000 for husband and ₵8,000 for wife monthly wages based on work input on daily basis. Let assume the husband mechanic saves ₵250 on daily basis for 30days average for all months in a year. Then also into daily savings of ₵200 for 30 days average for the wife for the whole year round. Then for a monthly salary for the husband mechanic is ₵7,500 and ₵6000 for the Rice distributor and the corresponding taxing analysis above. This is on a lower scale or level. But what of on a higher scale or level as in the case of distributing point shops or factory where a seller a trader picks good and pays ₵2000 upfront? In such a situation, a business owner or trader can pay or save ₵5000 per day. This is analyzed in the Table 2 below comparable to a government earner in that category.

Table 2: Two family taxing system analysis on a higher level (Gh₵ or ₵)

	Family A		Family B
	Husband (Director)	Wife (Accountant)	Husband (Car Dealer)	Wife (Goods Distributor)
Monthly Salary	Gh₵60,000	Gh₵40,000	Gh₵1,000,000	Gh₵1,500,000
Monthly Tax (10%)	Gh₵6,000	Gh₵4,000	Gh₵100,000	Gh₵150,000
Yearly Tax	Gh₵72,000	Gh₵48,000	Gh₵1,200,000	Gh₵1,800,000
Total Contribution by Family per Year	Gh₵120,000		Gh₵3,000,000
Ten Years Contribution Effect	Gh₵1,200,000		Gh₵30,000,000

Analysis from Table 1 and Table 2 gives a clear indication that the government of Ghana is losing huge sums of money on monthly, yearly and decade basis for the trader or seller who is not taxed. And it is possibly same in countries or regions where the tax collecting system in that country is not well regulated in the market sector or in the buying and selling business sector. Think of the two families having three wards each who graduates in the university in years to come with undergraduate degrees to doctor of philosophy level and to be employed by the government of Ghana or the government. One can ask himself or herself. What is the contribution by the two families towards tax generation or income for the government, job creation in the country, national development and world development? These and many more reasons for the MINISTRY OF GOLWAY establishment in Ghana, other countries and if possible worldwide. This is where all traders will be classified under one body or institution (MINISTRY OF GODWAY) and under it is a business entity or company called GLORY SUSU and other departments. This will be a company or business entity that will be employed to generate monthly income for all traders, sellers, drivers, fashion designers, and other professionals not classified under one umbrella in government. It will be simply generating a monthly salary, wages or income around whatever business one is running, spearheading or involved in. But it is subject to all kinds of conditions with the poor trader in mind because of sustainability of business, family he or she is running, daily earnings and the inflows and outflows of money in business. And out of the generated monthly salary for the trader will be a percentage for income tax for government comparable to the percentage income tax from government workers in Ghana and worldwide into government account on monthly basis. The percentage for tax will depend on all kinds of factors used to generate income tax for the worker in government and will be the same for the government worker. In Ghana for instance is 16.6% as according to my payslip. This MINISTRY OF GOLDWAY is applicable to all countries worldwide who have difficulty when it comes to the collection and accountability for income tax from the trader or seller in the market. The currency (Gh₵) used here (Table 1 & 2) as a scenario is also applicable to all currencies worldwide like the dollar ($), pound sterling’s (£), CFA France, Euro (€) etc.

3.4.2 Establishment of Ministry of Management and Maintenance Worldwide

Management and maintenance issue especially in the case of state owned institutions facilities and buildings is a major problem in Ghana and possibly same in other countries worldwide. With this under discussion, it is of utmost importance in this 21st century to have a body or institution that works in that direction as all and everybody on earth is now concern with beauty and aesthetics at all levels. It is necessary to have a body that will give or generate a structure or system that will keep these institutions anew and fresh always. Assuming Ghana decides to build modern towns, cities and country to international standards with everything in place. How do we keep the beauty, aesthetics and freshness always? There is therefore the need for another ministry that will basically look at how or ensures the renovation of state institutions, roads, sewage system, government projects, private projects etc through self-financing intelligence (by the ministry itself) and money generation process towards beauty of the system, country and for sustainability. There is therefore the need for the establishment of MINISTRY OF MANAGEMENT AND MAINTENANCE to cater for all management and how to maintain the well-built or generated town, city or country always anew all year round. By this declaration, I mean there will be a fund generation process to cater for the paintings, bioengineering works and little addition or modifications of all state institutions, housing systems, private structures, projects and other areas deemed fit and appropriate. Think of this simple simulation to generate money internally for this ministry on monthly basis and major maintenances works done within 6 months or on yearly basis. The scenario is applicable in all other currencies worldwide and highly dependent on population. Populations living in housing system is by estimation and hence subject to real time research and investigations in every country. But there is a high degree of confidence in estimating population size in this research work as detailed in Table 3.

Determining factors upon which population size in housing system depends includes;

Development status of country
Size of economy, job creation and accessibility potential
Migrations
Education levels
Languages
Housing system and accessibility etc.

And upon critical consideration and examination of these factors carefully, the percentage population that are living in housing system and will be able to pay Gh₵20 ranges from 50% – 60%. This is the case for Ghana but is applicable to all population countries worldwide at possibly the same rate but different currency interpretations.

Table 3: Monthly and Yearly estimation of Total amount generated to feed the Ministry of Management and Maintenance in its operation

Country	Amount Per head/ Family Size (Per Month)	Total Population Per Each Country	Population in Housing System (Per Estimate)	Total Amount per Month	Total Amount per Year
Ghana	Gh₵20	34.43Million	18Million	Gh₵360Million	Gh₵43.2Billion
UK	£20	68.2Million	34Million	£680Million	£8.16Billion
United States of America	$20	339.8Million	200Million	$4Billion	$48Billion

3.4.3 Establishment of Ministry of Lotteries and Bettings

The lotteries institution or organization has been in existence over several decades with the inception of the technological betting industry (sporting industry for instance). With modern intelligence and interest in the sporting industry, the lotteries industry and betting industry is a big sector worth considering and taking to the next level in government. Especially in the case of analyzing the quantum of money generated on daily, weekly, monthly and yearly basis from the lotteries and betting industry. With new creation intelligence, formation and its associated establishment of new ministries in government, it deems fit to add more ministries which have an impact parameter or factor. The Lotteries and betting industry has huge quantum of money in its coffers or accounts comparable to other newly formed ministries in Government in Ghana for instance. This is especially in the case of Ghana’s government like the ministry of Tourism, Ministry of Fisheries and aquaculture (This is same Ministry of Agriculture), Ministry of Communication (same as Ministry of Information). The above-mentioned ministries have been worked on and classified already with Ministry of Tourism for instance in Ghana money generation for ministry operations and impact on Ghana’s economy and development on a minimal level. But think and ask of the impacts of the Lotteries and Betting industry in Ghana in terms of wealth generation, country and world development, keeping faith and hope alive in the life’s of the unemployed graduate, the common citizen, the monthly income level of lottery and betting lovers, tax into government coffers, projects, the happy mode generation philosophy around the lottery, betting and sporting games in Ghana and worldwide and finally the employment industry created or generated? It’s worth to be classified to another level in Ghana and given international recognition in government. These are few reasons for the need for the establishment of MINISTRY OF LOTTERIES AND BETTINGS in Ghana and worldwide. Under the ministry will be the National Lottery Authority (NLA) which is operational in Ghana, the National Betting Authority (NBA) and other departments under them playing pivotal roles. Then at the University level will be the School of Lotteries and Bettings as a school of thought worth teaching and learning, understanding by students for country and world development. Because the lottery Sheet/book in Ghana for instance is a big mathematics manual worth understanding and analyzing. It comprises subjects or topics like permutation (perm) as used by lotto lovers, combinations, additions, subtractions, factorials, week endings (used by teachers for lesson plans preparations), dates in the month, dates or years of events etc. This is a whole school of thought whose manual is released on weekly basis (Mondays for the week) in Ghana for study and getting the five lotto numbers (as answers) after vigorous study and analysis then stamping final authority on it with money for a price or fee or winning amount according to marking scheme, which is the five numbers to be released by the lotto machines. This is the old lotto system in Ghana with results released on Saturdays at 5pm according to research and findings. The concept of Bettings also comprises of additons, subtractions, logical reasoning, graphs analysis, odds determinations, fractions, weigh factors determination, teams’ history, achievement levels, computer programming’s and a whole mathematical concept and philosophies. And these are all university courses and various schools of thoughts worth investigations and researching into. It’s again a good way of learning everything about a sporting game or activity (Football, Basketball, Volleyball, Rugby, Cricket etc) and keeping the data or records for history and unborn generations.

Someone might ask as to whether Lottery and Bettings is worth but according to the biblical books, ‘Jesus cloth was used for this same purpose towards proving a school of thought or investigating something after being hanged on the cross of Calvary’. Where the Roman officials threw a dice on his cloth for a cause, reason or to find out the next person to investigate the issue at hand – as a scenario and possibility for dying on the cross of calvary. According to the first four books of the New Testament ‘Then the soldiers nailed him to the cross. They divided his clothes and threw dice* to decide who would get each piece’. These are mysteries and secrets associated with the Biblical books and life which justifies the various schools of thoughts and philosophical world of intelligence. This is a clear justification for the creation of the School of Lotteries and Bettings and its impacts on world development. The betting industry as a school is dealing with contents such as Fractional odds, algorithms, programming languages etc as indicated above . These are schools of thoughts worth teaching and learning which gives a justification for its representation in the university. Every concept or argument is subject to a lot of assessment, validation and correction before acceptance by all. It is not everything that is consumable can be eaten by all as has been read in the biblical books. Where God asked peter to kill it and eat since everything is cleansed and acceptable unto God. But even that, everything is subject to our own will even though God recommends allowing His will to be done in our lives as can be seen in the books of Moses.

3.5 Mineral gold production coupled with Human Gold Production and Theological Exploration besides Political applications

3.5.1 Mineral Gold Production

Gold as a precious mineral is very expensive when it comes to exploration, discovery, mining and refining to obtain a pure quality mineral for exploits. For exploits is looking at where it can be sold for millions of pounds (M£) towards enrichment of oneself or towards greatness attainment in life. In terms of the enrichment in life is where the gold is quantified in monetary terms after selling and obtained money is used to buy or build mansions, buy cars, establish big companies, help the needy or poor in society, meet the SDG’s, help build a better country or world. It is also used as ornaments for decoration and beauty especially in the case of ancient chiefs and rich men and women. It is been used in this direction but on a lower level due to its huge price tag in this 21st century, difficulty in accessing the mineral and the needed input or effort against cost of investments. It is easy to access with machines but can the common illegal gold miner afford the price or buy one earth moving machine for illegal gold mining in Ghana?

Mineral gold production is accessed through rock mining, surface mining, or on water bodies. Rock mining is where pure gold is accessed from rocks by crushing rocks and embarking on due processing for the real gold in high purity of Karat. This gold is either accessed legally through standard operating procedures like at Newmont Akyem, Newmont Ahafo, Anglogold Ashanti, Persues Mines, Tarkwa Mines, Bogoso Mines etc. But a big question to ask is Anglo-gold comparable to Anlo – gold? (Volta land ‘Anlo’ – gold or? This is a big question worth analyzing from the perspective of tribalism, politics and creation intelligence. It’s a research question worth further investigating and probing. The above listed gold mining companies are all involved in legal gold mining business and operations generating several gold bars per week, per month and yearly towards town development, region development, country and world development. All development are towards enrichment and greatness attainment but in different dimensions. A good example is in meeting the Sustainable Development Goals (SGD’s) of the United Nations and embarking on World Bank projects for the goodwill of all citizens and people worldwide. This same gold is also accessed illegally in Ghana and Nsutam is no exception. The illegal gold mining business in Ghana always comes with a repercussion. The consequences here is the destroying of land resources, water resources, forest reserves, destruction of animals and aquatic habitats and finally the loss of human lives. This is seen on a lighter note on the part of the International gold mining companies due to standardization and the use of standard operating procedures (SOP’s). This is what entails in mineral gold production. That is gold obtained from rocks, soil and in water bodies and refined to a high purity state for enrichment, greatness attainment and meeting SDG’s worldwide by the UN.

But one shouldn’t just be interested in the precious mineral but the difficult and troubling journey towards attainment and final purity in karate or state. Anything worth much in life is worth suffering and acquiring and this is great philosophy associated with gold production worldwide. And this is the case for the mineral gold production worldwide by all legal gold mining companies or from the illegal gold miner (Galamseyers).

3.5.2 Human Gold Production

Gold status attainment and analysis highly depends on view point in life. Everyone and his/her perception, view point in life and understanding level based on the school of thought under consideration. Everything in life or reality boils down to how one sees or perceives it. There is what is called human gold production in life which is another school of thought. This is in two folds; human gold production through the education system and biblical grounds human gold production. The biblical human gold production basically deals with once faith and believe and ability to anchor and struggle through that faith towards greatness or richness attainment in society or country. This will be expatiated in the next sub topic. The human gold production through the education system or educating oneself in school structures or buildings is also explained here.

3.5.2.1 Human gold production through the education system

The human gold production through the education system according to Danquah and Amposah (2024), is explained in this way. The human gold production looks at how one identifies academia or learning in school structures/buildings as the ultimate path and root towards greatness or enrichment in life (refined real gold status). And hence justifies it by climbing the academic ladder from kindergarten to doctor of philosophy (PHD) level and beyond. The basic concept here is seeing a cell as the basic unit of life. Again viewing that, the basic unit of a building or house is a block or brick. The justification here is sowing a seed into the soil in good faith and allowing it to germinate under favorable or unfavorable conditions. Then nurturing it through weeding, mulching, irrigation, pruning, fertilization etc into a giant tree that feeds all with thousand birds playing and laying in it unto the next generation. In this case, one goes through a series or all kinds of learning (about 85% books usage), courses and programs after a well-defined choice of program, profession, career or a school of thought. The student or individual goes through all the pressures, the hustles, struggles, money issues (sika asem) associated with education and mid night burning of candles for several years. This is what one goes through and in doing so, builds a very strong foundation and faith in a chosen field or path through academia with associated spirituality level. All in the name of being refined into pure gold medal, bar or refined individual or personality for greater works or to impact generations in the future. This is where real gold products in the form of graduates are obtained in various fields to help build the nation and world. This research work is justified in doing same for now and future generations through well-defined school building structures that meets the demands of this technological age. With this engineers, lawyers, agriculturists, scientists, artist, business men and women, footballers and other professionals will be trained, refined and obtained as pure gold bars products to serve mankind and future generations. The pure gold products has the potential of serving town, region, and nation or being boxed and shipped to other countries to help build a beautiful world for all. We or most people are finding themselves on the international stage to help build a country or impact the world through this process. Since there are different schools of thoughts and motive for actions and inactions. For instance, another school of thought can be thinking of working on the human penis as a gold production business. These are all schools of thoughts and philosophical intelligent world of creation motives identified through investigations and research. Where one thinks to be seen as man or real man is highly dependent on manhood largeness and size. Where another world of creation thinks real man is highly dependent on intelligence or knowledge level and to another is the quantum of money in the pocket and wealth. These are all human gold production intelligent creations and schools of thoughts.

With a justification for mineral gold production as explained above which balances human gold production, refined man is able to explore, engineer and mine real gold as a refined gold product on planet earth. And then initiate the use of real mineral gold to address needs such as SDG’s of the United Nations (UN) and for World Bank projects. The gold is used as real gold or quantified in terms of monetary languages usable by all. This helps to address all the Sustainable Development Goals (SDG’s) as there will be eradication of poverty, hunger, promote good health and well-being, give quality education (quality human gold production), address gender equality, provide water and electricity for all. From the sustainable development goals (SDG’s) is also peace and justice establishment among citizens and finally, ensures partnership, collaboration and coordination among all the Sustainable Development Goals (SDG’s) for the United Nations and embark on World Bank projects for the good will of all mankind worldwide.

3.5.2.2 Human Gold Production and theological foundations from the Christian perspective

The Bible is made up of books which contains inspirational words from the highest being (God) and meant for correction, nurturing, training and pruning mankind into a refined gold products acceptable unto God himself. This refined human gold products becomes tools or instruments to be used for glorification and accomplishing tasks and missions in His vineyard. This biblical books talks or deals in human gold production but not directly written in the scriptures. But from the concept of schools of thought is a justification for this. The whole concept of the great commission task by Jesus in the Bible is the foundation or basis for human gold production in the Bible. ‘Jesus came and told his disciples, I have been given all authority in heaven and on earth. Therefore go and make disciples of all the nations, baptizing them in the name of the Father and the son and the Holy Spirit. Teach these new disciples to obey all the commands I have given you. And be sure of this; I am with you always, even to the end of the age’. This is the ‘Great Commission’ task from Jesus to his disciples (11 disciples comparable to 11 players forming a football team?) before ascension into the heavens after his salvation work on planet earth. This forms the foundational message and basis for the Christian gospel and family. After the acceptance of Christ into once life and being baptized into the Christian family is the process for work input for once own salvation with fear and trembling at any point in time throughout the Christian journey on earth. This comes with reading the Bible, prayers, fasting, meditations, fellowship and all kinds of religious sacrifices, rituals and activities. All these rituals are geared toward obtaining a good Christian in the vineyard of God and for the work of God. This is also coupled with teachings, correction, counselling’s, help and support from Christians or believers who are at the level of chewing bones as such a person will still be breastfeeding in the vineyard of God. This is seeing life as a dependent and independent figure towards a refined human gold product. The implication here is the mature Christian offering help and support to the new or young believer or babe Christian. Such a young believer or Christian is subject to all kinds of trails, tribulations, fights, hunger, torcher, anguish and all kinds of unnecessary conditions and wilderness from the accuser or enemy. And such a Christian should be willing to pass the examination here through personal hardwork and fight with some support from the mature Christian. The final justification after going through the trials, anguish, torcher and standing tall and strong in the Christian faith to pass the examination is a refined human gold product. That will be formed and fashioned for good use in the vineyard of God towards good works and glorification. This is comparable to refinement of mineral gold by passing it through fire and obtaining refined real gold with high purity and karat. This is summarized in the book of 1 Peter as ‘So be truly glad, there is a wonderful joy ahead even though you have to endure many trials for a little while. The trials will show that your faith is genuine. It is being tested as fire test and purifies gold – though your faith is far more precious than mere gold. So when your faith remains strong through many trials, it will bring you much praise and glory and honour on the day when Jesus Christ is revealed to the whole world’. These are the words of Apostle Peter to the church or Christian’s family concerning trails, tribulation, pain, anguish etc which are legal or illegal gold mining associated issues. These issues are repercussions one does goes through in real life, in the Christian faith or as a gold mining engineer to obtain real mineral gold legally or illegally (Galamsey). This is what the whole church doctrine, concept and process is about. In summary is shown below;

It all begins with the identification of a need, problem, sin factor and hence a salvation hand or man
After this is the confession for sins and inactions;
Then accepting Jesus Christ as Lord and personal savior;
Baptism with flowing water (comparable to Jesus baptism in River Jordan) – Cleansing of oneself with water from dirt as detailed in Danquah (2026) paper.
Then baptism of the Holy Ghost; That is baptism of the Spirit to commune and communicate with God and that is Baptism of the spirit by the Holy Ghost;
Working out of once own salvation with fear and trembling coupled with additions, subtractions, protections, counselling’s and monitoring from mature believers in the Christendom or Christian family; The whole concept of faith, trials, tribulations and gold refinement and processing stages in the human gold production business is seen here;
At the maturity level in the Christian journey will be the final refined human gold products for greater works in God’s vineyard and world development to propagate the gospel unto future generations.

This final refined human gold product is the treasure to propagate the gospel to the ends of the world. Such a human gold product is the new leader to lead the next generation through the same church gold mining or religious gold mining process. These refined human gold products are embedded with spiritual gifts and justified as Apostles, Prophets, Pastors, Teachers, Miracle workers, etc for the edification of the church. The basic spiritual gift unto all is a teacher as everyone on earth is seen teaching in various ways. So everyone has a spiritual gift as can be seen in the book of 1 Corinthians. This is comparable to a lecturer, engineer, Dentist or Doctor who is now a human gold product from another school of thought to help build a better world and leave it in the hands of the next generation. This will be towards meeting the United Nations Sustainable Development Goals (UN SDG’s) and Working out World Bank projects to help the most vulnerable in society. This most vulnerable person is comparable to a sinner who doesn’t know God and needs to accept Christ as Lord and personal saviour and taking through the human gold production process like a clay in potter’s hand. This clay is worked on and taking through several processes towards obtaining a final product with defined quality and beauty for glorification and enrichment in life. This is the human gold production in the direction of the Christian faith and is possibly same in other religious bodies or doctrines like the Moslem, the Buddhist, Traditionalist or idol worshipper etc. A good example explaining this three gold mining concepts and philosophy elaborated above are Newmont Akyem at Abirim (Now Zijin Golden Ridge Limited), the University of Environment and Sustainable Development (UESD) under construction at Bunso and the Church of Pentecost in Eastern Region salvation work. The current state of water resources in the Eastern Region is very bad as all water bodies have been destroyed due to illegal gold mining activities and business in the region. These water bodies are a function and foundation stones when it comes to Christian faith, usage and importance in the human gold production in the direction of the Christian perspective and theological backgrounds. This is can be seen in another paper as written by Danquah (2026). These water resources needs to be worked on for a balance between water on land, water above and water underground in order to protect and conserve the hydrological cycle. A whole school of thought worth probing further in this 2025/2026 under the NDC government.

The Newmont Akyem gold mining project is a project modelled from Newmont Ahafo gold mining project and the current status in terms of legal gold mining business, operation and management in Ghana and worldwide. With this intelligence, model and further work is the current number of gold mining companies like Transeco, BSD, CG Mining, Narawa etc which are to be worked on and elevated to Newmont Akyem at Abirim (now Zijin Golden Ridge Limited) status with pulling and building intelligence (principal/capital or resources). This has raised a lot of interests and concerns after work done and high interest in gold mining business and its operations in the Eastern Region of Ghana. These are worth investigating further with the region as resources are to be protected, managed and kept for now and future generations.

3.5.3 Gold mining business creation coupled with Tribal and Political competition in this 21st Century

Ghana in this 21st Century is seeing a creation around this gold mining intelligence and creation and the major question being asked by all (from all schools of thoughts); which tribe or country is ascribed to this gold mining business in Ghana and worldwide? Or which country worldwide is responsible for this gold mining project or initiating the gold mining business creation intelligence that was done years back and shot into the world to pilot or spearhead the world to today. A justification of gold mining business creation towards a day for another creation to take the next generation or world to another level? Is it the Akwapim man, is it the Ashanti Man, is it the northerner, is it the Fante man, is it the Ewe man, is it the Ga man, is it the Akyem man, is it the Kwahu man, is it the Kyerepong man or is it any other tribe in Ghana. Or is it the British, is it the India man, is it the American man, is the Portuguese, is it the French man, is it the German, is it the man from Burkina Faso or is it any man from another country. Is it from the New Patriotic Party (NPP), is it from the National Democratic Congress (NDC), and is it from the Democrats or from the Republican, or from which political party worldwide?

From research and investigations, the current legal and illegal gold mining activities and impacts in Ghana is a scenario from past creation, activities, actions and inactions when talking about gold mining business on planet earth. Therefore, who is responsible for this creation based on tribal, country or political grounds? And assuming this creation was done 200 years ago and shot to take off or spearhead the world to the next level, to the next generation; where are the creators, implementers and all those who did this hard work? Aren’t they dead and gone with the planet earth or world in place for new creations, inventions, modifications, additions and subtractions for the good will of all? Where is their wealth, riches, greatness, intelligence and contributions to humanity and world development? It is only records in books or internet that can record or talk about such great men dreams, works, dreams and contributions to world creation and development in life. This is what justifies dreams and greatness embedded in books, in the grave and spiritual realms. This is the reason for the Christian faith which believes in spiritual realm operation coupled with physical realm manifestation before God and all mankind for the advancement of the world unto the next generations.

4 CONCLUSIONS

The 21st Century mineral gold and human gold mining business is seeing battling from all angles for justification and validation of ownership and greatness height in world governance and rulership. But if everything is towards the goodwill of humanity and mankind, then the United Nations (one united world composed of different countries with its citizens and having all mankind at will and at heart) Sustainable Development Goals should be the main objective for all towards equitable sharing of resources. The equitable sharing of country or world resources is highly dependent on ability, intelligence level, education level, experience and impact towards country development, world development and greatness. That is the minister of the Gospel and minister in Parliament or governance, the engineer, the scientist, the artist, the security personnel and all schools of thoughts graduates will contribute their parts towards mineral gold and human gold production for the goodwill of all mankind worldwide. The need and importance to know that everyone is important when it talking about impact, effect and world development. And hence a justification for someone to hold just a single match stick at a corner on planet earth towards world development, growth and propagation of the gold mining business worldwide. This will help meet the United Nations Sustainable Development Goals (SDG’s) for the good will and wellbeing of mankind while embarking on World Bank projects in order to meet the financial needs of all.

Acknowledgment

I am grateful to the Almighty God for this Revelational knowledge, ability and strength for this research work on human gold production and mineral gold production in Ghana. I am again thankful to the UNITED NATIONS and WORLD BANK for this opportunity and in serving mankind and the world. I am grateful to His Royal Majesty, Osagyefuo Amoatia Ofori Panin, the king of Abuakwa Traditional Area in the Eastern Region of Ghana for given a consideration to not ‘laying all eggs in one basket’ and also not ‘laying into the basket of the deceiver as it lays outside the basket’. I am again grateful to Osabarima Abeam Brakatu Ofori Aninkrah who is the King of Bunso Traditional Area also in the Eastern Region of Ghana for the opportunity of serving the land, world and for proofreading this research paper. I am again thankful to the people of Nsutam, Osino, Kyebi, Enyiresi, Bepoase, Akyem Tafo, Kukurantumi, Akyem Abirim, Goaso, Kenyasi, Bunso, Koforidua, Accra, Kumasi, Bolgatanga, Wa, Takoradi, the Eastern Region and Ghana as a whole which are study area locations for this political paper. I am again grateful to the Danquah and Gyadu families at Nsutam, Bunso and Bepoase, the Darko and Kissiwa families at Kukurantumi and Kwahu areas all in the Eastern Region of Ghana. I acknowledge the role of my wife, Mrs Rita Abena Darko in my life and my two lovely boys; Gates Odoi Danquah and Michael Darko Danquah. My final gratification goes to my family worldwide as we all strive to work hard in meeting and addressing all the 17 Sustainable Development Goals (SDG’s) collaboratively towards the greatness and goodwill of all mankind worldwide. God bless us all.

References

Danquah, I. O., Amposah, G, 2024, Geotechnical Investigation and Assessment of Modern Building Foundation, Journal for Studies in Management and Planning, India.

Daily writing prompt

What’s a classic book that you think is overrated?

View all responses

How to Start Teaching Online in India in 2026: A Complete Guide for Tutors on UrbanPro

Everything you need to know to build a thriving online teaching career in India — from registration to earning your first ₹10,000 a month.

Introduction

Online teaching jobs in India are currently one of the most searched employment categories, with over 1,35,000 monthly searches for ‘online teaching jobs India’ alone. The demand for qualified tutors is at an all-time high — and platforms like UrbanPro are making it easier than ever to connect with students across the country.

Whether you are a schoolteacher looking to supplement your income, a fresh graduate with subject expertise, or a professional wanting to share your skills — this guide will show you exactly how to start teaching online in India in 2026 and build a sustainable income from it.

Why Online Teaching Is One of the Best Work-From-Home Opportunities in India

The Indian online education market is projected to grow at 28% CAGR through 2030. This means demand for quality tutors is only going to increase. Here is why online teaching makes excellent career sense:

High earning potential: Experienced tutors on UrbanPro earn between ₹500 and ₹3,000+ per hour depending on subject and level.
Flexible schedule: Teach at times that suit you — evenings, weekends, or full-time. You control your calendar.
No commute: Teach from home via laptop or smartphone. All you need is a decent internet connection.
Massive student base: UrbanPro has 55 lakh+ students actively searching for tutors across India’s top cities and Tier-2 towns.
Growing demand in Tier-2/3 cities: Industry data shows Tier-2 and Tier-3 cities are the fastest-growing segments in Indian online education.

Who Can Become an Online Tutor in India?

The eligibility bar for online tutoring in India is broad. You can teach online if you are:

A schoolteacher or college lecturer with subject expertise.
A graduate or postgraduate with strong academic knowledge.
A working professional who can teach skills like Python, Excel, digital marketing, or accounting.
A language expert who can teach Spoken English, French, German, Spanish, or regional languages.
A hobby/arts professional — yoga instructor, dance teacher, guitar player, or painter.
A competitive exam coach for JEE, NEET, UPSC, IELTS, or IBPS.

Step-by-Step: How to Register as a Tutor on UrbanPro

Step 1 — Create Your Tutor Profile

Go to UrbanPro.com and click ‘Signup as a Tutor’. Fill in your name, location, and contact details. Choose the categories you want to teach — Tuition, Languages, IT Courses, Hobby Classes, or Exam Coaching.

Step 2 — Add Your Qualifications and Experience

A strong profile is your most important marketing tool. Make sure you include:

Your educational qualifications (degree, certifications).
Years of teaching experience and subjects taught.
A professional profile photo — profiles with photos get 70% more enquiries.
A well-written bio describing your teaching style and what students can expect.

Step 3 — Set Your Availability and Fees

List your available time slots and set your hourly or monthly fee. Research what other tutors in your subject and level charge — competitive pricing in the beginning can help you build reviews faster.

Step 4 — Respond Quickly to Enquiries

When students or parents send enquiries, respond within a few hours. Fast response rates significantly improve your chances of converting an enquiry into a paid student. UrbanPro sends real-time notifications via app and SMS.

Step 5 — Deliver Outstanding Demo Classes

The demo class is your chance to impress. Prepare a structured 30-minute lesson that showcases your teaching clarity, subject depth, and ability to engage the student. A great demo almost always converts to a paid engagement.

Top Categories in Highest Demand on UrbanPro (2026)

Based on search volume data and UrbanPro’s platform activity, these are the hottest teaching opportunities right now:

Class 10 & 12 Tuition: Boards season drives massive demand — maths, science, English, and commerce subjects are top picks.
JEE / NEET Coaching: Physics, Chemistry, Biology tutors are in extremely high demand year-round.
Spoken English: One of the most searched categories in India with 1,65,000+ monthly searches.
Python & Data Science: IT professionals can earn premium rates — one of the highest CPC categories.
Online Yoga Classes: Post-wellness boom, yoga instructors have a strong, growing audience.
UPSC & SSC Coaching: High-intent students willing to invest in quality coaching — strong earning category.
IELTS Coaching: Huge demand from students planning to study or migrate abroad.

How Much Can You Earn as an Online Tutor in India?

Earnings vary by subject, level, and how many hours you teach. Here are realistic monthly earning benchmarks:

Beginner tutor (5-10 hrs/week): ₹8,000 – ₹20,000 per month.
Part-time tutor (15-20 hrs/week): ₹25,000 – ₹60,000 per month.
Full-time tutor (30+ hrs/week): ₹70,000 – ₹1,50,000+ per month.
Premium subject specialist (JEE/NEET/UPSC): ₹1,00,000 – ₹3,00,000+ per month.

The key to higher earnings is building a strong review profile, becoming a specialist in high-demand subjects, and maintaining consistent quality across all sessions.

Pro Tips to Grow Your Online Teaching Business

Collect student reviews actively — a profile with 10+ positive reviews gets 5x more enquiries than a new profile.
Upload a short video introduction to your profile. Video profiles significantly increase trust and conversion.
Be responsive and professional in all communication with parents and students.
Offer trial or discounted demo sessions initially to build your review base quickly.
Upskill regularly — tutors who teach trending topics like AI basics, data science, or digital skills command premium fees.
Use UrbanPro’s built-in tools — scheduling, payments, and messaging — to keep your workflow professional.

Conclusion

Online teaching in India is not just a side hustle anymore — it is a legitimate, scalable career. With India’s EdTech market growing at 28% CAGR and platforms like UrbanPro giving you direct access to millions of students, the opportunity has never been bigger.

Start by creating your free tutor profile on UrbanPro today. Build your reviews, specialise in a high-demand subject, and watch your teaching income grow month after month. The students are already searching — all you need to do is show up.

Daily writing prompt

Who are some underrated people in history?

View all responses

A Review of Closed-Loop Supply Chain Research: Theoretical Evolution, Practical Applications, and Future Prospects

Wang Piaoran¹*, Wang Feifan²

¹Farabi International Business School, Al-Farabi Kazakh National University, Almaty,

Kazakhstan

* Corresponding author: wangpiaoran7@gmail.com

ORCID: https://orcid.org/0009-0009-9412-5720

²Farabi International Business School, Al-Farabi Kazakh National University, Almaty,

Kazakhstan

Email: wangfeifan969@gmail.com

ORCID: https://orcid.org/0009-0003-4197-0492

Abstract

Closed-loop supply chain (CLSC) is an important paradigm for sustainable supply chain management. This paper systematically reviews domestic and international literature to summarize the evolution of this field from linear supply chains to the circular economy transition. The study identifies three major trends in CLSC research: a shift from single-link optimization to whole-chain collaborative governance; an evolution from cost-orientation to value co-creation; and a move from deterministic modeling to robust optimization and intelligent decision-making. This paper further analyzes typical cases including new energy vehicle power battery recycling, electronic product remanufacturing, and apparel reverse logistics to reveal the application mechanisms and practical values of CLSC in different industrial contexts. The results show that the effective operation of CLSC requires systematic governance supported by government policies, enterprise strategic coordination, technological innovation, and consumer participation. Future research should focus on cutting-edge topics such as artificial intelligence-enabled intelligent decision-making and supply chain resilience mechanisms.

Keywords: Closed-loop supply chain; Reverse logistics; Power battery recycling; Sustainable development

1. Introduction

Traditional supply chains have long followed the linear model of “extract–make–use–dispose”. While promoting economic development, this model has also led to resource depletion, environmental pollution, and other problems (Guide & Van Wassenhove, 2009). At present, more than 50 million tons of electronic waste are generated globally each year, and large amounts of waste clothing are incinerated or landfilled. Low resource utilization has become a key bottleneck restricting sustainable development.

Against this background, the closed-loop supply chain has emerged. Unlike traditional linear supply chains, CLSC emphasizes the closed-loop flow of materials. After their service life, products are not simply discarded but recycled, remanufactured, redistributed, or safely disposed through reverse logistics networks (Fleischmann et al., 1997). Its core lies in creating “value recovery” opportunities to extend product life cycles through remanufacturing, reuse, and recycling, thereby generating economic benefits while reducing environmental burdens and achieving the unity of commercial and social values.

In recent years, research on CLSC has grown rapidly. Early studies mainly focused on reverse logistics network design and cost optimization, and gradually expanded to multiple directions such as supply chain coordination mechanisms, carbon emission constraint optimization, and intelligent decision support systems (Rodríguez‑Escoto et al., 2024). Notably, the booming new energy vehicle industry has triggered a large-scale wave of decommissioned power batteries, making power battery recycling and echelon utilization a new hotspot in CLSC research. This paper aims to systematically sort out the theoretical evolution of CLSC research, summarize the main research themes and methodological characteristics, and reveal the practical application mechanisms of CLSC through typical case studies. The research provides important references for promoting the theoretical development of CLSC and guiding enterprise practice and decision-making.

2. Literature Review

Research on closed-loop supply chains has evolved from conceptual initiation to systematic improvement. In the early 1990s, scholars began to focus on end-of-life product management and proposed the conceptual framework of “reverse logistics” (Dell, 1998; Rogers & Tibben‑Lembke, 1999). Subsequent studies recognized the need to systematically integrate forward and reverse logistics, giving rise to the concept of closed-loop supply chains. Guide and Van Wassenhove (2009) pointed out that the core of CLSC is “value recovery”, extending product life cycles through remanufacturing, reuse, and recycling.

From the perspective of research evolution, CLSC studies can be roughly divided into three stages. The first stage (1990–2000) focused on basic issues such as reverse logistics network design, recycling channel location, and inventory optimization. The second stage (2000–2015) shifted to supply chain coordination mechanisms, profit-sharing contracts, and incentive mechanism design under information asymmetry. The third stage (2015–present), driven by the sustainable development agenda, has focused on carbon emission constraints, green procurement, and ecological design. Meanwhile, the rapid development of artificial intelligence has brought new research opportunities for CLSC (Sahamie et al., 2013).

Regarding research content, scholars have explored the design of recycling networks including topology, node location, and capacity allocation. Due to widespread demand uncertainty and recycling rate fluctuations, robust optimization has attracted attention for its ability to handle uncertain problems (Elsevier, 2026a). Rodríguez‑Escoto et al. (2024) constructed a multi-objective optimization model considering economic cost, environmental impact, and social benefits. They found that introducing environmental objectives increases operating costs by 15%–20% but significantly reduces carbon emissions. In addition, the impacts of policy tools such as carbon subsidies and tax incentives on remanufacturing decisions have been studied, showing that moderate carbon subsidies can encourage enterprises to carry out remanufacturing (Zhang & Li, 2023).

The connection between CLSC and sustainable development has become increasingly close. A World Economic Forum (2025) report states that CLSC is a key path to industrial circular transformation, and leading enterprises can reduce waste emissions by 30%–50% by building closed-loop networks. The application of artificial intelligence has become a new trend, with machine learning, deep learning, and reinforcement learning applied to demand forecasting, inventory optimization, and reverse logistics routing (IEEE, 2024a). Decision support systems can improve operational efficiency by 20%–30% (Elsevier, 2024a). Risk modeling addresses disruptions, quality fluctuations, market changes, and policy adjustments (IEEE, 2024b).

3. Research Methods

This study adopts a combined paradigm of systematic literature review and case analysis.

For the literature review, major databases including Web of Science, Scopus, Elsevier ScienceDirect, and Google Scholar are used. Search keywords include “closed-loop supply chain”, “reverse logistics”, “remanufacturing”, “battery recycling”, and “reverse supply chain”. The inclusion criteria are peer-reviewed journal or conference papers directly related to CLSC published after 2000. Non-Chinese/English papers, purely methodological studies without empirical applications, and full-text-unavailable documents are excluded. Content analysis is used to code the included literature and extract research questions, theoretical perspectives, methodologies, and core findings.

For case analysis, a multiple-case study method is adopted. Three typical cases are selected: new energy vehicle power battery recycling, electronic product remanufacturing, and apparel reverse logistics. Cases are chosen for representativeness, covering different industries and including both mature applications and emerging practices.

The literature review provides theoretical perspectives and research contexts, while case analysis presents application mechanisms and value creation paths in practice. The two approaches verify and complement each other, supporting a systematic review and in-depth understanding of CLSC research.

4. Research Results

4.1 Distribution of Research Themes

Through literature analysis, CLSC research covers six major thematic areas. These themes are interrelated and progressive, forming a complete knowledge system.

Table 1 Distribution of Research Themes in Closed-Loop Supply Chain Studies

Theme	Proportion	Main Content
Network Design and Optimization	25%	Topology, node location, capacity allocation
Coordination Mechanisms	20%	Contract design, profit distribution, information sharing
Remanufacturing Decisions	20%	Feasibility assessment, process routes, quality control
Recycling and Reverse Logistics	15%	Channel design, routing optimization, pricing strategies
Sustainable Development	12%	Carbon constraints, green procurement, eco-design
Intelligent Decision and Risk	8%	AI applications, blockchain, risk identification

4.2 Typical Cases

4.2.1 Power Battery Recycling

The rapid development of the new energy vehicle industry has led to a large number of decommissioned power batteries, making their treatment increasingly prominent. Power batteries contain scarce metals such as lithium, cobalt, and nickel, so recycling has important economic and environmental value.

Representative enterprises such as CATL and BYD have established full-life-cycle power battery management systems. Brunp Recycling under CATD has built a closed-loop system: “battery production–use–echelon utilization–recycling”, achieving a recovery rate of over 99% for nickel, cobalt, and manganese. This model reduces raw material costs and environmental pollution, verifying the practical value of CLSC in the power battery field.

4.2.2 Electronic Product Remanufacturing

Electronic product remanufacturing is one of the most commercialized CLSC fields. Enterprises such as IBM and Dell have remanufacturing programs that refurbish retired enterprise servers and sell them at a discount to small and medium-sized enterprises. Compared with new manufacturing, remanufactured servers reduce energy consumption and carbon emissions by about 50%. A core challenge is product quality uncertainty: remaining life and condition vary widely, requiring strict quality assessment and pricing.

4.2.3 Apparel Reverse Logistics

The apparel industry is a typical linear economy sector and an important testing ground for CLSC innovation. Fast fashion brands such as H&M, Zara, and Uniqlo have launched clothing recycling programs where consumers can exchange old clothes for discount coupons. However, actual closed-loop effects are limited: most recycled clothes are exported to secondhand markets or used as industrial rags, with less than 1% recycled into new fibers. This shows that building recycling channels does not equal real closed-loop realization.

High-end outdoor brands such as Patagonia have explored high-value closed-loop models. Its “Worn Wear” program recycles, professionally refurbishes, and offers trade-ins. Refurbished products are sold at 70%–80% of the original price, effectively extending product life cycles. This case indicates that successful CLSC requires not only recycling networks but also deep value connections with consumers to achieve both commercial and environmental benefits through product servitization.

4.3 Summary

Based on literature and case analysis, three core findings are obtained. First, CLSC research has formed a relatively complete theoretical system, shifting from single-link optimization to whole-chain collaborative governance, reflecting deeper systematic understanding. Second, CLSC shows differentiated characteristics and diverse values across industries, requiring industry-specific design. Third, effective CLSC operation demands multi-stakeholder coordination: government policy support, enterprise strategic coordination, technological innovation, and consumer participation are all indispensable. Systematic thinking is key to understanding and advancing CLSC.

5. Discussion

The literature review reveals three theoretical contributions of CLSC research: constructing a CLSC analytical framework that integrates forward and reverse supply chains from a systems perspective; developing supply chain coordination theory with rich contexts of multiple uncertainties; and expanding sustainable supply chain management theory by incorporating environmental externalities into decision-making, leading to carbon-constrained supply chain optimization and green supply chain performance evaluation.

The findings have important practical implications. For enterprises, CLSC has become a strategic tool for competitive advantage. They should actively apply AI, IoT, and blockchain to improve CLSC intelligence. For supply chain governance, reasonable profit-sharing mechanisms and long-term stable reverse logistics networks are needed. Government support is critical: carbon subsidies, tax incentives, and extended producer responsibility can effectively promote CLSC practices, but balance between environmental goals and economic efficiency is required.

This study has limitations: qualitative literature evaluation involves subjectivity; it focuses on academic literature and does not fully include industry reports and enterprise practices. Future CLSC research can focus on: AI-enabled intelligent decision-making and deep reinforcement learning for dynamic optimization; supply chain resilience and risk management under emergencies; digital CLSC with digital twin and industrial internet for full-process visualization and intelligent scheduling.

6. Conclusion

Through systematic literature review and case analysis, this paper sorts out the theoretical evolution, research themes, and methodological characteristics of CLSC research. It covers network design, coordination mechanisms, remanufacturing decisions, recycling optimization, green transformation, and intelligent decision-making, forming a complete theoretical system. Three major trends in CLSC research reflect the deepening understanding of its complexity. Cases such as power battery recycling, electronic product remanufacturing, and apparel reverse logistics show that CLSC presents differentiated features and diverse values in different industrial scenarios. Enterprises should select suitable CLSC business models and operational strategies according to their industry characteristics and resource endowments.

With the promotion of circular economy and sustainable development goals, CLSC will play an increasingly important role in corporate strategy and industrial policy. Especially under the rapid development of artificial intelligence, the effective integration of intelligent technology and CLSC operations will be an important direction for theoretical research and practical exploration.

References

Dell. (1998). The defragmentation of corporate America [Corporate report]. Dell Inc.

Elsevier. (2024a). Decision support systems for a resilient and sustainable closed loop supply chain. Decision Support Systems, 114182. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.dss.2024.114182

Elsevier. (2026a). A robust optimization model for a green closed‑loop supply chain network design. Procedia Manufacturing. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.promfg.2026.01.023

Elsevier. (2026b). Coordination in closed‑loop supply chains with remanufacturing: A bibliometric and cluster analysis. Procedia CIRP. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.procir.2026.01.045

Elsevier. (2026c). Optimizing pricing, greening, recycling, and emission reduction in a closed‑loop supply chain. Journal of Cleaner Production. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jclepro.2026.01.087

Fleischmann, M., Bloemhof‑Ruwaard, J. M., Dekker, R., van der Laan, E., van Nunen, J. A., & Van Wassenhove, L. N. (1997). Quantitative models for reverse logistics: A review. European Journal of Operational Research, 103(1), 1–17. https://doi.org/10.1016/S0377‑2217(97)00230‑0

Guide, V. D. R., & Van Wassenhove, L. N. (2009). Closed‑loop supply chains: An introduction to the feature issue (Part 1). Production and Operations Management, 18(5), 481–486. https://doi.org/10.1111/j.1937‑5956.2009.01033.x

IEEE. (2024a). Exploring the role of artificial intelligence in closed‑loop supply chain. IEEE Transactions on Engineering Management. https://doi.org/10.1109/TEM.2024.3387215

IEEE. (2024b). Risk modeling framework for strategic and operational intervention to enhance the effectiveness of a closed‑loop supply chain. IEEE Transactions on Engineering Management. https://doi.org/10.1109/TEM.2024.3356789

Rodríguez‑Escoto, M., et al. (2024). A multi‑objective sustainable closed‑loop supply chain network design with robust optimization. International Transactions in Operational Research. https://doi.org/10.1111/itor.13345

Rogers, D. S., & Tibben‑Lembke, R. S. (1999). Going backwards: Reverse logistics trends and practices [Industry report]. Reverse Logistics Executive Council.

Sahamie, R., et al. (2013). Transdisciplinary research in sustainable operations: An application to closed‑loop supply chains. Business Strategy and the Environment, 22(4), 245–268. https://doi.org/10.1002/bse.1756

World Economic Forum. (2025). Circular transformation of industries 2025: Leveraging closed‑loop supply chains for sustainable development [Industry report]. WEF Publications.

Zhang, W., & Li, Q. (2023). Construction and empirical test of remanufacturing closed-loop supply chain model considering carbon subsidy. Chinese Journal of Management Science, 31(5), 123–134.

Wang, F., & Liu, C. (2022). Research on recycling and pricing strategy of new energy vehicle power batteries in closed-loop supply chain. Systems Engineering — Theory & Practice, 42(8), 2158–2172.

Daily writing prompt

What’s a thing you were completely obsessed with as a kid?

View all responses

MiCA Compliance Becomes a Priority for Crypto Firms as LegalBison Launches Research Initiative

The European crypto industry is entering a new regulatory era as the Markets in Crypto-Assets (MiCA) framework moves closer to full implementation. For many digital asset companies, the challenge is no longer whether regulation is coming, but how quickly they can adapt their businesses to meet the new requirements.

Against this backdrop, LegalBison has introduced a new research series aimed at helping crypto operators better understand the realities of MiCA compliance and licensing across the European Union.

According to Reuters, LegalBison partnered with Bitcoin.com News to launch “MiCA Decoded,” a 12-part editorial series focused on the operational and legal aspects of the EU’s crypto regulations.

The initiative combines data from public CASP registers, information published by the European Securities and Markets Authority (ESMA), and LegalBison’s own experience working with crypto licensing applications in multiple jurisdictions. Rather than offering general commentary on regulation, the series focuses on practical details that companies often misunderstand during the licensing process.

One of the key topics covered is the structure of the Crypto-Asset Service Provider (CASP) authorization system. The research points out that although more than 170 entities appear in the register, only a limited number currently have authorization to operate centralized cryptocurrency exchanges. This highlights the level of scrutiny regulators are applying to applications and the growing importance of compliance preparation.

The series also examines how MiCA timelines work in practice. While many companies rely on simplified estimates for approval periods, the actual operational process can take significantly longer depending on the jurisdiction, internal documentation, and communication with regulators. LegalBison argues that misunderstanding these timelines is one of the most common reasons crypto businesses experience delays or unsuccessful applications.

Another important issue discussed in the research is the preparation of crypto asset white papers. Under MiCA, projects must provide detailed documentation explaining the structure, purpose, and risks associated with their digital assets. The series notes that many founders still rely on informal or incomplete formats that may not satisfy regulatory expectations. As compliance standards become stricter, documentation quality is becoming a critical factor in the authorization process.

Jurisdictional strategy is another major focus. Although MiCA creates a unified framework across the EU, implementation can still vary between member states. Different countries may offer varying processing speeds, regulatory approaches, and operational advantages for crypto businesses. The research explores how companies evaluate these factors when deciding where to establish their licensing operations.

The growing attention around MiCA reflects a broader shift in the digital asset industry. Regulators are increasingly treating crypto businesses similarly to traditional financial institutions, especially in areas such as anti-money laundering controls, customer verification, operational transparency, and consumer protection. As a result, compliance is becoming part of long-term business strategy rather than a temporary legal obligation.

Industry analysts believe that companies capable of adapting early may gain a competitive advantage as the market matures. Firms with approved licenses are likely to benefit from stronger banking relationships, improved credibility with institutional partners, and broader access to European customers. At the same time, businesses that fail to meet the requirements could face operational restrictions or lose access to key markets.

LegalBison specializes in legal and regulatory services for fintech and digital asset companies. The firm supports projects with licensing strategy, regulatory architecture, AML and KYC compliance programs, and communication with authorities in multiple jurisdictions. Its operational network spans more than 50 countries, with offices in locations including Warsaw, Tallinn, Panama City, Manama, and Kuala Lumpur.

As the implementation deadlines approach, demand for regulatory guidance across the crypto sector is expected to continue growing. Educational initiatives such as “MiCA Decoded” reflect the industry’s increasing need for practical information based on real licensing experience rather than theoretical interpretation alone.

Daily writing prompt

What’s a classic book that you think is overrated?

View all responses

IQ Option Safety Review 2026: What Nigerian Traders Should Consider

As online trading continues to expand in Nigeria, more users are evaluating international platforms that promise access to global markets. Among them, IQ Option remains one of the most discussed names, raising questions about both legitimacy and security.

As covered by Tribune Online, the platform has been operating for over a decade and serves millions of users across different regions. While longevity can indicate stability, traders still need to assess how the platform functions and what safeguards are actually in place.

From a security perspective, IQ Option follows standard industry protocols. It operates under SKY LADDER LLC, registered in Antigua and Barbuda, and implements SSL encryption to protect data transmission. Account-level protection includes two-factor authentication, which adds an extra verification step during login. Another structural element is the separation of client funds from company funds—this is intended to prevent misuse and ensure that user balances are not tied to operational expenses.

Functionality plays a major role in evaluating platform safety. IQ Option offers a multi-asset environment where users can trade forex pairs, cryptocurrencies, stocks via CFDs, commodities, indices, and options. Having all instruments accessible within one interface simplifies the trading process, especially for users who want to diversify without switching platforms. The system also includes analytical tools such as RSI, MACD, and Bollinger Bands, which help traders interpret price movements and make more informed decisions.

One of the more notable features is how the platform structures risk. Unlike margin-based systems where losses can exceed deposits, IQ Option limits the maximum loss to the amount placed on a trade. This means traders cannot accumulate debt through trading activity. Additional tools enhance this control:

Stop-loss orders automatically close positions to limit downside risk
Take-profit settings secure gains once a target level is reached
Early closure allows traders to exit positions before expiration
Price alerts notify users when specific levels are reached

These mechanisms are built into the platform rather than offered as optional add-ons, which contributes to a more controlled trading environment.

Despite these safeguards, user feedback reveals some recurring concerns. Most complaints are related to withdrawal timing, particularly when accounts are undergoing verification. This process—commonly known as KYC (Know Your Customer)—requires identity and address confirmation before funds can be released. While standard across financial platforms, it can create delays if users are unprepared. Another common issue involves bonus terms, where traders activate promotions without fully understanding the conditions attached.

The onboarding process itself is relatively straightforward. New users can begin with a demo account that includes virtual funds, allowing them to explore the interface risk-free. Transitioning to a live account requires a minimum deposit, and Nigerian users can fund accounts through local payment systems. Withdrawals are processed back to local bank accounts, typically within several working days depending on verification status.

It is also important to consider regulatory context. IQ Option does not hold a Nigerian SEC license, which means it operates without local regulatory oversight. For some traders, this may be a significant factor when evaluating trust and accountability. Others may prioritize functionality, accessibility, and global presence instead.

In practical terms, the platform’s safety depends not only on its technical infrastructure but also on how it is used. Trading inherently involves financial risk, and no system can eliminate the possibility of loss. Tools and protections can reduce exposure, but they cannot replace strategy, discipline, or market understanding.

Overall, IQ Option presents itself as a legitimate trading platform with established security measures and operational history. For Nigerian traders, the key is to approach it with realistic expectations: use the demo environment first, understand all terms—especially bonuses—and ensure full account verification before initiating withdrawals.

Daily writing prompt

What are the biggest benefits of minimalist living?

View all responses

CryptoProcessing by Coinspaid Achieves Highest CCSS Security Certification

The cryptocurrency sector is continuing to evolve from a niche financial market into a broader institutional ecosystem, and with that growth comes increasing attention to infrastructure security. As more enterprises and financial organizations integrate digital assets into their operations, independently verified cybersecurity standards are becoming a critical factor when selecting crypto payment and custody providers.

As noted by CoinMarketCap Community, CryptoProcessing by Coinspaid has achieved CCSS Level 3 certification for its Institutional-Grade Key Management and Wallet Infrastructure. The certification is the highest level available under the Cryptocurrency Security Standard framework developed by the CryptoCurrency Certification Consortium (C4).

The independent audit was conducted by Hacken, a cybersecurity and blockchain infrastructure auditor approved by C4. The assessment started in the fourth quarter of 2025 and reviewed the company’s Full System operational environment.

CCSS, short for Cryptocurrency Security Standard, is a framework created specifically for digital asset infrastructure. Unlike traditional cybersecurity certifications that focus mainly on general IT systems, CCSS evaluates the operational and technical processes directly involved in cryptocurrency management. This includes how companies generate, store, back up, and protect cryptographic keys, as well as how transactions are authorized and monitored.

The framework is widely recognized within the crypto industry because it addresses the unique risks associated with blockchain-based financial systems. Cryptocurrency infrastructure depends heavily on secure key management since private keys control access to digital assets. If these keys are compromised, funds can potentially be lost permanently. As a result, CCSS places significant emphasis on operational discipline, governance procedures, and layered security controls.

Level 3 is considered the most demanding tier within the CCSS framework. To achieve it, organizations must demonstrate mature infrastructure management, formalized operational policies, and advanced protection mechanisms across the entire system environment. Certification at this level indicates that security practices are integrated into everyday operations rather than implemented only as isolated safeguards.

During the audit, Hacken reviewed multiple areas of CryptoProcessing’s infrastructure. The assessment covered key generation processes, wallet creation procedures, secure key storage systems, backup protocols, access management controls, transaction authorization workflows, logging and monitoring mechanisms, and incident response strategies related to key compromise scenarios.

According to the findings, CryptoProcessing applies governance standards and operational procedures aligned with recognized crypto-native security practices. The review also confirmed that the company maintains structured risk management policies across its infrastructure environment.

The growing importance of certifications like CCSS reflects broader changes taking place across the digital asset industry. Enterprise clients and institutional investors are no longer evaluating providers only on transaction speed or payment functionality. Security transparency and independently validated infrastructure have become equally important, particularly for businesses managing large transaction volumes or operating under strict compliance requirements.

Independent audits can also simplify due diligence processes for financial institutions, banks, and corporate partners considering cryptocurrency integrations. In many cases, organizations entering the crypto sector must demonstrate that their partners follow recognized operational and cybersecurity standards before cooperation can proceed.

Another important factor is regulation. Governments and financial authorities around the world are introducing more detailed frameworks for digital asset oversight. In Europe, regulations such as MiCA and DORA are increasing expectations related to operational resilience, cybersecurity governance, and infrastructure reliability. Companies with independently verified security frameworks may find it easier to align with these regulatory standards.

Max Krupyshev, Executive Leader at CryptoProcessing, described the certification as a meaningful milestone for the company. According to him, CCSS Level 3 requires disciplined operations, resilient security controls, and formalized governance structures across the entire infrastructure environment. He noted that the certification validates the company’s operational maturity and reinforces trust for businesses relying on secure digital asset operations at scale.

CryptoProcessing by Coinspaid stated that it plans to continue investing in technology and security improvements to support businesses adopting cryptocurrency payments globally. The company sees the certification as another step toward delivering dependable and future-ready digital payment infrastructure for enterprise and institutional clients.

Hacken, the auditing company behind the assessment, is recognized within the blockchain cybersecurity sector and employs multiple specialists holding active CCSS Auditor certifications. Industry experts note that the increasing adoption of infrastructure audits and security certifications demonstrates how the crypto sector is gradually moving toward operational standards similar to those expected in traditional financial services.

As institutional adoption of digital assets continues expanding worldwide, independently verified security frameworks are likely to become even more influential in shaping the future of crypto payment infrastructure.

Daily writing prompt

What’s a thing you were completely obsessed with as a kid?

View all responses

The Strategic Effect of Entrepreneurial Education on Nigerian Economic Development

Citation

CHUKWUKA, E. J., & MOEMEKE, C. D. (2026). The Strategic Effect of Entrepreneurial Education on Nigerian Economic Development. International Journal for Social Studies, 12(2), 48–59. https://doi.org/10.26643/ijss/9

Ernest Jebolise CHUKWUKA (PhD)

Department of Entrepreneurship and Business Innovation

Faculty of Management Sciences

University of Delta, Agbor

ernest.chukwuka@unidel.edu.ng

Clara Dumebi MOEMEKE (Ph.D)

Department of Science Education

Faculty of Education,

University of Delta, Agbor

Orcid no: 0000 0003- 1848-0623

Abstract

This explorative study examined the effect of Entrepreneurial Education on Nigerian Economic Development. The main objective is to ascertain the exact nature of connection between entrepreneurial education and Nigeria’s economic growth. The study adopted systematic review methodology called thematic. Papers were selected from multiple databases thematically. Content analysis was used to examine the gathered data. Condensing lengthy textual information into fewer categories in accordance with clear coding standards is accomplished through the methodical and repeatable process of content analysis. The results demonstrated a substantial relationship or correlation between entrepreneurial education and Nigeria’s economic development. This implies that entrepreneurship education in Nigerian colleges has sparked a desire to capitalize on numerous business chances for Nigeria’s economic development. According to the findings, well-taught entrepreneurship courses that equip students with entrepreneurial knowledge and skills would encourage them to launch their own companies and contribute to Nigeria’s economic expansion. Determining the elements that affect economic development is one of the primary objectives of contemporary economics. The impact of entrepreneurship on a nation’s economy is enormous. This is known to economists and decision-makers. In actuality, entrepreneurship is now viewed as a catalyst for the growth and advancement of productive endeavors in all spheres of global economic life. The study concludes that there is a stronger correlation between economic growth and entrepreneurial education than with foreign assistance which contends that entrepreneurial education is essential for unlocking economic growth, generating employment, and lowering poverty, among other things, in developing countries like Nigeria. The study recommends, among other things, that entrepreneurship skills centers be set up in both rural and urban areas so that business owners can acquire new skills that will make them more productive and increase their contribution to economic development and growth.

Key Words: Entrepreneurship Education, Nigeria’s Economic Development, Entrepreneurship, Strategy, Development, Educators

Introduction

Entrepreneurship education seeks to provide learners with the knowledge, skills and motivation to encourage entrepreneurial success in a variety of settings. Variations of entrepreneurship education are offered at all levels of schooling from primary or secondary schools through graduate university programmes. It is focused on realization of opportunities where management education is focused on the best way to operate existing hierarchies (Chukwuka & Nwaka 2026). Entrepreneurship Education focuses on developing understanding and capacity for pursuit, of entrepreneurial behaviours, skills and attributes in widely different contexts. It can be presented as being accessible to everyone and not just the province of ambitious, high-achieving businesspeople.

The inclination to act in an entrepreneurial manner is not unique to any one person. A person’s capacity to exhibit and develop entrepreneurial behaviors, abilities, and traits will vary. All students should be exposed to entrepreneurship education because these behaviors may be learnt, developed, and practiced (Asia-Pacific Economic Cooperation Forum, 2010). Beyond their use in commercial endeavors, entrepreneurial abilities and mindsets serve society. The development of new and efficient Small and Medium-Sized Enterprises (SMEs) should be viewed as crucial to the creation of a healthy African economy since the business sector is the dynamic mechanism underpinning every successful economy.

There seems to be no nation in the world that is not directly or indirectly impacted by the problems associated with youth unemployment, making it an epidemic that is quickly turning into a worldwide disaster. In 2020, the worldwide youth unemployment rate was 15.28% due to the fact that over 621 million people between the ages of 15 and 24 do not have gainful job (International Labour Organization (ILO) 2022). The situation is worse in Nigeria, where 21.72 million young people between the ages of 15 and 35 are unemployed. By the end of 2022, the country’s youth unemployment rate is expected to reach 53% (National Bureau of Statistics 2021). Nigeria’s rapidly growing population, which is expected to reach over 840 million by 2050 (United Nations Development Programme (UNDP), 2017) and is primarily made up of young people, is supposed to be the country’s greatest asset in terms of providing labor for industrialization. Sadly, this growing youth population has created a significant social burden for the government, the world, and even the young people themselves. If immediate action is not taken, the current situation has shown that this exponential expansion is more of a time bomb than an opportunity. Like other emerging nations, Nigeria faces a growing unemployment rate that has led to a number of social issues, including internet fraud, banditry, terrorism, kidnapping, and ritual killings.

Raising young employment has been attributed to the nation’s inadequate educational system. Education stakeholders have long bemoaned the regrettable tendency of postsecondary schools producing graduates who wander the streets every day looking for employment that don’t exist (Gabadeen & Raimi 2016). The Federal Ministry of Education (FME) incorporated entrepreneurship education into the curricula of universities, polytechnics, and colleges of education through their regulatory agencies, the National Universities Commission (NUC), National Board for Technical Education (NBTE), and National Commission for Colleges of Education (NCCE), in an effort to address this issue by turning graduates of Nigerian higher education into job creators rather than lifelong job seekers. With effect from the 2007–2008 academic year, entrepreneurship education was formally added to the curricula of higher education institutions (ILO, 2010).

The degree of development of a country’s human resources, as well as in the areas of social integration, psychological stability, functional education, and political stability, are used to determine its wealth. Any country that reaches this level of development will undoubtedly eradicate poverty, unemployment, and corruption and advance industrialization, peace, security, human and capital development, a sufficient supply of food, and fair wealth distribution among its people. This supports the ideas expressed by Scottish economist and moral philosopher Adam Smith in his book An Inquiry into the Nature and Causes of the Wealth of Nations, which is commonly known by its abbreviated title The Wealth of Nations.

Incorporating entrepreneurship education into Nigerian university curricula was intended to equip students with the skills necessary to succeed in the workforce and contribute to society once they graduated (Davwet, Damar, Goyit, & Kajang, 2019). This goal is reflected in Nigerian institutions’ strategic plans, which provide undergraduates with the chance to become entrepreneurs and lifelong learners. Entrepreneurship education was created to give undergraduates from a range of fields the entrepreneurial skills they would need to own requirements of life, be human, and be free from societal servanthood (Edokpolor, 2020). Undergraduates’ ability to obtain independence and the requirements of life is described in the literature on sustainability and economic development (Mensah, 2019).

Statement of Problem and the Justification of the Study

In Nigeria, entrepreneurial education has been extensively advocated as an essential strategy for addressing enduring issues like high young unemployment, sluggish industrial growth, poor levels of innovation, and an excessive reliance on crude oil earnings. Nigerian universities, polytechnics, and other postsecondary institutions have responded by establishing entrepreneurship centers and courses, frequently making them mandatory for students in all subject areas. However, despite these efforts, the nation still has a sizable unproductive informal sector and high rates of underemployment and unemployment, particularly among graduates.

This circumstance calls into question the true strategic impact of entrepreneurship education on Nigeria’s economic growth. In particular, there is no empirical knowledge about whether the way entrepreneurial education is currently designed, taught, and delivered in Nigeria truly results in quantifiable outcomes like the development of businesses, the creation of jobs, the capacity for innovation, and GDP contribution. Few studies examine how entrepreneurial education affects more general development indicators like employment structure, economic diversification, and poverty reduction; most concentrate on students’ attitudes or intentions. Because of this gap, it is challenging for educators and policymakers to assess whether current entrepreneurship programs are useful as tools for development or require substantial revision.

Additionally, there seems to be a mismatch between the skills taught in many Nigerian entrepreneurship programs and the real-world demands of the business environment, such as technology change, infrastructure deficiencies, regulatory restrictions, and financial access. As a result, graduates could learn about entrepreneurship theoretically without the skills, networks, or ecosystems needed to build long-term businesses that can spur economic growth. This discrepancy implies that entrepreneurship education’s strategic potential as a catalyst for national development is not being fully realized. The lack of data on how and to what degree entrepreneurial education, as it is currently organized and applied in Nigeria, strategically influences important aspects of economic development like job creation, innovation, enterprise expansion, and structural economic transformation is the issue this study attempts to solve. Without this proof, entrepreneurship education may continue to be funded and expanded without clear evidence of its developmental benefit or recommendations for enhancing its efficacy.

The urgent need for evidence-based solutions to Nigeria’s high youth unemployment, which has been recognized as a significant socioeconomic issue and a cause of instability and insecurity, justifies this study. The idea that entrepreneurial education might provide young people the mindset and abilities to make their own jobs instead of relying just on wage employment is frequently put forth. Determining if this widely held belief is true in the Nigerian context will require assessing its strategic impact on economic development (Bessant& Tidd 2011).

Policymakers and educational planners who devote significant funds to entrepreneurial initiatives at the federal, state, and institutional levels should also take note of the study. The research can direct changes in curriculum design, teaching strategies, and support systems like incubation, mentorship, and financial access if it makes clear how entrepreneurial education helps (or doesn’t help) employment, innovation, and economic diversity. This will make it possible to allocate scarce public and private funds to entrepreneurial education programs that have clear developmental benefits.

The report provides a foundation for universities and other educational institutions to match entrepreneurial education with national economic priorities, like boosting MSMEs, encouraging a knowledge-based economy, and advancing non-oil sectors. The study can help enhance course content, experiential learning, industry relationships, and evaluation techniques by determining which elements of entrepreneurial education are most closely associated with economic outcomes (Chukwuka et al 2026b). This will increase the relevance and efficacy of programs. Lastly, by examining entrepreneurship education’s wider strategic impact on economic development indicators in a developing-country setting, the study adds to the body of scholarly literature by going beyond attitudinal and intention-based studies. A targeted study helps close a conceptual and empirical gap and offers a model for comparable investigations in other African economies because current research on Nigeria is still developing and frequently dispersed.

This study main objective is to ascertain the exact effect of Entrepreneurial Education on Nigerian Economic Development.

Literature Review

The Concept of Entrepreneurship Education

Several authors have attempted to conceptualize entrepreneurship education. For example, entrepreneurship education is defined by Okifo and Ayo (2010) as the kind of education intended to alter the recipient’s orientation and attitude while acquiring the skills and information necessary to establish and run a business organization. Osuala (2010) defined entrepreneurship education as a program or component of a program that equips people to start and run small businesses, including franchise operations, for the purpose of carrying out all business functions related to a product or service with an emphasis on social responsibilities, legal requirements, and risks for the sake of profit involved in the conduct of private business enterprises. The primary goal of entrepreneurship education, according to Suleiman (2010), is to prepare young people to be responsible, enterprising individuals who become entrepreneurs or entrepreneurial thinkers by providing them with real-world learning experiences that allow them to take risks, manage results, and learn from the outcome.

The process of teaching people to identify and cultivate essential entrepreneurial traits, abilities, and behaviors is known as entrepreneurship education. Since these abilities are necessary in the workplace, everyday activities, household management, and society at large, entrepreneurial skills like creativity, innovation, quick decision-making, and risk-taking are applicable to everyone, not just those who want to launch and expand their own business. As the saying goes, learning never ends, and entrepreneurship education should never end either (Chukwuka et al 2026). Successful business owners never stop learning during the course of their venture or business. Adesulu (2010) asserts that in order for Nigeria to achieve its Vision 20:2020 objectives, the nation must not just teach entrepreneurship in schools but also be ready to put it into practice. Another meaning of entrepreneurship education is someone who develops original concepts and transforms them into successful enterprises. Adesulu continues, “The act of combining creative and inventive ideas with organizational management abilities in order to combine people, money, and resources to solve a recognized need and create profit” is the definition of entrepreneurship. According to

Egunjimi (2012), the goals of entrepreneurship education are as follows: To provide adolescents with practical knowledge that will help them become independent and self-employed. Give the young graduates enough training so they can find new business prospects with creativity and innovation, to act as an accelerator of development and economic growth. Provide graduates of postsecondary institutions with sufficient risk management skills to ensure that certain bearings are viable. Migration from rural to urban areas has decreased. To lower the high poverty rate. Make jobs. Give the recent graduates adequate training and assistance so they can start a career in small and medium-sized businesses. To instill in young people and adults the spirit of perseverance that will allow them to persevere in any business endeavor they take on. Make the shift from a traditional to a modern industrial economy seamless.

Economic development is a primary concern for any competent government. It is a key campaign commitment during electioneering campaigns and has a prominent place in its growth strategy. Since education is widely seen as the cornerstone of progress, many governments in developing countries have focused on it as a way to achieve national development. A nation with educated citizens is more likely to see national progress than one with uneducated citizens. This is based on the idea that educated citizens are not only creative and productive but also socially and culturally tolerant people who apply moral and ethical principles in their daily lives with an entrepreneurial spirit that helps to create jobs and lessen poverty among the hordes of young people. Because of their beliefs and leadership abilities, they support political, economic, and technical advancement. Since man’s divine creation, education has been used largely as a reformative process in the sustainable development of a dynamic society for shared wealth and citizen harmony (Awofala & Sopekan, 2013; Oyekan, 2015).

The relationship between economic development and entrepreneurship

The following are some ways that entrepreneurship aids in economic development:
1) Balanced regional development: The growth of commerce and industry benefits the public in many ways, such as transportation, health, education, and entertainment. Development is limited to the cities where industry are concentrated. Due to greater rivalry in and around cities, there is a rapid development when new entrepreneurs thrive at a faster rate and are motivated to start their firms in smaller towns far from large cities. This aids in the advancement of underdeveloped regions.

2) Dispersal of economic power: As a result of industrial growth, economic power is typically concentrated in a small number of hands. One effect of this concentration of power in a small number of hands is monopolies. The growth of numerous entrepreneurs contributes to the population’s distribution of economic power. Consequently, it helps lessen monopoly’s detrimental effects.

3) Creating jobs: The country is worried about rising unemployment, especially among educated people. There are hardly 5% to 10% of unemployed people who can find work. There are two ways that entrepreneurs generate employment: directly and indirectly. Through their self-employment as entrepreneurs and the creation of many manufacturing facilities, they directly and indirectly create work for millions of others.

Therefore, the best way to fight unemployment is through entrepreneurship.
4) Innovation: An entrepreneur is a person who is always searching for new chances. He not only mixes the factors of production but also introduces new ideas and combinations of factors. He is always trying to implement more advanced techniques for producing goods and services. An entrepreneur advances economic growth through invention.

5) National income: National revenue is derived from both domestic and foreign goods and services. Both domestic consumption and export demand are the goals of the produced goods and services. As the population grows and living standards rise, so does domestic demand.

Export demand increases to meet the demands of growing imports for a number of reasons. An increasing number of entrepreneurs are required to meet the growing demand for goods and services. Consequently, entrepreneurship increases the country’s income.
6) Higher living standards: Increasing economic growth rates requires entrepreneurs. Depending on their demands, entrepreneurs can produce goods at a lower cost and provide the community with high-quality commodities at a lower cost. Customers can buy more items to meet their needs as commodity prices decline. In this way, they will be able to improve the standard of living for the populace.

Ogundele and Egunjimi (2017) list the following additional advantages of entrepreneurial education for the Nigerian economy:

a) Employment opportunities: There are more job openings as a result of entrepreneurial activity. Businesses need people to work for them. Additionally, entrepreneurship reduces the number of job seekers on the streets searching for open opportunities. Unemployment and idleness are other contributing factors to the high incidence of crime and violence among young people and on the streets.
b) Efficient use of natural resources: Entrepreneurship creates value for the economy and the entrepreneur by transferring resources from less productive to more productive areas. Nigeria’s vast natural and human resources are effectively used.

c) Equitable distribution of income and wealth: More entrepreneurial activity in rural areas generates more money, which spreads the economic prosperity of both communities and individuals. The rate of rural-urban migration will decrease as a result of more villages having more employment possibilities. In rural places, entrepreneurship creates new jobs, boosts local incomes, and enhances the standard of living. These kinds of entrepreneurial endeavors successfully link rural villages with larger urban areas. A nation’s increasing productivity and capital accumulation are further benefits of entrepreneurship education. In conclusion, the expansion of entrepreneurship is essential to the nation’s economic development. The role of entrepreneurship development can be summed up as follows: entrepreneurship is a cause of economic development, and economic development is a product of entrepreneurship (Kressel & Lento 2012).

According to Ogundele and Ogunjimi (2017), entrepreneurship has been a potent engine of economic growth and wealth creation for many developing nations, and it is essential for enhancing the quantity, diversity, and quality of employment prospects for the impoverished. Compared to other natural resources, which can run out, it is a better source of competitive advantage since it has several multiplier effects on the economy, encourages innovation, and encourages investment in people. Entrepreneurs launch new companies, economic sectors, and commercial endeavors.

They provide goods and services for society, develop new technologies, enhance or reduce the cost of outputs, generate jobs for others, and generate foreign exchange by increasing exports or replacing imports. With over 10% of the population living on less than $2 (two dollars) per day and 54% surviving on less than $1 per day, entrepreneurial activities have the potential to bring Nigeria out of poverty provided they are effectively carried out and supported by active government policies and infrastructures. Even while graduates who choose to pursue professional professions can find white-collar work, developing entrepreneurial abilities is also more practical. This is a way to generate more revenue for self-sufficiency (Adesulu, 2010).

Economic Development

In general, economic development refers to the persistent, coordinated efforts of communities and governments that raise the standard of living and economic well-being of a particular region. The quantitative and qualitative shifts in the economy are another name for economic progress. Human capital development, vital infrastructure, regional competitiveness, environmental sustainability, social inclusion, health, safety, literacy, and other activities are just a few of the topics that these measures may cover. Economic growth is not the same as economic development. Economic growth is a result of increased GDP and market productivity, whereas economic development is a governmental intervention effort aimed at improving people’s economic and social well-being (Abefe-Balogun & Nwankpa 2012).

As a result, “economic growth is one aspect of the process of economic development,” as noted by Amartya (1983). The method and policies that a country uses to enhance the social, political, and economic well-being of its citizens are included in the scope of economic development. According to Mansell and When (1998), economic growth—that is, improvements in per capita income—and the achievement of a quality of living comparable to that of industrialized nations have been considered components of economic development since the Second World War. Another way to think of economic development is as a static theory that describes the condition of an economy at a particular point in time (Awofala & Sopekan 2013).

Development and economic growth are two different concepts. It involves more than simply the economy growing (in terms of increased output). It entails increasing real per capita income and significantly improving every area of the economy (Dungrit, Bahago, & Gotip, 2022). Actually, there are numerous facets of economic development that cooperate with each other. It has to do with how far human potential has advanced, how well a nation’s citizens live, how robust and resilient its institutions are, and how effectively society is functioning overall.

Methodology

The literature review methodology used is thematic. Papers were selected from multiple databases thematically. The recentness and relevant theme were used to arrange the papers. On the other hand, similar but older studies were refuted just like the unrelated ones. As a result, the remaining recent articles that are relevant to the topic of this work were examined closely, and any flaws or deficiencies were noted. Recommendations for the examined papers were appropriate.

Content analysis was used to examine the gathered data. Condensing lengthy textual information into fewer categories in accordance with clear coding standards is accomplished through the methodical and repeatable process of content analysis. It entails looking for recurrent themes, patterns, and trends in written, visual, or auditory content (Krippendorff, 2019). Content analysis makes it possible to transform qualitative historical data into a structured framework for comparative study and interpretation in historical research.

Results and Discussion

The relationship between entrepreneurial education and Nigeria’s economic development was investigated in this study. The findings showed a strong correlation or connection between Nigeria’s economic development and entrepreneurial education. According to Okuneye, Idowu, and Dansu (2009), this suggests that entrepreneurship education in Nigerian universities has sparked a desire to take advantage of various entrepreneurship prospects for Nigeria’s economic development. The results suggest that well-taught entrepreneurship courses that give students entrepreneurial knowledge and skills would inspire them to start their own businesses and support Nigeria’s economic growth.

The study confirmed that Due to their various economies, both established nations like the United States and growing nations like Nigeria offer greater opportunities for entrepreneurs and are currently the focus of both domestic and international firms. In emerging nations like Nigeria, there is a clear correlation between economic growth and entrepreneurship. Consequently, it might be an answer to Nigeria’s financial issues. It is well known that entrepreneurship fosters skill development, creative thinking, product development, marketing, leadership development, and wealth creation. This leads to the development of successful micro, small, and medium-sized businesses (MSMEs) that produce profitable jobs, generate wealth, give women opportunities, diversify the economy, and ultimately expand it. The future of the Nigerian economy is primarily dependent on a new generation of entrepreneurs who must have the vision to create wealth and jobs in addition to coming up with innovative ideas and being committed to seeing them through to completion. Nigerian culture must change in order to achieve this. In the Nigerian economy, entrepreneurship education is necessary to build wealth and raise the standard of life while also reducing unemployment, crime, government spending, poverty, and social unrest.

Conclusion

This study examined the connection between entrepreneurial education and Nigeria’s economic growth. The results demonstrated a substantial relationship or correlation between entrepreneurial education and Nigeria’s economic development. This implies that entrepreneurship education in Nigerian colleges has sparked a desire to capitalize on numerous business chances for Nigeria’s economic development. According to the findings, well-taught entrepreneurship courses that equip students with entrepreneurial knowledge and skills would encourage them to launch their own companies and contribute to Nigeria’s economic expansion.

Determining the elements that affect economic development is one of the primary objectives of contemporary economics. The impact of entrepreneurship on a nation’s economy is enormous. This is known to economists and decision-makers. In actuality, entrepreneurship is now viewed as a catalyst for the growth and advancement of productive endeavors in all spheres of global economic life. The study concludes that there is a stronger correlation between economic growth and entrepreneurial education than with foreign assistance which contends that entrepreneurial education is essential for unlocking economic growth, generating employment, and lowering poverty, among other things, in developing countries like Nigeria.

Recommendation

The recommendations that follow are offered in order for entrepreneurship education at Nigerian institutions to be a tool for economic growth:
1. Regular training in entrepreneurial education should be provided to all instructors and lecturers. Lecturers should be hired, trained, and re-trained in this area. To increase their knowledge and successfully teach students entrepreneurial abilities, they should be financially supported to attend regional and global conferences.
2. Graduating students who choose to start their own business should have access to enough resources, including funding.

3. The various university administrations might get in touch with banks or non-governmental organizations (NGOs) to offer grants or low-interest loans to entrepreneurship instructors so they can launch and manage their own companies. Through their own efforts, they will be able to obtain real-world experience that they may then impart to the pupils.
4. The provision of suitable educational resources, local infrastructure, and support services to guarantee their applicability to the Nigerian context.
5. In order to promote entrepreneurship and boost efficiency, the federal, state, and local governments should supply the necessary social amenities, such as electricity, roads, and other infrastructure.
6. Particularly in the more remote areas, governments ought to implement policies that would assist in enhancing the physical infrastructure, such as power, broadband internet, and transportation.

7. To help entrepreneurs acquire new skills that will make them more productive and contribute more to economic growth and development, entrepreneurship skills centers should be set up in both rural and urban areas.
8. Governments ought to grant subsidies and tax breaks to businesses that provide excellent employee value propositions to potential professionals, such as specialized training or stock option programs.
9. To support the nation’s expansion and development, workshops, seminars, symposia, and lectures ought to be arranged.

References

Abefe-Balogun, B. & Nwankpa, N. N. (2012). Tackling unemployment through vocational education. Science Education Development Institute, 2(3), 103-110.

Abude, P., Chukwuka, E.J., Andrew, U.A., Efurueze, P.C., Kanene, K.C. (2025). Financial Risk and Firm Value in Nigeria: The Moderating Role of Ownership Structure. International Research Journal of Multidisciplinary Scope. 6(4):1471-1482. doi: https://10.47857/irjms.2025.v6i04.06697

Adesulu, D. (2010). Who cares for public schools in Nigeria? Retrieved on 16th August 2020 from http://www.vanguardngr.com/2010/09/who-cares-about-public-schools-in-Nigeria

Awofala, A. O. A. & Sopekan, O. S. (2013). Recent curriculum reforms in primary and secondary schools in Nigeria in the new Millennium. Journal of Education and Practice, 4(5), 98-107.

Bessant, J. & Tidd, J. (2011). Innovation and entrepreneurship. Chichester: John Wiley &Sons.

Chukwuka, E. J., & Amahi, F. U. (2026). Assessing the Modern Employee Management Strategies for Optimum Organizational Productivity in Nigeria. Journal for Studies in Management and Planning, 12(2), 1–27. https://doi.org/10.26643/jsmap/7

Chukwuka, E.J., & Igweh, K. F., I., & Nwaka, R.N. (2026). Assessing the contribution of small and medium-scale enterprises to economic development in Nigeria. International Journal of Development and Management Review, 21(1), 191–216. Retrieved from https://www.ajol.info/index.php/ijdmr/article/view/321832

Chukwuka, E.J & Nwaka, R.N. (2026). The Nexus of Creative Destruction in Entrepreneurship and Nigeria’s Economic Development. Jalingo Journal of Social and Management Sciences, 7(1), 245-264.

Chukwuka, E.J, Nwaka, R.N., Idoye C., Azimi, S. A (2026). Effective Internal Control System as a Measure against Business Failures in Asaba, Delta State, Nigeria. International Journal of Advanced Research in Multidisciplinary Studies (Ijarms), 5(2), 569-580.

Chukwuka EJ, Moemeke CD, Onyemaechi U, Nneka NR, Ejaita OA, Chukwuka GE and Nkechi AT, 2026. The impact of modern technological innovations on food security in Nigeria: A cutting-edge technology from an agropreneurship perspective. Agrobiological Records 23: 158-172. https://doi.org/10.47278/journal.abr/2026.014

Chukwuka EJ, Peter A, Efurueze PC, Okolobi AN, Christian I. (2026). The Strategic Role of Financial Record keeping in the Development of Small and Medium Scale Enterprises in Nigeria. International Research Journal of Multidisciplinary Scope. 7(1):287-306. DOI: https://10.47857/irjms.2026.v07i01.06698

Dau, I. A., & Cuervo-Cazurra, A. (2014). To formalize or not to formalize: Entrepreneurship and market institutions. Journal of Business Venture, 29, 668-686.

Egunjimi, F. H. (2012). Entrepreneurship education: A tool for national economy in Nigeria. A seminar paper presented at University of Ilorin, Nigeria on 16th April.

Ememe, O. N. (2011). Entrepreneurship education in the university in the Eastern Nigeria: Implications for higher education administration. Unpublished PhD Dissertation, University of Port-Harcourt.

Kressel, H. & Lento, T. V. (2012). Entrepreneurship in the global economy: Engine for economic growth. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.

Moemeka, C.D., Chukwuka, E.J. (2026). Effective Science Education for Technological Transformation and Entrepreneurial Digitization of Nigeria. International Journal of Multidisciplinary and Innovative Research 3(3), 168-179. https://doi.org/10.58806/ijmir.2026.v3i3n03

Naudé, W. (2011). Entrepreneurship and economic development. New York: Palgrave Macmillan.

Nkechi A., Emeh, I. E. J, & Okechukwu U. F. (2012). Entrepreneurship development and employment generation in Nigeria: Problems and prospect. Universal Journal of Education and General Studies, 1(4), 88-102.

Nwachukwu, A. C. (2012). The role of entrepreneurship in economic development: The Nigerian perspective. European Journal of Business and Management, 8(4), 95-105.

Ogundele, M. O. & Egunjimi, F. H. (2017). Entrepreneurship education: An instrument for sustainable economic development in Nigeria. The Online Journal of Quality in Higher Education, 4(2), 32-36.

Okoduwa, A . C., Chukwuka, E.J. , Ugbah, A. A., Ifurueze, C. P & Agbele, G. (2026). Impact of Crowdfunding as an Innovative Entrepreneurial Finance on Nigerian Small and Medium-Sized Businesses’ Funding Gaps. International Journal of Multidisciplinary and Innovative Research, 3(2), 100-110. https://doi.org/10.58806/ijmir.2026.v3i2n01

GOlawolu, O. E. & Kaegon, L. E. S. (2012). Entrepreneurship education as tool for youth empowerment through higher education for global workplace in Rivers. A paper presented at the Seventh Regional Conference on Higher Education for a Globalized World, organized by the Higher Education Research and Policy Network (HERPNET) held at the University of Ibadan, between the 19th to 21st September.

Oyekan, S. O. (2015). Diagnosis and remediation of challenges of education for quality human life in Nigeria. African Journal of Historical Sciences in Education, 11(1), 261-284.

Oyekan, S. O. (2016). Sustaining a diversified economy and combatting security challenges through science and technology education. Science & Technology, 2(6), 201-220.

Schumpeter, J. A. (1934). The theory of economic development. Cambridge: Harvard University Press.

Thaddeus, E. (2012). Perspectives: Entrepreneurship development & growth of enterprises in Nigeria. Entrepreneurial Practice Review, 2(2), 31-35.

Daily writing prompt

How can you build a regular fitness routine?

View all responses

Development of an Arduino-Based Smart Security System Integrating User Type, Authentication Method, and Access Status for Enhanced Access Control

Citation

Lariosa, Z., & Junio, O. (2026). Development of an Arduino-Based Smart Security System Integrating User Type, Authentication Method, and Access Status for Enhanced Access Control. International Journal of Research, 13(4), 189–196. https://doi.org/10.26643/ijr/edupub/19

Zandrex Lariosa, Oliver Junio

c1-241-02102@uphsl.edu.ph, omj@uphsl.edu.ph

University of Perpetual Help System Laguna

Abstract

The increasing trend of hacking attacks and security violations in addition to inefficiencies in access control mechanisms is one reason that calls for the implementation of an intelligent security mechanism. The purpose of this research is to design and implement the Arduino-based intelligent access control security system, which considers user type, authentication method sequence, and access status to strengthen multi-level access controls. With regards to the DiD security layer concept, the ABAC principle, and the IPO framework, the system features RFID and fingerprint-based sequential authentication to enhance the security process.

The designed system entails the use of RFID and fingerprint technology, attendance logging in real-time, intrusion detection, sending of alerts through email and SMS messages, remote monitoring via the Internet, and analysis of access pattern based on time and frequency of access. For this study, the descriptive developmental method of research was utilized, along with a waterfall software development process. The evaluation of the software was conducted among small business owners and IT personnel residing in the City of Trece Martires, Cavite, using the ISO/IEC 25010 software quality framework.

The results revealed that the proposed system is highly acceptable and efficient as a cost-effective smart security system. The inclusion of multi-factor authentication, real-time monitoring, and intelligent access control analysis improved the reliability of the security and access control system process. This study has contributed to the existing literature on Arduino and IoT security systems in that it demonstrated the practicality of implementing multi-factor authentication, role management, and intelligent monitoring into small business settings.

Introduction

The rapid advancement of technology has led to a corresponding increase in security threats, particularly in small businesses where resources for advanced protection are limited. Traditional access control systems, which often rely on single authentication methods, are becoming inadequate in addressing modern challenges such as unauthorized access, theft, and data breaches. These systems lack flexibility, real-time monitoring, and adaptive capabilities, making them vulnerable to exploitation. While previous studies have explored the use of RFID, biometrics, and monitoring technologies, many remain limited to isolated implementations without integrating multiple security layers or intelligent analysis.

To address these limitations, this study proposes the development of an Arduino-based smart security system that integrates multi-layered authentication mechanisms. The system utilizes a sequential process where RFID verification is followed by fingerprint authentication, ensuring enhanced identity validation before granting access. It also incorporates role-based access control for different user types and provides real-time monitoring of system activities, including detection of unauthorized access and intrusion attempts. This structured approach strengthens security by combining multiple authentication methods and improving overall access control efficiency.

In addition, the system introduces an intelligent access behavior analysis component that evaluates user activity based on time patterns and frequency of access attempts. This enables the detection of unusual or suspicious behavior, contributing to proactive security management. Designed as a cost-effective and open-source solution, the system is suitable for small businesses, offices, and similar environments. Overall, the study contributes to the development of a scalable and efficient smart security system that integrates multi-factor authentication, user management, and intelligent monitoring to address the limitations of existing access control technologies.

METHODOLOGY

This study employed a descriptive-developmental research design combined with the Waterfall software development model to design, develop, and evaluate an Arduino-based smart security system. The approach enabled the researchers to first assess existing security practices among small businesses, identify system requirements, and subsequently develop a solution that addresses identified gaps. The methodology followed a structured process consisting of needs assessment, system development, and evaluation, ensuring that the resulting system is both technically sound and aligned with user needs.

The system development process followed the Waterfall model, which consists of sequential phases: analysis, design, implementation, testing, and maintenance. During the analysis phase, system requirements and security challenges were identified. The design phase involved planning the hardware and software architecture, including the integration of RFID, fingerprint sensors, and web-based monitoring. Implementation focused on coding and assembling the hardware components, while testing ensured system accuracy, reliability, and performance. The Waterfall diagram is included in this study to illustrate the step-by-step development process followed.

The architecture of the system integrates both hardware and software components to support a multi-layered security mechanism. The system utilizes RFID and fingerprint authentication, a microcontroller (Arduino/ESP32), a web-based platform, and notification systems for real-time alerts. It enables role-based access control for administrators and staff, attendance monitoring, and intrusion detection based on unauthorized access attempts or irregular usage patterns. The design ensures secure, efficient, and reliable access control supported by real-time monitoring capabilities.

Data for system evaluation were collected from 100 purposively selected respondents, including business owners, staff, and IT professionals from Trece Martires City, Cavite. A structured questionnaire based on the ISO/IEC 25010 software quality model was used to assess system performance across nine criteria, including functionality, efficiency, security, and reliability. Data gathering procedures included surveys, usability testing, and interviews, while analysis was conducted using weighted mean and Likert scale interpretation. Ethical standards such as informed consent, confidentiality, and voluntary participation were strictly observed throughout the study.

Results and Discussion

The results of the study revealed that most small businesses still rely on traditional security mechanisms such as manual locks and basic surveillance systems, which are often not actively monitored and lack real-time alert capabilities. These systems are vulnerable to unauthorized access and fail to provide immediate response during security breaches. The findings highlight the need for a more advanced and integrated security solution that addresses these limitations through automation and multi-layered protection.

Based on the identified needs, the proposed Arduino-based smart security system was designed to incorporate key features such as multi-factor authentication using RFID and fingerprint scanning, real-time monitoring, attendance tracking, and remote access via a web-based platform. The system also includes alert mechanisms that notify administrators through SMS and email in cases of unauthorized access. These features directly respond to the operational requirements of small business owners and staff, improving both security and administrative efficiency.

The evaluation results showed that the system achieved “Excellent” ratings across all software quality attributes based on the ISO/IEC 25010 framework. IT experts, business owners, and staff consistently rated the system highly in terms of functional suitability, performance efficiency, compatibility, interaction capability, reliability, security, maintainability, flexibility, and safety. Among these, security received the highest ratings, indicating strong confidence in the system’s ability to protect against unauthorized access. Slightly lower but still excellent ratings in interaction capability suggest opportunities for further improving user interface design.

Overall, the findings demonstrate that the developed system is highly acceptable, reliable, and effective for small business environments. The integration of multi-layered authentication, real-time monitoring, and intelligent alert mechanisms significantly enhances security operations compared to traditional systems. The results also confirm that the system is practical, user-friendly, and adaptable, making it a viable solution for improving access control and security management in small-scale enterprises.

Criteria	IT Experts	Employers	Staff	Overall Mean	Interpretation
Functional Suitability	4.83	4.53	—	4.68	Excellent
Performance Efficiency	4.80	4.33	—	4.57	Excellent
Interaction Capability	4.73	4.30	—	4.52	Excellent
Compatibility	4.85	4.55	—	4.70	Excellent
Reliability	4.80	—	4.46	4.63	Excellent
Security	4.92	4.64	—	4.78	Excellent
Maintainability	4.84	—	4.56	4.70	Excellent
Flexibility	4.70	—	4.59	4.65	Excellent
Safety	4.80	—	—	4.80	Excellent

The statistical results indicate that the developed Arduino-based smart security system achieved consistently high ratings across all nine ISO/IEC 25010 software quality characteristics, with all computed means falling within the “Excellent” range (4.20–5.00). The overall grand mean of 4.67 confirms a very high level of acceptability and performance among all respondent groups, including IT experts, employers, and staff.

Among the evaluated criteria, Security (4.78) obtained the highest overall mean, reflecting strong confidence in the system’s ability to prevent unauthorized access and ensure data protection. This is followed by Compatibility and Maintainability (4.70), indicating that the system is adaptable across different environments and easy to manage. These findings suggest that the integration of multi-layered authentication and real-time monitoring significantly enhanced system robustness.

On the other hand, Interaction Capability (4.52) received the lowest mean, although it still falls under the “Excellent” category. This implies that while users find the system highly functional and reliable, there is still room for improvement in terms of user interface design and ease of interaction, particularly for non-technical users.

Overall, the statistical findings validate that the system is highly reliable, efficient, secure, and user-acceptable, making it a viable solution for improving access control and security management in small business environments.

Conclusion

This study concludes that Chinese technology enterprises demonstrate a high level of effectiveness in contract management practices, supported by well-established governance frameworks and positive contractor relationships; however, these practices do not directly translate into enhanced contractor performance. While effective contract management significantly improves relationship quality, contractor performance appears to be influenced by additional factors such as innovation capability, technological competence, and performance-based incentives. This indicates that contract management, while essential, must be strategically integrated with performance monitoring mechanisms and outcome-driven evaluation systems to generate measurable improvements. Therefore, to maximize contractor performance, technology enterprises must move beyond compliance to adopt performance-oriented contracting models that promote accountability, innovation, and continuous improvement.

Recommendations

Based on the findings of the study, several recommendations are proposed to further enhance the functionality, security, and usability of the developed system. First, the development of a mobile application is recommended to allow remote monitoring of access logs, user management, and real-time alert notifications. This will significantly improve user interaction, accessibility, and convenience, especially for administrators who need to manage the system off-site. In addition, the implementation of data encryption and secure communication protocols is strongly suggested to strengthen data protection, ensuring that sensitive information is safeguarded against potential data breaches and unauthorized access.

Furthermore, the inclusion of a device expansion module is recommended to improve system scalability. This feature may integrate an access point (AP) hotspot capability, enabling users to easily connect to Wi-Fi and manage multiple devices across different business branches efficiently. Another important enhancement is the incorporation of an emergency key mechanism, which can be used to grant access during unexpected situations such as power outages or internet interruptions, ensuring continuous system functionality.

Finally, the system can be further upgraded by incorporating advanced multi-factor authentication mechanisms that combine RFID technology, fingerprint scanning, and AI-based access behavior analysis. This enhancement will provide an additional layer of security by not only verifying user identity but also assessing access patterns for potential anomalies. Overall, these recommendations aim to improve the system’s adaptability, security, and reliability, making it more robust and suitable for wider implementation in various business environments.

References:

Afreen H., Kashif M., Shaheen Q., Alfaifi Y. H., & Ayaz M. (2023). IoT-Based Smart Surveillance System for High-Security Areas. Applied Sciences, Volume 13 Issue 15, 8936. https://doi.org/10.3390/app13158936

Alaba, A. F., Othman, M., & Hahsem, I. A. T. (2017). Internet of things security: A survey. Journal of Network and Computer Applications 88. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jnca.2017.04.002

Ameer, S., Benson, J., & Sandhu, R. (2022). An Attribute-Based Approach toward a Secured Smart-Home IoT Access Control and a Comparison with a Role-Based Approach. Information 2022, 13(2), 60; https://doi.org/10.3390/info13020060

Atif Afroz (2022). Digital Smart Door Lock Security System Using Arduino Uno Microcontroller. Iconic Research and Engineering. JUL 2022, IRE Journals, Volume 6 Issue 1, ISSN: 2456-8880

Badmus E.O, Odekunle O.P, & Oyewobi D.O (2021). Smart Fingerprint Biometric and RFID Time-Based Attendance Management System. European Journal of Electrical Engineering and Computer Science. 5, 4 (Jul. 2021), 34–39. DOI: https://doi.org/10.24018/ejece.2021.5.4.339.

Bhanushali M., Bhanushali D., Chaugule A., & Bhelande M. (2020). Biometric Authentication System using Arduino. Journal of Advancement in Parallel Computing, 3(3), 1–5. https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.4335458.

Bounabi B., Mosbah C., Khiter O., & Soussi Y. (2024). Design and implementation of an intelligent building security system using Arduino GIGA R1 Wi-Fi. Vol. 5 No. 2 (2024): Studies in Engineering and Exact Sciences, Curitiba, v.5, n.2, 2024. https://doi.org/10.54021/seesv5n2-217

Irugalbandara, C., Naseem, A. S., Perera, S., Kiruthikan, S., & Logeeshan, V. (2023). A Secure And Smart Home Automation System With Speech Recognition And Power Measurement Capabilities. Sensors, 23(13), 5784.

Kassim, S.O, Idriss, A.S, Ahmed, A.I, (2023). Implementation of a Sustainable Security Architecture Using Radio Frequency Identification (RFID) Technology for Access Control. https://doi.org/10.48550/arXiv.2304.04628

Khabarlak K. & Koriashkina L. (2021). Mobile Access Control System Based on RFID Tags and Facial Information. In Bulletin of National Technical University “KhPI”. Series: System Analysis, Control and Information Technologies 2 (4) (2020): 69-74. https://doi.org/10.20998/2079-0023.2020.02.12

Kordov K. & Bilyal I. (2023). Access Control System Using Arduino Microcontroller and RFID Reader. Annual of Konstantin Preslavsky University of Shumen Faculty of mathematics and informatics XXIV C:9-15, https://doi.org/10.46687/QSFY7970

Lavanya Y., Rajitha Laksjmi M., Tarun V., Suma P., & Rakesh P. (2024). Design and Development of Biometric and Keypad Based Smart Door Security System for Residential Building. Vol. 10 No. 3: IJERAT May-2024. https://doi.org/10.31695/IJERAT.2024.3.2

Mohammed M. Sultan, Amer T. Saeed, & Ahmed M. Sana (2021). Design and implementation of an adaptive multilevel wireless security system using IoT. Vol.23, No.3 Institute of Advanced Engineering and Science (IAES). http://doi.org/10.11591/ijeecs.v23.i3.pp1804-1813

Mumtaz Z., Ilyas Z., Sohaib A., Ullah S., & Madni H.A. (2020). Design and Implementation of User-Friendly and Low-Cost Multiple-Application System for Smart City Using Microcontrollers. https://doi.org/10.48550/arXiv.2010.07016

Pamarthy, S. K. (2025). AI-Powered Risk-Based Access Control: Advanced Security Framework For Modern Systems. International Journal Of Research In Computer Applications And Information Technology, 8(1), 3031–3045.

Shreehari H S., Vinolya S, Siriguppa & Varshitha (2022). Smart Attendance System based on Biometrics and Location’s Boundary Conditions. (IJERT) ICEI – 2022 (Volume 10 – Issue 11), DOI : 10.17577/IJERTCONV10IS11024

Singh, J., Rani, S., & Kumar, V. (2024). Role-Based Access Control (RBAC) enabled secure and efficient data processing framework for IoT networks. International Journal of Communication Networks and Information Security, 16(2), 19–32.

Shubham R., Avinash G., Mudaliyar R. & Pratiksha P. (2020). Industry based security system using GSM and Arduino. Volume 5 Issue 3 March 2020 ISSN (Online) 2456-0774.

Sujatha, M., Muthusamy, M., Surya, T., Ravi, K., & Reddy K. (2022). Door locking system with Arduino based on mobile authentication. IP Conference Proceedings. 2022, Vol. 2452 Issue 1, p1-10. 10p. AIP Conf. Proc. 2452, 070002 (2022). https://doi.org/10.1063/5.0118165

Vinodhini S., Gnanavarshini S., Sheryl E., & Divya Prapanjani PA. (2024). Password based Smart Doorlock System using Arduino UNO for Enhanced Security. IRO Journal on Sustainable Wireless Systems Volume 6, No. 2 (2024): 95-109. http://doi.org/10.36548/jsws.2024.2.002

Zhou, W., Jia, Y., Yao, Y., Zhu, L., Guan, L., Mao, Y., Liu, P., & Zhang, Y. (2018). Discovering and understanding the security hazards in the interactions between IoT devices, mobile apps, and clouds on smart home platforms. arXiv. arXiv:1811.03241.

Development of a Blockchain-Based Tokenization Enhancing Diploma Security, Authenticity, and Verification at Cavite State University – Trece Martires Campus

Citation

Olimpiada, A. E., & Junio, O. M. (2026). Development of a Blockchain-Based Tokenization Enhancing Diploma Security, Authenticity, and Verification at Cavite State University – Trece Martires Campus. International Journal of Research, 13(4), 150–188. https://doi.org/10.26643/ijr/edupub/18

Ariel E. Olimpiada

Faculty of the Graduate School

University of Perpetual Help System Laguna

Oliver M. Junio

Faculty of the Graduate School

University of Perpetual Help System Laguna

Abstract

There is a growing need for credible, valid, and efficient certification of diplomas. These needs have exposed some inadequacies within the current diploma management systems, which can be susceptible to forging and inefficient manual verification. This research project proposed a blockchain-enabled diploma tokenization solution that would help manage the security, validity, and verification process at Cavite State University-Trece Martires Campus.

The diploma management platform was developed according to the Input-Process-Output design model. It was developed using the Waterfall development approach. React 18, TypeScript, and TailwindCSS were the technologies used in the development of the frontend. Meanwhile, Express 5 with Passport.js was used for developing the backend. PostgreSQL was used for database management. Blockchain technology integration was done by deploying the platform on the Ethereum Sepolia test network using ethers.js. Diploma hashes were then stored on the blockchain network.

The system was assessed based on factors such as functionality, efficiency, usability, reliability, security, and safety. The outcomes were consistent in showing highly favorable scores described as “Excellent” on all criteria, meaning that the system successfully addressed both user and technical needs.

The findings revealed that blockchain technology greatly enhances the trustworthiness and verification of academic credentials. The system created through this study offers a safe, reliable, and efficient mechanism for handling diploma credentials.

Keywords: Blockchain Technology; Diploma Tokenization; Academic Credential Validation; Data Protection; Credibility; Smart Contracts; NFTs; Decentralization; Hash Function; Higher Education System; Digital Credentials; Fraud Detection; Self-Sovereign Identity (SSI); Immutable Ledger; Cavite State University

Introduction

The exponential advancements in digital technology have dramatically impacted data management techniques in numerous industries, including higher education. Modern universities often employ digital solutions in managing their academic records and other organizational processes. Nevertheless, the process of issuing and verifying diplomas has remained rather conventional and still depends on physical paper documents. Paper diplomas are easily subject to forgery, decay, loss, and the lengthy process of manual authentication. These vulnerabilities contribute to administrative inefficiencies and pose credibility concerns for educational organizations, especially considering the rising cases of credentialing fraud on a global scale (Gupta et al., 2020; Juan et al., 2023). In this regard, there is an increasing demand for safe, tamper-proof, and reliable credentialing management systems.

Blockchain technology can be regarded as a promising solution to the above-listed issues. Blockchain technology refers to a decentralized distributed ledger system that provides data with immutability, cryptographic protection, transparency, and consensus validation capabilities. After the information is confirmed and stored in the blockchain infrastructure, it becomes resistant to any unauthorized changes (Tian et al., 2020; Juan et al., 2023). Thus, blockchain appears to be highly effective in dealing with critical information like academic credentials.

Tokenization is one application of blockchain technology that refers to the process of creating digital tokens of physical and non-tangible resources within a blockchain system (Gupta et al., 2020; Freni et al., 2020). Diploma tokenization is an approach through which physical diplomas are transformed into digitally verifiable resources through the creation of digital tokens for diplomas through smart contracts. Smart contracts are blockchain-enabled mechanisms used to carry out programmed transactions upon the satisfaction of certain predefined conditions (Anderson & Park, 2022). Smart contracts can therefore be used in learning institutions to issue and verify diplomas, hence minimizing chances of errors in the manual process and ensuring record accuracy.

Despite several successful cases in international literature showing the viability of blockchain-based credential systems, most cases have only been implemented through pilots or those conducted in technologically advanced organizations (Zhuang et al., 2023; Queiroz et al., 2024). There is also a lack of empirical work regarding the creation and evaluation of blockchain-based diploma tokenization systems in higher education institutions in the Philippines. Blockchain has yet to be implemented to issue and verify diplomas in CSU-TMC and there has been no existing empirical work assessing the effectiveness of such a system using any form of standard software quality models, such as the ISO/IEC 25010 System and Software Quality Requirements and Evaluation (SQuaRE) Model.

According to many scholars, the implementation of blockchain technology can guarantee that digital documents will indeed prove to be secure and verifiable due to its unique characteristics (Gupta et al., 2020; Juan et al., 2023). It also provides efficient transaction management making it possible for blockchain technology to be used in certificate issuing systems (Buldas et al., 2022; Dutta, 2020). The self-sovereignty of identities and the use of smart contracts will allow for the autonomous control of credentials by the students.

Nevertheless, the fact that the above-mentioned research works had been conducted in international universities rather than at Philippine institutions signifies that little has been done concerning the application of such blockchain technology in the Philippines. Hence, there appears a significant discrepancy between theoretical concepts of its usage and practical application in Philippine institutions. Therefore, a proposal is to carry out an investigation on designing and testing blockchain-based tokenized diplomas at CSU-TMC.

The current research work offered designing and developing a blockchain-based tokenized diploma system with smart contracts for safe diploma token issuing and verification. There were three key concepts used in this study: security, authenticity, and verification. The former will be responsible for the issuing of the tokenized diplomas by administrators, the latter two will refer to the process of graduates’ diplomas accessing, managing, and verification by employers.

As it was mentioned before, the research will contribute significantly to the body of knowledge concerning the use of blockchain technology in educational systems by offering a localized approach to its application based on the standards presented in the ISO/IEC 25010 framework.

Theory/Manual Operation

The important feature, which characterizes the nature of the diploma tokenization based on blockchain, lies in distributed ledger technology used, where all academic diplomas will be registered, verified, and controlled with the help of decentralized and tamperproof technology. In this way, the diploma will become an electronic token, which contains key information regarding the identity of the owner of this diploma, educational program, date of graduation, as well as hash code, which is necessary to ensure the uniqueness of the document.

From the perspective of system synthesis and functioning, the process of diploma tokenization begins with encoding of the data of all graduates, who graduated from the given educational program, by the registrar. Then, the automatic generation of the digital token takes place by the system itself.

While the system integrity is maintained by the IT professionals/system administrators, they also watch out for the transactions in the blockchain network in order to see to it that everything has been done systematically without any disruptions. Meanwhile, the employers/verifiers enter the system through the verification interface where the QR code/token ID number of the credential details can be seen on the blockchain.

Generally, the process undertaken manually provides an easy flow of events from data encoding to verification of the academic credentials of the student or learner.

The operational framework illustrates how the diploma tokenization system, based on blockchain technology, works at Cavite State University – Trece Martires Campus. In the Input phase, the requirements of the entire system were gathered to identify its specifications. For the frontend, React 18, TypeScript, Vite, TailwindCSS, shadcn/ui, wouter, TanStack Query v5, and framer-motion were utilized for routing, fetching data, and creating animated UIs, respectively. As for the backend, the stack used was Express 5, Passport.js with local strategy and express session for authentication purposes. Database operations were handled with the help of PostgreSQL with Drizzle ORM for efficiency and proper structuring. Blockchain implementation entailed the utilization of Ethereum Sepolia testnet via ethers.js wherein the diploma hash was stored. Some of the features of the system include pdf export using jsPDF and jsPDF-autotable, excel export using exceljs, and qrcode creation using qrcode.react. Lastly, the hardware requirement for the project entails any computer (PC/Laptop) that can access the internet.

In terms of the procedure, the application is subjected to several steps, including Requirements gathering; System design; Implementation; Testing and Verification; Deployment; and Maintenance. This guarantees that the system will be able to handle the necessary functionalities and security measures, particularly for blockchain transactions.

Figure 1. Diploma chain operational framework

The Output phase involved developing the system for blockchain-based diploma tokenization that improves diploma security, validity, and verification in CSU-Trece Martires Campus.

Statement of the Problem

The main objective of this study was the design and development of a diploma tokenization system using blockchain technology that would enhance assurance concerning the security, authenticity, and verifiability of academic records.

This study aimed to answer the following research questions:

What problems and threats exist in the current process of diploma issuance and validation in Cavite State University – Trece Martires Campus?
What requirements must be met to provide sufficient security, authenticity, and verification for a diploma tokenization system using blockchain technology?
How should a diploma tokenization system using blockchain technology be designed and developed to resolve these problems?
How acceptable and effective is the system designed and developed from the perspective of IT specialists and end-users in terms of the ISO/IEC 25010 software quality characteristics:

4.1 Functional Suitability
4.2 Performance Efficiency

4.3 Interaction Capability
4.4 Reliability
4.5 Security and
4.6 Safety?

Assumptions of the Study

The research relied on the following assumptions:

The blockchain technology provides a secure, decentralized, and tamper-proof method of storing electronic documents.
The application of smart contracts ensures efficient and accurate issuing and verifying of diplomas.
The tokenization of diplomas in the blockchain environment increases the reliability, security, and authenticity of educational documents.
Administrators, graduates, and employers possess enough digital literacy to operate in the proposed system without any difficulties.

Scope and Delimitation

The research focused on the design and development of a blockchain diploma tokenization system for Cavite State University – Trece Martires Campus. The design aimed to mitigate the security risks associated with the management of diplomas. The functionalities of the system include issuing diplomas via smart contracts, recording the diplomas using blockchain technology, and verifying their data through token IDs. It had role-based access, which gave admin, graduates, and employers different dashboards to perform tasks such as managing, accessing, and validating data. This project was evaluated based on the ISO/IEC 25000 software quality model. The parameters included functionality, performance, usability, reliability, security, and safety.

This study was limited to Cavite State University – Trece Martires Campus only. It excluded other universities that have branches in Cavite City. It did not cover any other external academic institution either. In addition, the study involved the issuance and verification of diplomas, not transcripts of records and certificates of grades. Finally, the study mainly relied on expert validation and selective user feedback for its evaluation.

Significance of the study

Conclusions made based on the results of the research will prove to be important for many interested parties involved.

For graduates, the solution guarantees possession of the diploma without any risk of damage, since the electronic document is safely stored on the blockchain technology. In such a way, they will be able to verify their diploma anytime they need, thus improving their chances on the job market and making their education recognized.

For the University and Registrar’s Office, the new system represents a modern innovation in diploma management and issue that significantly increases its credibility and eliminates risks of falsification. Thus, the employees will be able to save time by not verifying papers manually.

For employers, other universities, and even for students themselves, the system will ensure quick and trustworthy verification of the candidate’s educational history and documents, guarantee authenticity and eliminating the risk of making a wrong choice during hiring process.

In terms of contribution to the research community, this research contributes significantly to the literature surrounding the application of blockchain technology to education, specifically in the Philippine context where concrete implementation is still in its early stages. This study provides insight on how blockchain technology can be applied locally to help solve the issues surrounding credential verification for academic purposes, which will be helpful for further research or projects.

Lastly, to the next developers or IT professionals out there, this research is an actual example of applying blockchain, tokenization, and smart contracts to academic-related activities.

Definition of Terms

For purposes of clarity and uniformity, the following terminologies were operationally and conceptually defined as used in this study. These terms emanate from the Statement of the Problem and the Research Methodology.

Authenticity implies the genuineness of a digital credential and its source issuance authority (ISO/IEC 25000, 2011). Authenticity means the degree to which the diploma token recorded on the blockchain accurately represents the graduate’s achievements and is tamper-free.

Blockchain is a technology whereby records are maintained through distributed ledgers among multiple nodes that cannot be altered retroactively (Nakamoto, 2008). In this research, blockchain is the underlying technology that facilitates storing, protecting, and validating diploma tokens.

Compatibility implies a measure of the effectiveness of a computer system in working well with other computer systems and environments without problems (ISO/IEC 25000, 2011). In this study, compatibility will be considered regarding the system functioning under diverse browser, device, and blockchain conditions.

Diploma Token implies a distinct electronic representation of an educational certification that is issued using blockchain technology. In this study, the diploma token will refer to the token generated by the smart contract, which holds the verified credentials of the student, and recorded on the blockchain ledger.

The employer or verifier is an individual or organization tasked with verifying the academic qualifications of applicants. For this research, the employer is an authorized user whose role involves verifying the authenticity of the applicant’s diploma through checking the token record via the system.

Functional Suitability is a measure of the extent to which a system possesses functionalities necessary to address explicit and implicit needs in certain circumstances (ISO/IEC 25000, 2011). For this study, it will determine how effectively the diploma token system executes its functions.

Graduates are individuals who have completed all the academic demands of an institution. In this research, graduates are former students who hold a diploma tokenized on the blockchain.

Maintainability is the ease of modification and upgrade of a system (ISO/IEC 25000, 2011). For this research, it pertains to the ability of the developers to change or update the blockchain diploma system.

Performance Efficiency is the effectiveness of system performance in terms of adequate response times and resource usage in certain conditions (ISO/IEC 25000, 2011). For this research, it pertains to transaction speed, the period it takes to issue the diplomas, and verification response time.

Portability is the measure of ease of movement of a system from one setting to another (ISO/IEC 25000, 2011). In this case, portability relates to the ease of adaptation of the system to different platforms or prospective institutional deployments.

The registrar is the officially designated department within a university that deals with academic records and the issuance of diplomas. In this study, the registrar takes on the role of the administrator that authenticates academic records and initiates the issuance of diploma tokens using smart contracts.

Reliability is the capability of the system to provide the intended function under given conditions (ISO/IEC 25000, 2011). In this study, reliability concerns the consistency and stability of the diploma issuance and verification processes.

Security is the protection of the confidentiality, integrity, and availability of information and data from threats such as breaches or tampering (ISO/IEC 25000, 2011). In this study, security relates to the cryptographic mechanisms of the blockchain platform.

A smart contract is an algorithmic mechanism embedded in the blockchain that automatically implements the terms and conditions of a predetermined rule set once certain events occur (Szabo, 1997). In this study, smart contracts automate the process of issuing and validating diplomas.

Tokenization involves changing tangible or intangible assets into digital tokens that are held and controlled using a blockchain infrastructure (Gupta et al., 2020). In this research, tokenization represents the transition of traditional paper diplomas to secure digital diplomas. Usability represents the degree to which a system can be used productively, effectively, efficiently, and satisfyingly by users (ISO/IEC 25000, 2011). In this research, usability represents the ease of use of the system by administrators, graduates, and employers.

Verification entails verifying the legitimacy of the credentials. In this research, verification represents the validation of diploma tokens through blockchain, which relies on results provided by the system.

REVIEW OF RELATED LITERATURE

The following chapter provides selected research studies and literature that will be the basis for the conceptual framework that will serve as the foundation for designing the blockchain-enabled diploma tokenization system. The selected literature includes concepts related to blockchain technology, tokenization, smart contract, non-fungible tokens (NFTs), and digital credentialing systems.

Blockchain Technology for Tokenizing and Preventing Diploma Fraud

In their research paper, Gupta et al. (2020) investigated the use of blockchain technology for real estate tokenization and identified its utility in decreasing fraud through immutable recordkeeping. Their conclusions underscore the importance of blockchain technology’s immutability and decentralized verification methods in preventing any changes to digital assets. While their study did not consider academic credentials, these two issues are similar in that diploma validation is essential.

Juan et al. (2023) similarly explored the topic of tokenized markets and argued that blockchain technology can develop secure, transparent, and efficient digital representations of tangible and intangible assets. Their analysis confirms the idea that tokenization is beneficial because it provides traceability and credibility, which is relevant in diploma tokenization programs aiming to produce permanent documentation.

Finally, Joshi and Choudhury (2022) also showed how blockchain technology decreases fraudulent behaviors by enabling reliable ownership tracking. When applying this solution to diploma authentication, it ensures that academic credentials are not falsified or duplicated.

Scalability and Infrastructure for Tokenized Systems

Nevertheless, scalability is still a key criterion for the adoption by organizations that issue vast amounts of credentials every year. Buldas et al. (2022) suggested a super-scalable framework for blockchain which can sustain high transaction volume for asset tokenization platforms. The results prove that blockchain technology can be implemented in scalable environments thus providing the ability to use the technology for university diploma storage and processing.

Tian et al. (2021) examined blockchain tokenization technology within financial infrastructures and identified two important properties of such technologies: immutability and transparency which promote trust within transactions.

Token Classification and Standardization

Freni, Ferro, & Moncada (2022) developed a morphological classification system for tokens in the blockchain. The article is pertinent to the diploma tokenization process since it outlines the steps involved in designing structured tokens. Structured tokens promote interoperability among various systems, making them more accessible to institutions and organizations.

Wang & Nixon (2021) examined the legal and theoretical underpinnings of token creation, specifically regarding smart contract security and consensus protocols. These results are crucial in ensuring that the diplomas issued via blockchain networks comply with technical and regulatory standards.

NFT-Based Credentials and Patent Developments

The recent advancements in the use of non-fungible tokens (NFTs) have made it possible to apply blockchain technology to credentials management. NFTs are non-exchangeable digital assets that uniquely identify and track ownership. In a study by Zhuang et al. (2023), it was shown that the integration of self-sovereign identity (SSI) with NFT tokenization can be used to provide users with full control and sharing capabilities over their digital credentials without having to depend on central institutions. This approach would enable decentralized ownership and authentication of diplomas.

In addition to the research, the concept of NFTs is being developed through patent filing. Patents recently filed for blockchain technologies include systems and methods to issue, store, and validate digital credentials through NFTs, which ensure authenticity and immutability. Patent filings for such innovations highlight cryptographic hash functions, distributed storage, and automated certification processes, such as diploma issuance based on smart contracts.

Wang & Lin (2021) also came up with digital badges powered by blockchain technology. The concept is almost identical to diploma tokenization since both processes seek to create permanent and verifiable digital credentials.

Smart Contracts in Academic Credentialing

Smart contracts are integral to automation within blockchain systems. Anderson & Park (2022) proposed an application of blockchain technology to automate the issuance and validation of academic credentials.

According to their results, smart contracts are effective in eliminating manual involvement, reducing human error, and enhancing operational efficiency.

Kopp & Orlovskyi (2022) also emphasized the importance of decentralization and the application of smart contracts to ensure transparency and traceability within educational credentialing systems.

Tokenization and Blockchain Tokens Classification: a morphological framework

The IEEE (2020) scholarly article gives a brief account on the application of blockchain technology to authenticate educational credentials, stating how blockchain technology is useful in developing a safe and decentralized storage method for educational credentials. According to the study, blockchain technology removes all middlemen associated with the management of these educational credentials, making it easier to authenticate them.

Review of blockchain tokens creation and valuation. Future Internet

Use of blockchain in education was reviewed by Alammary et al. (2023). From the study, it is evident that blockchain technology can be used as an efficient, trustworthy, and decentralized system for managing academic credentials. First, there is no doubt that the use of blockchain technology will guarantee maximum integrity in the system due to its immutability nature. Secondly, this kind of technology makes the process of storing and verifying academic credentials simpler and faster.

Tokenized markets using blockchain technology: Exploring recent developments and opportunities. Information

Research by Khan et al. (2023) on the application of blockchain technology to address the issue of verification of degrees in educational institutions was carried out. The authors note that traditional techniques to handle such an issue could prove time-consuming and expensive, and even fraudulent sometimes. It means that Khan et al. have proposed that employing a blockchain-enabled framework could be helpful for solving such issues.

The findings indicate that blockchain provides high-level protection to information due to the use of an immutable ledger and cryptographic hash functions. In addition, the application of this innovative technique would allow verifying degrees effectively and securely without cases of fraud.

The art of tokenization: Blockchain affordances and the invention of future milieus. Media Theory

A study carried out by HAL (2020) concerning the implementation of blockchain technology in the management and validation of academic diplomas observed that the traditional method of managing and validating credentials was inefficient, involving manual processes, delays, and vulnerability to hacking. Therefore, the authors suggested the adoption of a blockchain mechanism whereby the details of the diploma will be stored safely and cannot be altered, and there is no requirement of an intermediary authority to validate the document.

According to the research, blockchain technology fosters data integrity and transparency since the data provided cannot be tampered with. This implies that the verification process is faster and reliable for educational organizations and prospective employers, demonstrating that blockchain technology is one of the best methods for protecting academic credentials.

Token Valuation: A Systematic Literature Review and Empirical Analysis.

From the results obtained from the research carried out at Politecnico di Milano (2025), blockchain technology helps to address critical issues facing existing systems, particularly trust issues, transparency, and management issues. By using blockchain technology, a decentralized system can easily be created where smart contracts and tokens will give room for participation by users, provide increased transparency, and enhance system security. It is also clear that blockchain technology enhances system reliability since there are verifiable transactions without over-dependence on central organizations.

Thus, from this research finding, it can be stated that blockchain technology provides an effective solution to existing problems in the systems such as inefficiencies and lack of trust.

Blockchain in cultural heritage: insights from literature review. Sustainability,

According to Bucea-Manea-Țoniş et al., (2022), the application of blockchain technology would enhance the current higher education system since it would ensure that there is an assurance that there is a safe and decentralized system in the management of academic records. This is because it was found that using blockchain technology makes it certain that data would not change due to the immutability aspect of the technology.

The authors noted further that the application of blockchain technology makes it easy to validate credentials, and this does not require centralization; consequently, this makes the process swift. Indeed, the application of blockchain technology can be viewed as an effective method that can help achieve the objectives of this research.

Tokenization, blockchain and web 3.0 technologies as research objects in innovation management. International Journal of Innovation.

It could be stated that the blockchain technology is a safe way of securing academic credentials because it guarantees the protection of academic degrees against tampering. The following are some problems associated with the verification of diplomas that can be solved with the help of the blockchain technology.

Blockchain technology implies using a decentralized model, meaning that the provided data cannot be modified in any way (Caramihai & Severin, 2023). Additionally, the process of verifying credentials becomes more effective since the verification is possible independently of the institutions that issue the diploma. Smart contracts could make the process automated, reducing human interference (Chaniago et al., 2021).

Overall, blockchain enhances the protection and verification of academic credentials.

Tokenization on blockchain. In Proceedings of the 14th IEEE/ACM international conference on utility and cloud computing companion

There is a lot of research that indicated that it was possible to verify educational documents based on blockchain technology. As reported by Heredia and Barros-Gavilanes (2021), the technology provides multiple levels of verification carried out in a decentralized manner, thus implying that the process is not controlled by a particular institution.

As was seen from the study discussed earlier, the same findings can be found in the current one, as the use of blockchain ensures immutability of educational documents and instant verification, which minimizes the risks of fraud as once the document has been validated, any changes cannot be made to it. In addition, the use of smart contracts automates the entire verification procedure.

The tokenization of everything: Towards a framework for understanding the potentials of tokenized assets.

Blockchain technology has attracted considerable interest around information systems to increase trust, transparency, and verifiability in digital environments. In the context of academic credentials, centralized models have resulted in inefficiencies and vulnerabilities such as forgery of documents, delays, and other issues.

As per Dela Cruz and Ramos (2021), the systematic way of verification with distributed data implies a lesser reliance on central institutions and increased data security. Hence, blockchain could help design a safer system with decentralized verification and better data security.

Regarding the challenge of diploma validation, blockchain solutions would enable securing the documents electronically and ensuring their veracity. Accordingly, blockchain technologies could help build trust among graduates, employers, and other stakeholders and reduce administrative efforts. Based on a review of previous literature, it seems that blockchain technologies offer more efficient and safe verification methods compared to conventional approaches.

Synthesis of the Reviewed Literature

From the literature, blockchain technology can serve as a channel through which digital credentials can be stored and authenticity of such digital credentials can be verified. There is abundant literature suggesting that the blockchain technology would ensure authenticity by reducing the chances of fraud while making sure that there is transparency. Gupta et al. (2020), Juan et al. (2023) believed conceptually that through the nature of the blockchain, which is decentralization and irreversibility, security and authenticity could be ensured when managing credentials. To put differently, there is the possibility of issuance and verification of academic credentials through the blockchain technology.

Buldas et al. (2022) and Dutta (2020) also demonstrated that due to the ability of the blockchain technology to manage many transactions effectively, it becomes relevant to use it in universities where thousands of diplomas are issued. Additionally, Tian et al. (2021), and Zhuang et al. (2023) argued that self-sovereign identity and smart contracts can allow graduates to maintain ownership of their credentials while at the same time ensure authenticity and trustworthiness.

In general, there is sufficient literature available about the application of blockchain technology in providing a secure and efficient way of managing diplomas. Nonetheless, this is seen in other parts of the world. There is still a lack of studies, including application studies, regarding this approach in Philippine universities. This study aims to bridge that gap through presenting an innovative diploma tokenization platform using blockchain technology for the Cavite State University-Trece Martires Campus.

Gap/s Bridged by the Present Study

As the interest in blockchain technology continues to grow worldwide and as more people become involved in exploring its application within the context of issuing academic credentials, very few practical applications of such technology have been attempted by public universities located in the Cavite region, particularly Cavite State University – Trece Martires Campus.

Majority of existing literature pertaining to blockchain technology in academia focuses only on theoretical discussions about the use of such technology without considering the real-life problems of local students, such as diploma fraud, inefficient verification process, and accessibility issues. Because of this, the development and evaluation of blockchain technology to enhance efficiency, security, and authenticity in local universities become very necessary to be done.

RESEARCH METHODOLOGY

The method of research is discussed in this chapter whereby the researcher describes the process of data collection used to accomplish the goals of the study. It covers research design, data sources, population and sampling, research instruments, data collection and analysis.

Research Design

Descriptive developmental research was used by the researcher to develop, test, and evaluate the performance of the computer system for issuing the tokenized diploma services, thus contributing towards the improvement in the aspect of the security, authenticity, and verification of the issuance of credentials at Cavite State University-Trece Martires Campus. This kind of research is relevant for this topic as it considers not only the problems associated with the current situation regarding the issuance and verification of the diploma but also provides the practical solutions for those issues. Four steps may be expected from the organization of this study, including the following ones:

1. What problems and risks exist when it comes to the process of the issuance and verification of diplomas in the Cavite State University – Trece Martires Campus?

2. What kind of requirements must be provided for making sure that a blockchain-based diploma tokenization system would have an adequate level of security, authenticity, and verification?

3. What should be done to provide the development of the computer system based on blockchain that would solve the problems mentioned above?

4. How could the computer system developed be evaluated by the experts and tested by users?

Figure 2: Waterfall Software Methodology

The process of developing the diploma tokenization system via blockchain was carried out following the Waterfall approach, which implies linearity and sequence of the processes performed. Thus, each phase needed to be accomplished before proceeding to the next step.

Requirements Analysis. As part of the current phase, all the requirements for creating the system were gathered. Stakeholders including registrars, IT specialists, and employers were recognized at this stage and their expectations such as issuing and verification of diplomas and requirements concerning security of the system were considered. It should be noted that specific technical requirements for building the system were formulated including the use of React 18, TypeScript, Express 5, PostgreSQL, and Ethereum Sepolia testnet.

System Design. The development of the system was conducted as a web application stack, where the blockchain technology was employed. For the front-end side, architecture design has been made with React, TailwindCSS, and shadcn/ui libraries. In terms of back-end development, Express.js along with the Passport.js authentication library has been used. The database design was performed based on PostgreSQL and Drizzle ORM, whereas smart contracts were designed to store diploma hashes in Ethereum blockchain.

Implementation. The development phase in our project was conducted according to the specification created before. The front end of the system was implemented using React library and TypeScript library for back-end APIs implementation. For data storage, PostgreSQL has been used; moreover, ethers.js library has been employed for blockchain interaction purposes (with Ethereum Sepolia testnet). Additionally, the system supports PDF generating (using jsPDF) and Excel spreadsheets exporting (using exceljs).

Testing. Testing of the created application is crucial for assessing its reliability and security features. The unit testing was performed to test different API endpoints, database operations, and working with blockchain as well. Verification of correctness of registering of diploma hashes in blockchain and verification through QR codes is included in the verification process.

Deployment. Following completion of the testing process, the created product was deployed in the required environment. App production and making it available for registrars, students, and external verifiers was performed. Checking the connectivity with blockchain on the testnet was also made.

Maintenance. Maintenance of the app included providing its reliability and upgrading of the system to avoid any future problems.

System Architecture

The use case diagram highlights the Blockchain Diploma Issuance and Verification System (CvSU-TMC). This includes interaction between three key stakeholders: Registrar, student, and employer/verifier within the system. The Registrar oversees user account management and generates blockchain-based diplomas to ensure that academic documents are stored securely and are immutable. On the part of the student, he or she can create an account, view the generated diplomas, and review transaction history in the blockchain. Additionally, the student can forward diplomas to potential employers. Lastly, the employer/verifier verifies the validity of the diploma by employing either of the two approaches; one involves verifying the ID of the document while the other involves scanning of QR codes.

Figure 3. Use case diagram of development of a blockchain-based diploma

Sources of Data

The primary sources of data in this research are the stakeholders who directly engaged in the issuing and validating of the academic credentials in the university – Cavite State University, Trece Martires campus. This includes the admin whose responsibility is to maintain and certify the student’s academic records, the graduates who got tokenized diploma, and the employers who validated the credentials provided by the applicant. The feedback from these parties played an important role in determining the efficiency and effectiveness of the system being developed.

Secondary data were collected from various readings, literature, journal articles, and relevant studies on blockchain technology, tokenization, smart contracts, and blockchain technology in higher education institutions’ credentialing. These sources served as the theory and the technical aspect of the system.

Population of the Study

This study was participated in by 50 people who were purposefully selected among the Cavite State University -Trece Martires Campus and its partners. Participants comprised three categories made up of 30 graduate students, 10 university IT personnel and registrars, and 10 employers. This categorization enabled the researchers to collect feedback from all people that took part in the issuance, authentication, and utilization of the diplomas.

Purposive sampling technique was used for the selection of research participants based on specific criteria according to the objectives set for this study. The technique involved the participation of individuals who had the appropriate experience to provide valuable insights concerning the blockchain-based tokenized diplomas.

According to the research researcher, there were three main criteria for inclusion of graduate students in the study, namely: (i) recent graduation, (ii) previous exposure to academic records, and (iii) readiness to undergo the evaluation of the system. Their responses would be very important during the evaluation of the system’s usability, accessibility, and verification capabilities.

University staff / Registrars were identified based on the following criteria: (i) directly involved in diploma generation and record management processes, (ii) aware of current systems of verification processes within the institution, and (iii) ready to give their feedback regarding the efficiency of the system’s security functions.

Employer and industry stakeholders were chosen by applying three factors that included qualification verification, their work experience, and knowledge regarding digital verification of records as well as their willingness to test the system. The researchers relied on their professional knowledge and skills to test three major features of the blockchain-based diploma tokenization system, such as usability testing, authentication, and reliability evaluation.

In terms of testing, the blockchain-based diploma tokenization system was tested comprehensively due to the presence of three groups of respondents involved in the process, including end users and system implementers and verifiers of the system’s functionalities.

Instrumentation and Validation

A survey questionnaire will be used by the researcher to determine the quality and effectiveness of the smart security system based on the software quality measurement model developed by ISO/IEC 25010:2011. The instrument was specifically created to measure six major quality attributes of software products, namely: functionality, performance, interaction, reliability, security, and safety.

Instrumentation

A structured questionnaire was used as the primary research instrument for the data collection process in this study. Based on ISO/IEC 25010:2011 software quality standards, the tool had been designed to gauge the degree of the acceptability and success of the application using the six software quality characteristics such as functional suitability, performance efficiency, interaction capabilities, reliability, security, and safety. These characteristics were assessed using statement evaluations based on the Likert scale that ranged from Poor (1) to Excellent (5).

Content validation of the research tool was conducted in relation to the relevant experts depending on their specialization and designation. IT specialists (software developers) validated items addressing issues of safety, security, maintainability, compatibility, and flexibility regarding ISO/IEC 25010:2011 software quality standards. Business administrators and human resource personnel validated items addressing functional suitability, performance efficiency, compatibility, and interaction capability to prove their appropriateness in relation to business operations and security practices.

Modified Questionnaire

The revised questionnaire was created to test the newly proposed diploma verification system based on blockchain using the ISO/IEC 25010 software quality model framework. It employed a 5-point Likert scale to rate users’ opinions on various parameters including but not limited to functionality, performance, usability, reliability, and security. Other aspects such as safety were also considered. This tool enabled the researchers to examine whether the system is efficient and secure enough to meet the user expectations.

Validation

The validation of the survey tool was performed to confirm the accuracy and efficacy of the assessment of the blockchain-based diploma authentication system that was created. To do so, the modified questionnaire according to the ISO/IEC 25010 framework underwent content validity analysis by information technology specialists and system developers. The specialists assessed whether each indicator was relevant, understandable, and pertinent to the research purpose.

Improvements were made regarding the indicators’ wording, structure, and applicability according to the recommendations. The process was aimed at ensuring that all dimensions, including functional suitability, performance efficiency, usability, reliability, and security, were adequately considered.

Evaluation and Scoring

The acceptance and performance of the designed smart security system using the blockchain technology were analyzed using a Likert scale of five points, following the ISO/IEC 25010:2011 recommendations for assessing software quality. Respondents had to rate their level of agreement regarding each statement where the value 1 stood for “Poor” and the value 5 for “Excellent.”

The evaluation of the software quality in the research was performed according to six characteristics: functional suitability, performance efficiency, intractability, reliability, security, and safety. The average weight of each quality was estimated, allowing for measuring the acceptance and performance of the system under consideration. Descriptive ratings scales were applied in assessing the outcome.

Scoring Framework

This study adopted a rating methodology that made use of a five-point Likert Scale in measuring the acceptability and efficacy of the smart security system developed for the study. The individual items were rated in line with the respondents’ level of agreement with each item, and numeric scores were allocated accordingly.

Individual items were assigned ratings ranging from Poor (1) to Excellent (5). These average ratings were then interpreted using the following scale:

5 – Excellent (4.20 – 5.00)

4 –Verry Good (3.40 – 4.19)

3 – Good (2.60 – 3.39)

2 – Pair (1.80 – 2.59)

1 – Poor (1 – 1.79)

Numerical Ranges and Verbal Interpretations

The responses were categorized based on their assigned point values, as shown below:

Assigned Point	Numerical Range	Categorical Response
5	4.20 – 5.00	Excellent
4	3.40 – 4.19	Very Good
3	2.60 – 3.39	Good
2	1.80 – 2.59	Fair
1	1.00 – 1.79	Poor

Data Gathering Procedure

Three major procedures were employed in the data gathering process. These are Requirement Assessment and System Evaluation and Validation and Feedback, which were the core components of the study. The blockchain-powered diploma tokenization system was subjected to such tests to evaluate its software quality properties, such as functionality, performance, usability, reliability, security, maintainability, compatibility, and scalability, as per ISO/IEC 25010 standards. Permission to conduct the research was acquired from the Dean’s Office, where consultations were made with concerned individuals at Cavite State University-Trece Martires Campus for organizing data gathering with the help of registrars and administrators and graduates and prospective employers. Initial discussions revealed issues that hampered the issuance and verification of diplomas and record safety. These discussions provided information on system requirements that would guide the design of the blockchain tokenization system.

The researcher went ahead and developed their data gathering instruments to collect data for their research work. The researcher developed questionnaires and interviews that followed ISO/IEC 25000 guidelines for assessing the diploma tokenization system based on its features including issuance and verification mechanisms and its use of blockchain-based transactions. The instruments were professionally validated by experts working in areas such as blockchain and IT systems development as well as academics. To validate the instruments, the researchers piloted the tool by collecting data from a few individuals, and the data collected tested the tools for attributes such as clarity and reliability and relevance.

The research study adopted semi-structured interviews as the main data collection approach for collecting qualitative data related to the system performance and security as well as verification of diplomas. Interviews were conducted either face-to-face on campus or via phone for individuals unable to make themselves physically available to participate in the interviews. The Validation and Feedback phase involved the process of data collection and data analysis.

Ethical Consideration

The researcher followed proper ethical procedures for conducting research by making sure that all subjects undergoing the intelligent security system were accorded dignity, privacy, and full protection. Prior to beginning data collection, the researcher will obtain the necessary clearance from the board of researchers and first receive approval from the Cavite State University-Trece Martires City Campus.

All the participants, that is, small business owners, registrar/staff, and IT professional participated in the research on a voluntary basis. All the participants were told of the nature of the research and informed of their right to terminate their participation anytime without any form of penalty. The researcher obtained information consent from the participants before administering the questionnaires and interviews.

Confidentiality was assured during the entire course of the research. Personal data was not collected, and responses were made anonymous to protect the privacy of the subjects. The information obtained was solely for academic purposes and was kept in safe custody, available only to the researcher and academic personnel involved.

It should also be noted that the participants of the study were not put into conditions that could cause them physical, emotional, or psychological harm. Research tools will be checked for clarity and neutrality to prevent any invasive questions. Moreover, participants were chosen according to their relevance to the purpose of the study, and there is no prejudice based on age, gender, socio-economic background, or personal history.

All these principles of ethics guarantee the integrity of the study and equal treatment of participants.

Statistical Treatment of Data

A weighted mean was employed to establish the level of acceptability and usability of the software application through an ISO/IEC 25010:2011 software quality assessment model, which was comprised of the following six parameters: functionality suitability, performance efficiency, interaction capability, reliability, security, safety.

PRESENTATION, ANALYSIS, AND INTERPRETATION OF DATA

The following chapter discusses the data collected during the investigation and interprets the findings in terms of their significance with respect to the implemented blockchain-based tokenization framework used to ensure the security, validity, and authentication of the diploma certificates at Cavite State University – Trece Martires Campus. The data was gathered from experts in IT, registrar office, university graduates, and employers, considering various software quality factors.

Challenges and Risks in the Current Diploma Issuance and Verification Process

Based on the findings above, the existing diploma issuance and verification processes are manual and centralized, thus posing numerous challenges that render the process highly inefficient and insecure. First, the existing diploma issuance and verification process suffers from the potentiality of forgery and counterfeiting. The traditional paper-based diplomas fail to provide adequate measures that can protect them from being forged or counterfeited.

Secondly, because of the existence of manual methods in the issuance and verification process, there is a lot of time involved. When a request for verification is made, it requires a personal visit to the registrar who will respond after some time, thus making it very inconvenient for the requestor.

Thirdly, because of the existence of centralized data storage in the system, there exist various challenges regarding the protection of the data from any kind of losses.

System Requirements for Security, Authenticity, and Verification

Apart from the advantages of blockchain, there are other requirements that need to be addressed for the system to fulfill the demands for high security, authenticity, and verification. The requirements have been developed by considering the problems associated with the existing diploma issuance procedure.

The first requirement concerns establishing a mechanism for authentication and authorization. The introduction of this requirement implies the implementation of an authentication and authorization procedure like role-based access control. With the help of this requirement, users who have roles in the system can perform certain actions. To ensure the authenticity of the data, it is necessary to introduce a requirement to use blockchain technology in which the information about diplomas will be stored in hashed data form.

Smart contract is another requirement of the system as its use will automate the issuance and validation procedures thus reducing errors. It is also required to implement a system that includes a secure backend with the necessary features for session and database management.

Another requirement for the system concerns implementing real-time verification methods like QR code and token verification.

Design and Implementation of the Blockchain-Based Diploma Tokenization System

To address the issues related to traditional management of credentials, the authors proposed and developed the decentralized platform for blockchain diploma tokens issuance. Within this framework, the full-stack architecture model was considered, which included such components as the front-end, back-end, database, and blockchain.

For developing the front-end, react 18, TypeScript, and TailwindCSS programming languages were used. As for the back end, the authors decided to use the following libraries: Express.js and Passport.js. For storing information effectively, PostgreSQL and Drizzle ORM tools were adopted.

Moreover, for interacting with blockchain, the Ethereum Sepolia test network and ethers.js library was chosen. Furthermore, the smart contracts were created to store the hash of diplomas in the blockchain. Every document issued by the registrar became tokenized on the blockchain.

Finally, for more interactive engagement with the system, the QR code generation was realized. Thus, users would be able to check their credentials either via QR code scanning or entering a unique identifier.

Interpretation of Results

Table 1: Functional Suitability

User	Functional Suitability	Verbal Interpretation
IT Expert	4.80	Excellent
Registrar	4.80	Excellent
Employer	4.90	Excellent

An assessment of the analysis of the system’s functional suitability according to the rating provided by the IT Experts, Registrars, and Employers is presented in Table 1 below. From Table 1 above, IT Experts and Registrars gave an average score of 4.80, implying that the performance of the system is “Excellent.” Employers, on the other hand, gave the best score of 4.90, meaning the performance is “Excellent.” From the above rating, it can therefore be deduced that the system has performed well according to its functions.

Regarding the process, the IT Experts’ rating implies that the operations carried out in the back-end systems, such as validation, processing, and integration of the data were done efficiently. This therefore means that the architecture of the system was appropriate in ensuring efficient data processing. In addition, the rating of Registrars also shows that data input and validation were executed successfully, indicating that both the data encoding and validation processes were accurate.

Lastly, from the Employer rating, one can deduce that the accuracy, reliability, and authenticity of system output was good, showing that the process of delivering results to the employers was successful.

Table 2: Performance efficiency

User	Performance efficiency	Verbal Interpretation
IT Expert	4.80	Excellent
Graduates	4.83	Excellent
Employer	4.87	Excellent

Performance efficiency assessment of the system was performed by rating of IT Experts, Graduates, and Employers. The mean score obtained by IT Experts for the performance efficiency of the system is 4.80 which was regarded as “Excellent” level of performance. On similar grounds, the average scores of 4.83 and 4.87 for Graduates and Employers, respectively, were regarded as “Excellent” rating of the system in terms of performance efficiency. It is observed from the obtained results that the system had been highly efficient in performance concerning the speed and responsiveness criteria.

In terms of system process view, the “Excellent” rating from IT experts shows that the system had performed transactional requests very effectively and with minimal usage of system processes. As a result, it was observed that the system performed efficiently during all its operation processes. In case of the “Excellent” rating of graduates, it means that the system was able to perform effectively and quickly whenever users were using it.

Furthermore, the “Excellent” rating of employers indicates that the system performed effectively and quickly in generating and retrieving system outputs. To conclude, it can be stated that the system is efficient regarding its performance efficiency criterion.

Table 3: Interaction capability

User	Interaction capability	Verbal Interpretation
IT Expert	4.87	Excellent
Graduates	4.83	Excellent

The interaction capability evaluation from IT experts and graduates is presented in Table 3. From the evaluation table, it is evident that the mean score from IT experts for interaction capability is 4.87 and it can be classified as excellent while the mean score from graduates for interaction capability is 4.83 which is also excellent. Therefore, the interaction capability of the system gives the best user experience.

Considering the process of the system, the excellent interaction capability implies that the interaction capability of the system has made the process of navigation through different modules of the system easy and it is also able to give an excellent command. In this case, it means that there is excellent interaction capability which allows communication between the user and the system processes regarding the input, command, and output operations. On the other hand, the excellent rating by graduates shows that the system is easy to interact because of convenience of the interface.

To conclude, the interaction capability evaluation implies that the system has excellent interaction capability.

Table 4: Reliability

User	Reliability	Verbal Interpretation
IT Expert	4.88	Excellent
Graduates	4.78	Excellent
Registrar	4.88	Excellent

Analysis based on the reliability of the system conducted by IT Experts, Graduates, and Registrars is shown in Table 4. In particular, the average scores of IT Experts and Registrars were both 4.88, which means that the system has “Excellent” reliability. The average score of Graduates was 4.78, and thus the system also has “Excellent” reliability in their opinion. These results mean that the system could perform all its tasks properly and consistently.

From the perspective of process running in the system, the ratings given by IT Experts and Registrars confirm that the process was stable, and therefore the system behaved correctly and could successfully perform transaction, data processing, and operate consistently and without any interruptions. Additionally, such a high rate given by the Registrar indicates that the system could handle record management and verifications operations reliably.

As for Graduates, the obtained rating indicated that the system behaved correctly while working with users, which means no interruptions, stability, and correct performance during generating output. To summarize, the system demonstrated itself to be very reliable while executing all kinds of its functions.

Table 5: Security

User	Security	Verbal Interpretation
IT Expert	4.84	Excellent
Graduates	4.78	Excellent
Registrar	4.84	Excellent
Employer	4.84	Excellent

The security aspect of the system assessed by the experts of IT Professionals, Graduates, Registrars, and Employers is indicated in Table 5. IT Professionals, Registrars, and Employers reached the mean value of 4.84, and this value was considered “Excellent”. In addition, Graduates received the average score of 4.78 which was also considered “Excellent”. These results prove the fact that high security of the system was provided for various types of users and situations.

Analyzing the operation of the system, it can be stated that the security of the system is provided by the process of the system’s functioning together with the use of access control and other required procedures. Blockchain processes help ensure security of information. Consequently, this means that information was secured while being processed, stored and retrieved in the course of work.

On the other hand, considering the opinion of the graduates, the security of the system was provided at the interaction stage too. This means that users felt confident while working with the system as far as the security of information was concerned.

Table 6: Safety

User	Safety	Verbal Interpretation
IT Expert	4.90	Excellent
Graduates	5.00	Excellent
Registrar	4.90	Excellent

Evaluation of safety of the system by IT Experts, Graduates and Registrars is shown on Table 6 below. The mean rating received by IT Experts and Registrars is 4.90 (Excellent). On the other hand, Graduates had an excellent rating of 5.00 (Perfect). This implies that the system is very safe when compared to other systems in terms of user interface and processes involved.

About the safety of the system process, it was noted that the high rating of experts and registrars is attributed to the presence of proper system designs which provided security during data handling and processing within the system. This means that operational processes involving handling user data and transactions in the system have been put into consideration and are very safe.

On the contrary, the perfect rating given by graduates means that the system is extremely safe and does not have any form of risk associated with it. Hence, users did not experience any form of complications and problems when using the system processes.

SUMMARY OF FINDINGS, CONCLUSIONS, AND RECOMMENDATIONS

This chapter contains the results, conclusions, and recommendations of the study entitled “Development of Blockchain-Based Tokenization to Improve Diploma Security, Authenticity, and Verification at Cavite State University-Trece Martires Campus.” It includes the important results obtained from the analysis and the conclusions drawn from the results. Recommendations are also given based on the results and conclusions of this study.

Summary of Findings

The current research entailed designing a novel diploma tokenization blockchain system aimed at ensuring improved validity, credibility, and enhanced level of security related to corresponding diplomas. The major conclusions based on the system evaluation results should include the following ones:

First, the existing process of diplomas issuance and validation can be criticized in terms of such problems as inefficiencies including the need for the involvement of human resources leading to a higher probability of errors and a high level of risks related to the occurrence of fraudulent activities due to the nature of the existing system.

Second, based on the requirements analysis, the importance of implementing such elements of functionality and features as the use of cryptography techniques, Blockchain technology, smart contracts, role-based access control, and QR verification was revealed.

Third, during the design process, the full-stack application utilizing React, Express.js, PostgreSQL, and Ethereum Blockchain technologies was developed. This system enables efficient tokenization and storage of the hashes of the corresponding diplomas.

Finally, the evaluation results obtained by experts in Information Technologies, Registrars, Graduates, and Employers prove that all the qualities, i.e., functional suitability, performance efficiency, reliability, security, safety, and interaction capability, can be assessed as “Excellent”.

Conclusions

Taking into consideration the results obtained from the current research, there are several conclusions that can be made regarding the implementation of the diploma tokenization system using blockchain technologies at Cavite State University – Trece Martires Campus.

1. The classical model of managing academic diplomas is rather inefficient due to the presence of potential issues such as delays in processing requests, as well as risks of frauds and other issues. In this case, a new solution needs to be developed to increase effectiveness, reliability, and security.

2. The evaluation of the designed system allowed concluding about the importance of system requirements for building a reliable and efficient diploma management system. This, in turn, proved the appropriateness and effectiveness of applying blockchain technology in this situation.

3. Evaluation of the developed application revealed high-quality metrics concerning suitability, performance, interoperability, reliability, and safety of the product under analysis. Hence, it can be suggested that the system will be well-received by the target audience.

4. Blockchain technology is highly effective for improving the validity and reliability of diplomas.

Recommendations

Recommendations based on the above findings include the following:

1. System Integration within the University System. The proposed system can be integrated within the official systems used by Cavite State University-Trece Martires Campus to provide added security and efficiency to the process of diploma issuance and verification.

2. Feedback Mechanism for Users. A feedback mechanism can be incorporated in the system, which will allow the users to give suggestions and comments for system improvement.

3. System Integration with Other Institutions. This system can be expanded for cooperation with other institutions for wider coverage and better functionality.

REFERENCES

Dutta, S. K. (2020). Tokenization. In The definitive guide to blockchain for accounting and
business: Understanding the revolutionary technology (pp. 79–105). Emerald Publishing
Limited.

Farabegoli, F., & Fucile, N. (2023). Token Valuation: A Systematic Literature Review and
Empirical Analysis.

Freni, P., Ferro, E., & Moncada, R. (2020, July). Tokenization and blockchain tokens
classification: A morphological framework. In 2020 IEEE Symposium on Computers and
Communications (ISCC) (pp. 1–6). IEEE.

Freni, P., Ferro, E., & Moncada, R. (2020, July). Tokenization and Blockchain Tokens
Classification: a morphological framework. In 2020 IEEE Symposium on Computers and
Communications (ISCC) (pp. 1–6). IEEE.

Gunawan, I. K., Lutfiani, N., Aini, Q., Suryaman, F. M., & Sunarya, A. (2021). Smart contract
innovation and blockchain-based tokenization in higher education. Journal of Education
Technology, 5(4), 636–644.

Gupta, A., Rathod, J., Patel, D., Bothra, J., Shanbhag, S., & Bhalerao, T. (2020). Tokenization of
real estate using blockchain technology. In Applied cryptography and network security
workshops (pp. 77–90). Springer.

Gutierrez, A. (2023). Tokenizing college courses using the XRPL blockchain (Doctoral
dissertation, Manhattan College).

Heines, R., Dick, C., Pohle, C., & Jung, R. (2021). The tokenization of everything: Towards a
framework for understanding the potentials of tokenized assets.

International Organization for Standardization. (2019). ISO/IEC 25020:2019 Systems and
software engineering — Systems and software quality requirements and evaluation
(SQuaRE) — Quality measurement framework. ISO.

Joshi, S., & Choudhury, A. (2022). Tokenization of real estate assets using blockchain.
International Journal of Intelligent Information Technologies, 18(3), 1–12.

Juan, A. A., Perez-Bernabeu, E., Li, Y., Martin, X. A., Ammouriova, M., & Barrios, B. B. (2023).
Tokenized markets using blockchain technology: Exploring recent developments and
opportunities. Information, 14(6), 347.

Lotti, L. (2019). The art of tokenization: Blockchain affordances and the invention of future
milieus. Media Theory, 3(1), 287–320.

Marin, O., Cioara, T., Toderean, L., Mitrea, D., & Anghel, I. (2023). Review of blockchain
tokens creation and valuation. Future Internet, 15(12), 382.

Queiroz, B. A., Westphall, J., & Martina, J. E. (2024, September). Badges as a gamification tool
in higher education through tokenization. In 2024 IEEE Biennial Congress of Argentina
(ARGENCON) (pp. 1–6). IEEE.

Rani, P., Sachan, R. K., & Kukreja, S. (2023). Academic payment tokenization: An online
payment system for academia utilizing non-fungible tokens and permissionless blockchain.
Procedia Computer Science, 230, 347–356.

SCAFUTO, I. C. (2022). Tokenization, blockchain and web 3.0 technologies as research objects
in innovation management. International Journal of Innovation.

Son-Turan, S. (2023). Tokenization and NFTs: A tokenized income sharing model for higher
education as a potential solution for student debt in the USA. In Crowdfunding in higher
institutions: Theory and best practices (pp. 145–158). Springer International Publishing.

Tian, Y., Lu, Z., Adriaens, P., Minchin, R. E., Caithness, A., & Woo, J. (2020). Finance
infrastructure through blockchain-based tokenization.

Vacchio, E. D., & Bifulco, F. (2022). Blockchain in cultural heritage: insights from literature
review. Sustainability, 14(4), 2324.

Wang, G., & Nixon, M. (2021, December). SoK: Tokenization on blockchain. In Proceedings of
the 14th IEEE/ACM International Conference on Utility and Cloud Computing Companion
(pp. 1–9).

Daily writing prompt

Who are some underrated people in history?

View all responses

Design And Implementation of a Blockchain-Based Certificate Management System for the Office of the Registrar of Cavite State University – Trece Martires City Campus

Citation

Barabat, M., & Junio, O. (2026). Design And Implementation of a Blockchain-Based Certificate Management System for the Office of the Registrar of Cavite State University – Trece Martires City Campus. International Journal of Research, 4(13). https://doi.org/10.26643/ijr/edupub/17

Marjorie Barabat, Oliver Junio

c1-241-02095@uphsl.edu.ph, omj@uphsl.edu.ph

University of Perpetual Help System Laguna

Abstract

It is essential for educational institutions to possess efficient, transparent, and dependable administrative services that manage student information and certificates. The Office of the Registrar is responsible for maintaining confidential records, including grades, registration details,

and certificates. However, when these offices are required to perform tasks manually and on paper, they encounter numerous challenges. Traditional methods frequently result in errors, delays, and susceptibility to tampering, thereby diminishing the reliability of academic records and impeding

service delivery. At Cavite State University—Trece Martires City Campus, computer systems remain incompatible, and certificates continue to be distributed manually. Emerging technologies

such as web-based tracking, automation, and blockchain have been considered potential solutions;

however, options remain limited at present. Typically, they concentrate on one aspect or the other,

but never concurrently.

Smart contracts, blockchain technology, and the idea of making computers run themselves are what the answer is based on. Three things work together to keep them safe and healthy. The blockchain is what the system is built on. Student records are safe from fraud and cannot make any changes since this is under the use of blockchain, tampering credentials is not accessible in this system. This system assures the user that they process the request for the right owner of the credentials. It also easier to do administrative tasks, it lessens the manual work for the registrar employee all the process is automated, faster work and more accurate process. The Registrar’s Office can add information of the students to process the request of the certificates in blockchain- based certificate management system since it is the safe way to get the request of the student. On the blockchain check credentials quickly and since the system are created with blockchain, smart contracts, and automation, the certificates cannot be tampered. It will gain more trust to the university transaction in terms of releasing student credentials. The risk of fake certificates goes down, and it easier for students and employers to check them and it helps Cavite State University – Trece Martires City Campus to have a better manage certificates.

The ISO/IEC 25010:2011 software quality model was utilized to thoroughly evaluate the system, with feedback gathered from students, registrar staff, and IT experts. As anticipated, the acceptance scores remained high, falling within the “Excellent” range. The system received an average score of 4.85 from students, indicating that it performed well in terms of user interaction, safety, and security. However, it could benefit from the ability to integrate with other systems and adapt to changing circumstances. Registrar employee rating the system with a high average score of 4.96, reflecting their strong approval. They rated it highly in safety, dependability, functionality, and performance, suggesting confidence that it would enhance operational efficiency at the institution. IT experts provided a mean score of 4.95, praising its safety, security, ease of maintenance, and flexibility. They proposed strategies to improve its functionality and performance. A Cronbach’s alpha of 0.870 indicates that the evaluation tool demonstrates high reliability, making it trustworthy. Overall, the results affirm that the blockchain-based certificate management system is safe, reliable, and effective. Consequently, it is suitable for immediate implementation in educational institutions to meet their long-term needs.

The results indicate that the blockchain-based certificate management system is a reliable, secure, and effective method for tracking academic records and digital credentials. It effectively meets user needs by ensuring that the processes for issuing and verifying certificates are accurate, transparent, and difficult to alter. This technology safeguards records against unauthorized changes, thereby enhancing data integrity. Additionally, it streamlines and accelerates transactions

at the Registrar’s Office, increasing overall efficiency. The consistently high ratings from students,

registrar staff, and IT experts demonstrate a strong confidence in its functionality, user- friendliness, and technical performance. This overwhelmingly positive feedback suggests that the system is both practical and suitable for real-world application. In summary, the results indicate that the system is ready for implementation in educational institutions, with opportunities for continued improvement to maintain its usefulness, adaptability, and reliability over time.

Introduction

The study emphasizes the critical role of efficient, transparent, and secure management of academic records and certificates in higher education institutions. It identifies the Office of the Registrar as the central unit responsible for handling sensitive student data, including grades and credentials. However, traditional paper-based and manual processes remain prevalent, leading to inefficiencies, delays, human errors, and vulnerability to document tampering. These issues are particularly evident at Cavite State University – Trece Martires City Campus, where limited system integration and reliance on manual workflows hinder effective certificate management.

The introduction highlights emerging technologies—such as web-based systems, automation, and blockchain—as potential solutions to these challenges. Prior studies suggest that while these technologies improve accuracy, efficiency, and security, existing implementations often address only isolated aspects rather than providing a comprehensive solution. Blockchain technology, in particular, is recognized for its decentralized and immutable nature, enabling secure, tamper-proof, and transparent verification of academic credentials while reducing reliance on intermediaries.

Despite these advancements, a gap persists in the local implementation of integrated blockchain-based certificate management systems. The study addresses this gap by proposing the design and implementation of a blockchain-based system tailored to the university’s needs. The proposed system aims to automate certificate issuance, enhance data security, prevent forgery, and improve overall administrative efficiency. Ultimately, the research seeks to modernize academic record management, strengthen trust among stakeholders, and provide a reliable, secure, and efficient mechanism for issuing and verifying academic credentials.

The system follows an Input–Process–Output (IPO) operational model, where inputs such as student data, certificate templates, and academic requirements are processed through system development phases (planning, analysis, design, testing, and deployment) using a structured methodology, resulting in outputs that include automated, blockchain-secured certificates and a reliable verification mechanism accessible to stakeholders. This integrated approach aims to modernize academic record management, reduce administrative burdens, prevent fraud, and strengthen trust among students, institutions, and external verifiers.

METHODOLOGY

This part presents the research methodology employed in the study, focusing on the systematic processes used to design, develop, and evaluate the proposed blockchain-based certificate management system. The study adopts a descriptive-developmental research design, which is appropriate as it not only examines existing issues in certificate management but also develops a technological solution. The research is structured into three major phases: first, analyzing the current practices of the Registrar’s Office; second, designing and developing the blockchain-based system using smart contracts; and third, evaluating the system through expert validation and user testing to determine its effectiveness and usability.

The system development follows the Waterfall Software Development Methodology, ensuring a structured and sequential approach. This includes analysis of system requirements, design of system architecture and user interface, implementation through coding and blockchain integration, testing using the ISO/IEC 25010:2011 software quality model, deployment within the Registrar’s Office, and continuous maintenance for improvements. This step-by-step process ensures that the system is thoroughly planned, tested, and aligned with institutional needs, resulting in a secure, efficient, and reliable certificate management solution.

The study utilizes both primary and secondary data sources. Primary data are gathered from key stakeholders, including registrar employees, students, and IT experts, who serve as system users and evaluators. A total of 30 participants are selected using purposive sampling to ensure relevant expertise and experience. Secondary data are obtained from existing literature on blockchain, smart contracts, and digital credentialing, providing theoretical and technical support for system development. Data collection is conducted through structured questionnaires designed to assess usability, functionality, and technical performance of the system.

To evaluate the system, the study employs a validated survey instrument based on the ISO/IEC 25010:2011 software quality model, covering key attributes such as functionality, performance efficiency, usability, reliability, security, maintainability, compatibility, flexibility, and safety. Responses are measured using a five-point Likert scale, and the results are analyzed using weighted mean scores to determine overall acceptability and effectiveness. The evaluation process ensures a comprehensive assessment of both user experience and technical quality, confirming the system’s readiness for implementation in an academic environment.

Results and Discussion

This part presents the results and interpretation of data gathered from students, registrar employees, and IT experts regarding the developed blockchain-based certificate management system. The results reveal that the existing practices in the Registrar’s Office are largely manual, characterized by paper-based processing, delays, inefficiencies, and vulnerability to errors and document tampering. These findings validate the need for a more secure, automated, and integrated system. The developed blockchain-based solution directly addresses these issues by introducing automation, secure data handling, and a transparent verification mechanism, thereby improving both administrative processes and user experience.

The evaluation of the system shows a very high level of acceptability among end users. Students rated the system with a mean score of 4.85, indicating excellent performance in usability, security, and interaction capability. Registrar employees provided an even higher mean score of 4.96, reflecting strong agreement on its effectiveness in improving efficiency, reliability, and operational performance. These results suggest that the system successfully meets user expectations by simplifying certificate requests, reducing manual workload, and ensuring faster and more accurate processing of academic credentials.

From a technical perspective, IT experts also evaluated the system positively, assigning a mean score of 4.95. The system was highly rated in terms of security, maintainability, flexibility, and overall system integrity. Experts confirmed that the integration of blockchain technology and smart contracts effectively ensures data immutability, prevents unauthorized modifications, and enables secure and transparent verification of certificates. However, they also recommended further enhancements, particularly in system integration and scalability, to improve adaptability to future institutional requirements.

Statistically, the overall evaluation demonstrates strong reliability and consistency. The use of the ISO/IEC 25010:2011 software quality model and a five-point Likert scale allowed for systematic measurement of system performance across multiple criteria. The computed Cronbach’s alpha value of 0.870 indicates high internal consistency of the evaluation instrument, confirming that the results are reliable and dependable. The consistently high weighted mean scores across all respondent groups fall within the “Excellent” range (4.20–5.00), validating the system’s effectiveness, usability, and security. Overall, the statistical analysis supports the conclusion that the blockchain-based certificate management system is a robust, efficient, and ready-for-implementation solution for improving academic record management.

Conclusion

The findings confirm that the Blockchain-Based Certificate Management System is a dependable, secure, and efficient solution for managing academic records and digital credentials. It successfully addresses user needs by delivering accurate, transparent, and tamper-resistant processes for certificate issuance and verification. The system further strengthens data integrity by safeguarding records against unauthorized modification, while enhancing operational efficiency in the registrar’s office through faster and more streamlined transactions.

Furthermore, the high level of acceptance from students, registrar employees, and IT experts demonstrates strong confidence in its functionality, usability, and technical performance. This collective positive assessment indicates that the system is both practical and suitable for real-world application. Overall, the results suggest that the system is ready for institutional deployment, with opportunities for further enhancement to sustain effectiveness and adaptability over time.

Recommendations

Based on the findings, several recommendations are proposed to further enhance the system. Although the blockchain-based certificate management system received excellent ratings overall, improvements in interaction and user experience are suggested, particularly since students gave a slightly lower score (4.73) for interaction capability. Enhancing the user interface by simplifying navigation, improving visual clarity, and incorporating more user-friendly features can make the system easier and more intuitive to use. In addition, strengthening system maintainability is essential through regular updates, comprehensive documentation, and established maintenance procedures to ensure smooth operation and easier troubleshooting.

To sustain the system’s reliability, it is also important to maintain strong security measures by conducting regular audits, vulnerability assessments, and continuous system monitoring to safeguard academic records and certificates. Furthermore, providing training sessions for both students and registrar staff will help ensure effective system utilization, while establishing a feedback mechanism will allow users to report issues and suggest improvements. By implementing these measures, the institution can further enhance the system’s performance, usability, and sustainability, ensuring its long-term effectiveness in securing and managing academic credentials.

References:

Alharby, M., & van Moorsel, A. (2017). Blockchain-based smart contracts: A systematic mapping study. arXiv preprint arXiv:1710.06372. https://arxiv.org/abs/1710.06372

Andrade, A. J. E., & Amate, F. C. (2024). A smart contract based application for certificate issuance and student verification. arXiv preprint arXiv:2401.12345.

Akinnifesi, A. S., & Balogun, J. M. (2025). Design and implementation of a blockchain-based certificate verification system for secure academic credential authentication. University of Ibadan Journal of Science and Logics in ICT Research, 15(1), 209–218.

Bhumichitr, K., & Channarukul, S. (2021). AcaChain: Academic credential attestation system using blockchain. In Proceedings of the 18th International Joint Conference on Computer

Science and Software Engineering (JCSSE) (pp. 1–6). IEEE. https://doi.org/10.1109/JCSSE53117.2021.9441077

Castro, R. Q., & Au-Yong-Oliveira, M. (2021). Blockchain and higher education diplomas. European Journal of Investigation in Health, Psychology and Education, 11(1), 154–167.

https://doi.org/10.3390/ejihpe11010013

DIAR: A blockchain-based system for generation and verification of academic diplomas. (2021). Discover Applied Sciences. SpringerLink.

Gao, Y., Xu, L., Chen, L., & Shi, W. (2020). SmartCert: Redesigning digital certificates with smart contracts. In 2020 IEEE International Conference on Blockchain (Blockchain) (pp. 226– 233). IEEE. https://doi.org/10.1109/Blockchain50366.2020.00036

Getz, D., & Page, S. J. (2016). Event studies: Theory, research and policy for planned events (3rd ed.). Routledge. https://www.routledge.com/Event-Studies-Theory-Research-and-Policyfor-Planned-Events/Getz-Page/p/book/9781138024080

International Journal of Applied Information Systems. (2023). Utilizing blockchain technology for university certificate verification systems. IJAIS.

https://www.ijais.org/archives/volume12/number3/1234-2023

Jenifer, A., Mahadik, P., Sanskar, S., Gupta, T., & Meshram, Y. (2024). Certificate issuing and verification application using blockchain. International Journal of Software Computing and Testing, 10(1), 12–20.

Kistaubayev, Y., Mutanov, G., Mansurova, M., Saxenbayeva, Z., & Shakan, Y. (2023). Ethereumbased information system for digital higher education registry and verification of student achievement documents. Future Internet, 15(1), 3. https://doi.org/10.3390/fi15010003

Liu, M. (2021). A hybrid blockchain-based event ticketing system (Master’s thesis, University of Saskatchewan). University of Saskatchewan. https://harvest.usask.ca/handle/10388/13456

Nakamoto, S. (2008). Bitcoin: A peer-to-peer electronic cash system.

Click to access bitcoin.pdf

Oluwaseyi, O. S., & Akinyede, R. O. (2024). Utilizing blockchain technology for university certificate verification system. International Journal of Applied Information Systems, 12(45), 23–40. https://doi.org/10.5120/ijais2024451977

Páez, J., Pérez, M., Ramírez, G., & Montes, J. (2020). An architecture for biometric electronic identification document system based on blockchain. Future Internet, 12(1), 10.

https://doi.org/10.3390/fi12010010

Patil, R. V., & Kolhe, T. D. (2022). Blockchain-based academic certificate verification system. International Journal of Progressive Research in Engineering Management and Science.

https://doi.org/10.58257/IJPREMS43889

Prasad Reddy, P., Srinivas, R., Raghavendran, C. V., Lalitha, R., & Annapurna, B. (2021). A zeroknowledge proof-enabled blockchain based academic record verification system. EURASIP Journal on Information Security. MDPI.

Raimundo, R., & Rosário, A. (2021). Blockchain applications in higher education: Enhancing security, transparency, and trust in academic credentials. Education Sciences, 11(1), 21.

https://www.mdpi.com/2254-9625/11/1/21 (mdpi.com in Bing)

Ravikumar, G., Venkatachalam, K., Masud, M., & Abouhawwash, M. (2022). Cost efficient scheduling using smart contract cognizant Ethereum for IoMT. Intelligent Automation & Soft Computing, 33(2), 865–877. https://doi.org/10.32604/iasc.2022.021407

Rennock, M., et al. (2018). Blockchain technology and regulatory investigations. Steptoe & Johnson LLP. https://www.steptoe.com/a/web/171967/LITFebMar18-FeatureBlockchain.pdf

Saeed, M., Alharbi, A., Ullah, I., & Alkhaldi, A. (2023). Blockchain-powered education: A sustainable approach for secured and connected university systems. Sustainability, 15(3), 2104. https://doi.org/10.3390/su15032104

Shinde, S., Myanewa, I. R., Nimbal, S., & Randhir, H. (2025). Blockchain-based academic credential verification system. International Journal of Engineering Research & Technology (IJERT), 14(1), 1–8. https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.18114880

Soni, P., Kaur, S., Shukla, H., Kumar, S., & Kumar, A. (2023). Blockchain-based system for managing educational event registrations. ResearchGate. https://www.researchgate.net/publication/371234567

Srinivasarao, N., Devakinandan, P., Srujan, S., & Kaliyamurthie, K. P. (2022). Event ticket management with blockchain implementation. Bharath Institute of Science & Technology.

Srinivasarao, N., Reddy, S., & Prasad, V. (2022). Event ticket management with blockchain implementation. ResearchGate. https://www.researchgate.net/publication/360123456

Sriram, R., Kumar, S., & Ahmed, F. (2025). Enhancing digital identity and access control in event management using blockchain. UAE University Research Publications.

https://research.uaeu.ac.ae/en/publications/enhancing-digital-identity-and-access-controlin-event-management

Daily writing prompt

What are the biggest benefits of minimalist living?

View all responses

Citation

Keywords: reading, pre-reading activities, reading comprehension, achievements.

Introduction

Background and Statement of the Problem

Scope of the Study

Literature Review

Effects of Pre-Reading Activities on Students ’Reading Comprehension

Importance of Pre-Reading Activities to Students’ Achievement

Method and Procedure

Design, Population and Sample

Procedure

Administration of the Treatment

Administration of Post-Test

Analyses

Table 1: The Pre-test and Post-test Literal Comprehension Achievement Mean scores of SS II students in the Experimental and Control Groups

Table 2: The Pre-test and Post-test Inferential Comprehension Achievement Mean Scores of SS II Students in the Experimental and Control Groups

Hypotheses Hypothesis One

Table 3: ANCOVA Result on Pretest and Posttest Literal Comprehension Achievement Mean Scores of SSII Students in the Experimental and Control Groups

Table 4: ANCOVA Result on Pretest and Posttest Inferential Comprehension Achievement Mean Scores of SSII Students in the Experimental and Control Groups

Discussion

References

Rate this:

Citation

2.3.4 Autoregressive integrated moving average (ARIMA) model

Rate this:

Citation

Rate this:

Citation

Rate this:

Rate this:

Rate this:

Everything you need to know to build a thriving online teaching career in India — from registration to earning your first ₹10,000 a month.

Introduction

Why Online Teaching Is One of the Best Work-From-Home Opportunities in India

Who Can Become an Online Tutor in India?

Step-by-Step: How to Register as a Tutor on UrbanPro

Step 1 — Create Your Tutor Profile

Step 2 — Add Your Qualifications and Experience

Step 3 — Set Your Availability and Fees

Step 4 — Respond Quickly to Enquiries

Step 5 — Deliver Outstanding Demo Classes

Top Categories in Highest Demand on UrbanPro (2026)

How Much Can You Earn as an Online Tutor in India?

Pro Tips to Grow Your Online Teaching Business

Conclusion

Rate this:

Rate this:

Rate this:

Rate this:

Rate this:

Citation

Rate this:

Rate this:

Citation

Numerical Ranges and Verbal Interpretations

Rate this:

Citation

Rate this: